Skip to content
Atlas of Saints

Summa Theologica

Section 32 · Saint Thomas Aquinas

Section XXXII · Location 32 of 80

Section 32 · Open to read

From Summa Theologica by Saint Thomas Aquinas

Edition: Summa Theologica, Second Part of the Second Part, Questions 47–79: Treatise on Prudence and Justice, trans. Fathers of the English Dominican Province (1918)

Second Part of the Second Part — Extra-Judicial Injuries in Words, Fraud in Buying and Selling, Usury, and the Integral Parts of Justice (Questions 72–79)

Summa Theologica · Chapter 32 summary

A person's good name is the most precious of external possessions, and backbiting or listening complaisantly to detraction sins gravely against justice. Tale-bearing (whispering) is an even graver sin than simple backbiting. This is because a friend is better than honor, and the tale-bearer sows discord between friends.

Atlas of Saints wrote this summary of section 32 of Summa Theologica by Saint Thomas Aquinas. It uses our own words. It is not a quotation from the book.

Cite this summary

Atlas of Saints. “Second Part of the Second Part — Extra-Judicial Injuries in Words, Fraud in Buying and Selling, Usury, and the Integral Parts of Justice (Questions 72–79)” Summary of Summa Theologica, by Saint Thomas Aquinas. https://www.atlasofsaints.com/writings/summa-theologica/chapters/32#atlas-answer

Section breakdown

The final chapter of the treatise examines sins against commutative justice committed through words outside a courtroom and through unfair economic transactions. In doing so, he concludes with the integral parts of justice. Five sins injure a neighbor by extra-judicial speech. This involves reviling (contumelia, which dishonors a person openly to his face). It also involves backbiting or detraction (which secretly blackens a neighbor's good name, a treasure more precious than material wealth), tale-bearing or whispering (susurratio, whichis even worse than backbiting because it destroys friendship, the greatest external good), derision or mockery (which shames a person to make him look contemptible), and cursing. In commerce, justice forbids fraud in buying and selling (selling above the just price, hiding dangerous or substantial defects, or using false weights) and forbids usury, which charges a price for the mere loan of money whose very use consists in its consumption. Finally, all justice is summed up in its two integral parts: declining from evil and doing good.

In Questions 72–76, Thomas Aquinas analyzes the five verbal injuries outside court—reviling, backbiting (detraction), tale-bearing (`susurratio`), derision, and cursing. In doing so, he proves that tale-bearing is the gravest. This is because it destroys friendship, which is the highest of all external goods. In Question 72, a Christian should bear open reviling patiently. At the same time, sometimes correcting the reviler to check his insolence and avoid scandal. In Questions 77–78, Aquinas sets forth the moral laws of commerce and credit: buying and selling are instituted for the common advantage of both parties according to the just price, sellers must reveal hidden defects that render goods harmful or worth less, trade for moderate gain to support one's household or the poor is lawful, and usury is unjust. This is because money has no use distinct from its consumption in exchange.

Question 76 distinguishes sinful cursing that wishes evil upon a neighbor out of hatred from prophetic declarations of divine justice. In Question 79, Aquinas concludes the treatise on justice in itself by showing that declining from evil and doing good are the two quasi-integral parts of justice, corresponding to negative precepts (which prevent transgression) and affirmative precepts (which prevent omission). Question 78 examines why inducing someone to commit usury is always sinful, though borrowing under necessity from a professional usurer for a good purpose is permissible. The two integral parts of all justice are declining from evil (avoiding injury to others) and doing good (rendering what is due). In general, sins of transgression are graver than sins of omission.

The story inside

In Question 77, Article 3, Aquinas discusses the famous moral case raised by Cicero and Saint Ambrose. A grain merchant sails from Alexandria to a famine-struck island where wheat is selling at a sky-high price. In doing so, he knows that several more grain ships are just behind him. Must he inform the islanders that more grain is arriving, or may he stay silent and sell at the current famine price? Aquinas distinguishes between hidden defects present in the goods right now (which the seller is strictly bound in justice to disclose, or else make restitution) and future market changes that have not yet lowered the value of the grain today. Strict justice does not compel him to announce future arrivals. At the same time, higher virtue counsels him to inform the buyers or lower his price out of mercy. Justice strictly forbids concealing any present defect in goods sold. At the same time, Christian virtue goes even further by sharing helpful knowledge with buyers.

Lessons worth keeping

  1. 1

    A person's good name is the most precious of external possessions, and backbiting or listening complaisantly to detraction sins gravely against justice.

  2. 2

    Tale-bearing (whispering) is an even graver sin than simple backbiting. This is because a friend is better than honor, and the tale-bearer sows discord between friends.

  3. 3

    In buying and selling, commutative justice requires equality of value according to the just price and requires sellers to disclose hidden defects that could cause loss or danger.

  4. 4

    The two integral parts of all justice are declining from evil (avoiding injury to others) and doing good (rendering what is due). In general, sins of transgression are graver than sins of omission.

Test your recall

Why is tale-bearing (whispering) a graver sin than backbiting?

Answer from memory first. Then check the summary and lessons above.

Notes & sources

3 notes

From Summa Theologica, Second Part of the Second Part, Questions 47–79: Treatise on Prudence and Justice, trans. Fathers of the English Dominican Province (1918). Line numbers show where each passage appears in the digitized text.

  1. 1.
    Lines 13774–13777
    “Ohj. 2. Further, Reviling seems to imply dishonour. But a man can be dishonoured or slighted by deeds more than by words. Therefore it seems that reviling consists, not in words but in deeds.”
  2. 2.
    Lines 15178–15181
    “Sometimes evil is spoken under the aspect of useful, as when one wishes a sinner to suffer sickness or hindrance of some kind, either that he may himself reform, or at least that he may cease from harming others.”
  3. 3.
    Lines 16113–16116
    “Ohj. 7. Further, Anyone may lawfully accept a thing which its owner freely gives him. Now he who accepts the loan, freely gives the usury. Therefore he who lends may lawfully take the usury.”

Location: section 32 of 80 · 40%

Display settings