Section XXXI · Location 31 of 80
Section 31 · Open to readFrom Summa Theologica by Saint Thomas Aquinas
Edition: Summa Theologica, Second Part of the Second Part, Questions 47–79: Treatise on Prudence and Justice, trans. Fathers of the English Dominican Province (1918)
Second Part of the Second Part — Vices Against Distributive and Commutative Justice in Deeds and Courts of Law: Respect of Persons, Murder, Theft, and Courtroom Injustice (Questions 63–71)
Summa Theologica · Chapter 31 summary
Respect of persons sins against distributive justice by conferring public or Church offices based on favoritism or wealth rather than fitness for the office. It is never lawful to kill an innocent person. Nor may anyone take his own life. This is because life belongs to God and the community. Lawful self-defense uses only proportionate force to save one's life.
Atlas of Saints wrote this summary of section 31 of Summa Theologica by Saint Thomas Aquinas. It uses our own words. It is not a quotation from the book.
Cite this summary
Atlas of Saints. “Second Part of the Second Part — Vices Against Distributive and Commutative Justice in Deeds and Courts of Law: Respect of Persons, Murder, Theft, and Courtroom Injustice (Questions 63–71)” Summary of Summa Theologica, by Saint Thomas Aquinas. https://www.atlasofsaints.com/writings/summa-theologica/chapters/31#atlas-answer
Section breakdown
Aquinas had established the nature of justice. Therefore, he examines the sins opposed to distributive and commutative justice in deeds and in judicial proceedings. Opposed to distributive justice is 'respect of persons' (acceptio personarum), which awards public offices or spiritual benefices out of favoritism or family ties rather than merit for the common good. Opposed to commutative justice in deeds are murder (wherein taking an innocent human life is never lawful for any private person or public authority, and self-defense is lawful only when moderated without the direct intention to kill, while suicide wrongs the person, the community, and God), bodily mutilation, and theft or robbery. Even so, in extreme, urgent necessity where life is in immediate danger, taking food to survive is not theft. This is because in extreme need all material goods become common. Finally, in courts of law, justice binds the judge, the accuser, the defendant, the witness, and the advocate to serve the truth.
In Question 63, Thomas Aquinas defines respect of persons (`acceptio personarum`) as the sin against distributive justice that awards public or ecclesiastical offices for reasons extraneous to a candidate's fitness for the common good. Question 64 opens the inquiry into homicide, contrasting man's lawful use of plants and animals with the inviolability of innocent human life. In Questions 64–66, Aquinas proves that suicide and killing the innocent are intrinsically unlawful, formulates the principle of double effect for proportionate self-defense (Question 64, Article 7). Establishes that while private ownership is lawful for orderly administration, in extreme necessity all material goods are common so that taking bread to save life is not theft.
Question 66 analyzes theft and robbery, showing how extreme necessity excuses taking what is needed to sustain life. In Questions 67–71, Aquinas sets forth the ethics of the courtroom. A judge acts as a public person who must judge according to proved public evidence. He also may never remit the injured party's right. Witnesses must testify truthfully without perjury. Advocates must refuse to defend knowingly unjust suits. Question 70 explains why courtroom justice requires the corroborating testimony of two or three reliable witnesses. In a court of law, a judge must judge according to the public evidence presented rather than private personal knowledge. An advocate sins gravely if he knowingly defends an unjust cause.
The story inside
Two of the most famous principles in moral philosophy and law come from Questions 64 and 66 of this volume. First, in Question 64, Article 7, Aquinas asks whether a private person may kill an attacker in self-defense. He answers that one single act can have two effects—one intended (saving one's own life) and the other beside the intention (the attacker's death)—provided the defender uses no more force than necessary. Second, in Question 66, Article 7, he asks whether a starving person who takes another's bread commits theft. He answers that human law concerning private property cannot override natural law, according to which inferior goods are made to sustain human life. Therefore, in urgent and manifest necessity, need makes all goods common. Human law and property exist to serve human life and the common good, never to destroy the innocent.
Lessons worth keeping
- 1
Respect of persons sins against distributive justice by conferring public or Church offices based on favoritism or wealth rather than fitness for the office.
- 2
It is never lawful to kill an innocent person. Nor may anyone take his own life. This is because life belongs to God and the community. Lawful self-defense uses only proportionate force to save one's life.
- 3
Private property is lawful and necessary for peaceful order. However, as to the use of goods in extreme, life-threatening necessity, all things are common.
- 4
In a court of law, a judge must judge according to the public evidence presented rather than private personal knowledge. An advocate sins gravely if he knowingly defends an unjust cause.
Test your recall
Why does Aquinas distinguish between the ownership of external goods and their use?
Answer from memory first. Then check the summary and lessons above.
Notes & sources
3 notesFrom Summa Theologica, Second Part of the Second Part, Questions 47–79: Treatise on Prudence and Justice, trans. Fathers of the English Dominican Province (1918). Line numbers show where each passage appears in the digitized text.
- 1.Lines 9096–9099
“We must now consider the vices opposed to the aforesaid parts of justice. First we shall consider respect of persons which is opposed to distributive justice: secondly we shall consider the vices opposed to commutative justice.”
- 2.Lines 10770–10772
“Now the widow and the orphan are not connected with other persons. Therefore the sin is not aggravated through an injury being inflicted on one who is connected with others.”
- 3.Lines 12135–12137
“Ohj. 3. Further, No man is bound to act against the fidelity which he owes his friend; because he ought not to do to another what he would not have others do to him.”
