Section XXVIII · Location 28 of 80
Section 28 · Open to readFrom Summa Theologica by Saint Thomas Aquinas
Edition: Aquinas Ethicus: The Moral Teaching of St. Thomas, Volume I, trans. Father Joseph Rickaby, S.J. (1896)
Second Part of the Second Part — Questions I–XLVI: Faith, Hope, Charity, Fraternal Correction, Just War, Almsdeeds, and Spiritual Folly
Summa Theologica · Chapter 28 summary
Faith assents to revealed truth on the authority of God as defined by the Church and Sovereign Pontiff. Unbelievers who have never embraced the faith must never be forced to believe. Nor may their young children be baptized against their parents' natural rights.
Atlas of Saints wrote this summary of section 28 of Summa Theologica by Saint Thomas Aquinas. It uses our own words. It is not a quotation from the book.
Cite this summary
Atlas of Saints. “Second Part of the Second Part — Questions I–XLVI: Faith, Hope, Charity, Fraternal Correction, Just War, Almsdeeds, and Spiritual Folly” Summary of Summa Theologica, by Saint Thomas Aquinas. https://www.atlasofsaints.com/writings/summa-theologica/chapters/28#atlas-answer
Section breakdown
Saint Thomas Aquinas enters the Secunda Secundae (Questions I–XLVI). Then he examines the three theological virtues (Faith, Hope, and Charity) together with the gifts that perfect them and the vices that oppose them. "R. The object of any cognitive habit has two" (lines 14493..14493) aspects. What is known (the material object) and the light or motive by which it is known (the formal object). In the virtue of Faith, the formal motive is the First Truth (God Himself revealing). As a result, we believe whatever God has revealed solely because He, who is Sovereign Truth, has spoken it. The articles of faith are gathered in the Creed. Moreover, new questions or controversies arise. In response, it belongs to the Sovereign Pontiff (whose faith Christ prayed would not fail and who presides over the universal Church) to publish a new edition of the Creed defining the truth. Faith is more certain in itself than any human science or philosophy because it rests on divine truth, which cannot err. By contrast, human reason is subject to error.
In Question X, Aquinas establishes crucial principles regarding unbelievers and the freedom of the act of faith. Among those who have never heard the Gospel preached, negative unbelief is not a personal sin, but a penal consequence of original sin. They are damned. In that case, it is for other personal sins they commit against the natural law, not for failing to believe what they never heard. Moreover, unbelievers who have never received the Christian faith (such as pagans and Jews) must under no circumstances be compelled by force to believe. This is because to believe is an act of the free will that cannot be coerced. Even further, in Question X, Article 12, Aquinas asks whether the young children of Jews or other unbelievers should be baptized against their parents' will. In addition, he answers firmly in the negative: doing so violates the universal custom of the Church and violates natural justice. This is because before a child has the use of free reason. He is under the natural care of his parents as in a spiritual womb. It would be against natural justice to take him from his parents' custody or baptize him against their will.
Next comes the theological virtue of Hope (Questions XVII–XXII). Through this, the human will leans upon God's omnipotent assistance to attain eternal beatitude. Hope walks between two opposite precipices. The first is Despair, which judges that God will deny pardon to a repentant sinner or that salvation is impossible. Unbelief and hatred of God are greater sins in themselves. Even so, despair is the most perilous sin for us in its effects. Someone who despairs of eternal happiness lets go of every restraint and plunges headlong into vice. Indeed, he who despairs of the end ceases to care about the means. He who turns from "God must consequently of necessity turn to other" (lines 15932..15932) fleeting pleasures. The opposite sin is Presumption, which expects forgiveness from God without repenting of sin, or expects heaven without striving to keep the commandments. Hope is perfected by the Gift of Fear—not "servile fear", which abstains from sin merely out of terror of hellfire as a slave fears the whip. However, "filial" or chaste fear, which reveres God as a beloved Father and dreads offending Him or being separated from Him.
Questions XXIII–XLVI crown Volume I with the treatise on Charity. Aquinas follows Aristotle's insight that friendship requires mutual goodwill and a shared life. Then he marks out Charity as a true supernatural friendship of man with God. Because God shares His own eternal beatitude with us, He calls us no longer servants, but friends. Charity is the "form" and mother of all the virtues. This is because it directs the acts of every other virtue to God as our Last End. Without Charity, no virtue is complete or meritorious of eternal life. Charity follows a strict order grounded in relationship to God. First, we must love God above all things, more than ourselves. Second, in spiritual goods, each person must love his own soul more than his neighbor's soul—so that he may never commit even the smallest sin to rescue a neighbor from sin. Third, a person must love his neighbor's eternal salvation more than his own bodily life, being ready to risk bodily death to save a neighbor's soul. Fourth, among neighbors, we owe warmer natural affection and care to parents, spouse, children, and kinsfolk, because grace perfects nature rather than erasing family bonds. What about our enemies? Charity does not command us to love an enemy insofar as he is wicked or hostile, nor to show special signs of familiar intimacy to everyone indiscriminately (though doing so is a counsel of higher perfection). However, it strictly obliges every Christian to love enemies as fellow human beings made in God's image and capable of sharing heaven. In doing so, he banished all inward desire for private revenge and stood ready to help an enemy whenever he falls into genuine necessity.
From Charity spring three inward effects (Joy, Peace, and Mercy) and three outward works: Beneficence, Almsdeeds, and Fraternal Correction. "Now good men take for the prime element in them" (lines 16542..16542) their spiritual reason, which keeps them at peace with themselves and others. Almsdeeds comprise seven spiritual works (instructing the ignorant, counseling the doubtful, comforting the sorrowful, reproving sinners, forgiving injuries, bearing wrongs patiently, and praying for all) and seven corporal works (feeding the hungry, giving drink to the thirsty, clothing the naked, sheltering the harborless, visiting the sick, ransoming captives, and burying the dead). Giving alms out of one's superfluous wealth—or even out of what fits one's station when a neighbor is in extreme, life-threatening necessity—is not merely a counsel. Rather, it is a strict precept of charity under pain of mortal sin. Fraternal Correction seeks to heal a brother's sin for his own good: therefore. In doing so, he follows Christ's rule in Matthew 18, if the sin is secret and harms only the sinner himself, we must correct him privately between him and us alone to spare his reputation, brings in witnesses or telling superiors only if private admonition fails. By contrast, a secret sin is a plot of treason or heresy that immediately endangers the whole community. In that case, we must report it at once to save the common good.
Finally, Aquinas examines the sins opposed to Charity and Peace: Hatred, Sloth, Envy, Discord, Schism, War, Brawling, Sedition, Scandal, and Spiritual Stupidity. In Question XL, Article 1, Aquinas sets forth the three classic conditions required for a War to be just. First is the authority of the sovereign ruler by whose command the war is waged (since private individuals can appeal to a higher tribunal and have no authority to summon the nation to arms). Second is a just cause (namely, that those who are attacked deserve it on account of some fault or refusal to make amends for a wrong they have inflicted). Moreover, third, a rightful intention on the part of the belligerents, aiming to advance good, avoid evil, and secure a just peace rather than acting out of cruelty, lust for domination, or greed for plunder.
The story inside
The formal object of Faith is the First Truth (God revealing). At the same time, its material object encompasses all articles proposed in the Creed, which belongs to the Sovereign Pontiff to draw up and define when controversies arise. Faith is more certain than any human science because it rests on infallible divine truth. Outward confession of faith is strictly binding whenever God's honor or our neighbor's spiritual good requires it. Negative unbelief in those who have never heard the Gospel is not a personal sin (though they cannot be saved without grace). By contrast, positive resistance to the known faith is the gravest sin of unbelief. Unbelievers who have never received the faith must never be compelled by force to believe. This is because to believe is an act of the free will. The young children of unbelievers must not be baptized against their parents' will, which would violate natural justice. Heresy (obstinately choosing against the Church's rule of faith) destroys supernatural faith completely, and Blasphemy against God is a mortal sin.
Lessons worth keeping
- 1
Faith rests on God's authority as proposed by the Church. Unbelievers who have never embraced the faith must never be forced to believe. Nor may their young children be baptized against their parents' natural rights.
- 2
Charity is man's supernatural friendship with God and the form of all virtues. In doing so, it orders our love of God, self, family, and enemies, and requires almsgiving from superfluous goods.
- 3
Fraternal correction must admonish secret personal faults privately before public disclosure. A war is morally just only when waged by legitimate sovereign authority, for a just cause, and with a right intention for peace.
Test your recall
Why does faith depend on the First Truth of God's word rather than human sight, and why is charity the mother and form of all the virtues?
Answer from memory first. Then check the summary and lessons above.
Notes & sources
3 notesFrom Aquinas Ethicus: The Moral Teaching of St. Thomas, Volume I, trans. Father Joseph Rickaby, S.J. (1896). Line numbers show where each passage appears in the digitized text.
- 1.Lines 14691–14692
“R. Our acts are meritorious, inasmuch as they proceed from free-will, moved by the grace of God.”
- 2.Lines 15336–15340
“R. The name heresy signifies choice or election. Now election is of means to the end, the end being presupposed. In matters of belief the principal truth bears the character of the last end, and the secondary truths the character of means to the end.”
- 3.Lines 16747–16749
“A sign of this is, that a man ought not to take upon himself any evil of sin to deliver his neighbour from sin.”
