Section XLIV · Location 44 of 80
Section 44 · Open to readFrom Summa Theologica by Saint Thomas Aquinas
Edition: Summa Theologica, Second Part of the Second Part, Questions 141–170: Treatise on Temperance, trans. Fathers of the English Dominican Province (1922)
Second Part of the Second Part — Humility, Pride, Adam's First Sin, Studiousness, Curiosity, Outward Modesty, and the Precepts of Temperance (Questions 161–170)
Summa Theologica · Chapter 44 summary
Humility restrains the mind from tending immoderately to high things. It is the foundation of the spiritual life in the sense that it clears away pride so grace can flow in. True humility does not require a person to believe falsely that he is the worst sinner. However, to recognize that all he has of himself is nothingness and defect. At the same time, all good comes from God.
Atlas of Saints wrote this summary of section 44 of Summa Theologica by Saint Thomas Aquinas. It uses our own words. It is not a quotation from the book.
Cite this summary
Atlas of Saints. “Second Part of the Second Part — Humility, Pride, Adam's First Sin, Studiousness, Curiosity, Outward Modesty, and the Precepts of Temperance (Questions 161–170)” Summary of Summa Theologica, by Saint Thomas Aquinas. https://www.atlasofsaints.com/writings/summa-theologica/chapters/44#atlas-answer
Section breakdown
The concluding ten questions of the volume examine the four species of modesty (above all humility and studiousness) alongside their opposing vices. Humility (Question 161) is the virtue that restrains the appetite from aiming immoderately at high things above one's measure, grounded in reverence for God. Charity and the theological virtues are greater in absolute perfection. Even so, humility is the foundation of the spiritual edifice. This is because it removes pride, the obstacle to grace, across Saint Benedict's twelve degrees. Pride (Questions 162–165) is the inordinate appetite for one's own excellence, the queen and beginning of all sins. Our first parents in Paradise sinned first by pride in desiring likeness to God in knowledge of good and evil by their own natural power, incurring mortality and original sin. Finally, Questions 166–170 contrast studiousness—moderating the desire for knowledge according to duty and charity—with curiosity, and examine modesty in outward gesture, necessary recreation (`eutrapelia`), and simple dress.
In Questions 161–162, Thomas Aquinas defines humility as the virtue that restrains the appetite from tending immoderately to high things out of reverence for God. Moreover, he analyzes Saint Gregory's four species of pride. In Question 161, humility expels pride and opens the soul to receive divine grace, as shown in the parable of the Publican and the Pharisee. In Questions 163–165, Aquinas proves that the first sin of Adam and Eve was pride (desiring spiritual likeness to God in knowing good and evil by their own power) which forfeited the gift of original justice and subjected humanity to death and concupiscence.
In Question 164, Adam's rebellion against God's command resulted in the rebellion of the lower flesh against human reason. In Questions 166–170, Aquinas contrasts studiousness with curiosity (which errs by pride, neglect of duty, or prying into forbidden things), defends virtuous recreation (`eutrapelia`) for resting the mind, and establishes modesty in dress. Question 168 sets forth the three rules of virtuous recreation (eutrapelia). This involves avoiding shameful words or deeds, keeping gravity of soul, and fitting the time, place, and person. Studiousness orders the pursuit of knowledge to useful truth and edification. At the same time, recreation (`eutrapelia`) gives the weary soul needed rest just as unbending a bow preserves its spring.
The story inside
Some stern moralists in the early Church claimed that all joking, games, and playful recreation are sinful wastes of time. In Question 168, Article 2, Aquinas answers them with a famous story from the Conferences of Cassian about the Apostle Saint John the Evangelist. A hunter was scandalized to find the aged Apostle gently playing with a tame partridge. In response, John pointed to the bow in the hunter's hand. In addition, he asked why he did not carry it with the string always drawn tight. The hunter replied that if a bow is kept bent all the time, it loses its spring and cannot shoot when needed. 'So too', John answered, 'if the human mind is never relaxed by moderate rest, it breaks under the strain.' Aquinas concludes that just as the body needs sleep, the soul needs cheerful, innocent recreation (`eutrapelia`) to refresh its strength for spiritual work. Moderate, innocent recreation is not a sin. However, a moral virtue that restores the mind's energy for serious duty and contemplation.
Lessons worth keeping
- 1
Humility restrains the mind from tending immoderately to high things. It is the foundation of the spiritual life in the sense that it clears away pride so grace can flow in.
- 2
True humility does not require a person to believe falsely that he is the worst sinner. However, to recognize that all he has of himself is nothingness and defect. At the same time, all good comes from God.
- 3
Pride (the inordinate desire to excel above the rule of God) was the first sin of Adam and Eve. He wished to determine good and evil by their own natural power.
- 4
Studiousness orders the pursuit of knowledge to useful truth and edification. At the same time, recreation (`eutrapelia`) gives the weary soul needed rest just as unbending a bow preserves its spring.
Test your recall
How can a holy person sincerely esteem every neighbor as better than himself without telling a lie in his own mind?
Answer from memory first. Then check the summary and lessons above.
Notes & sources
3 notesFrom Summa Theologica, Second Part of the Second Part, Questions 141–170: Treatise on Temperance, trans. Fathers of the English Dominican Province (1922). Line numbers show where each passage appears in the digitized text.
- 1.Lines 9876–9879
“We must consider next the species of modesty: (i) Humility, and pride which is opposed to it; (2) Studiousness, and its opposite, Curiosity: (3) Modesty as affecting words or deeds: (4) Modesty as affecting outward attire.”
- 2.Lines 11411–11413
“Obj. 2. Further, It is written (Ecclus. x. 14) that the beginning of... pride is to fall off from God. Therefore falling away from God precedes pride.”
- 3.Lines 12244–12246
“Obj. 2. Further, That which pertains to a person's dignity does not, seemingly, pertain to his punishment. But the multiplying of conceptions pertains to a woman's dignity.”
