Section XXVII · Location 27 of 80
Section 27 · Open to readFrom Summa Theologica by Saint Thomas Aquinas
Edition: Summa Theologica, First Part of the Second Part, Questions 90–114: Treatise on Law and Grace, trans. Fathers of the English Dominican Province (1915)
First Part of the Second Part — The Necessity, Essence, Division, Cause, and Effects of Grace: Justification and Merit (Questions 109–114)
Summa Theologica · Chapter 27 summary
In the state of fallen nature, human reason and will are wounded (though not totally destroyed). As a result, without healing and elevating grace a human being cannot love God above all things, avoid all mortal sin for long, prepare himself for grace, or persevere to the end. Habitual (sanctifying) grace is a supernatural quality infused by God into the very essence of the soul prior to the infused virtues. In doing so, he made the human person a partaker of the divine nature (2 Peter 1:4).
Atlas of Saints wrote this summary of section 27 of Summa Theologica by Saint Thomas Aquinas. It uses our own words. It is not a quotation from the book.
Cite this summary
Atlas of Saints. “First Part of the Second Part — The Necessity, Essence, Division, Cause, and Effects of Grace: Justification and Merit (Questions 109–114)” Summary of Summa Theologica, by Saint Thomas Aquinas. https://www.atlasofsaints.com/writings/summa-theologica/chapters/27#atlas-answer
Section breakdown
Crowning the First Part of the Second Part, the Treatise on Grace (Questions 109–114) examines how God helps human beings internally to know truth, love Him above all things, heal wounded nature, be justified from sin, and merit eternal life. Without grace, humans even in fallen nature can know some natural truths and perform particular natural goods (such as building houses or planting vineyards). Yet in the state of corrupted nature we cannot fulfill the whole natural law, love God above all things, avoid all mortal sin for long, rise from sin, or perform any work meritorious of eternal life without divine grace (Question 109). Grace includes both God's actual motion moving the soul and the habitual gift (sanctifying grace) infused into the essence of the soul as a participation in the divine nature (Questions 110–111), caused by God alone (Question 112). Its two great effects are the Justification of the Ungodly—consisting of the infusion of grace, the movement of free will toward God by faith, the movement of free will against sin, and the forgiveness of guilt (Question 113)—and Merit. By this means, the just person, and moved by the Holy Spirit as a living branch on the vine of Christ. In addition, he truly merits eternal life condignly and the conversion of others congruously (Question 114).
In Question 109, Thomas Aquinas steers between Pelagianism and total-depravity errors. He does this by demonstrating across ten articles what human nature can and cannot do without grace before and after the Fall. Without grace fallen man can know natural truths and do some particular moral goods. However, he cannot love God above all things, fulfill all the commandments, rise from sin, prepare himself for grace, avoid all mortal sin, do any meritorious work, or persevere in good without special divine assistance. Question 109 proves against Pelagianism that no human being can perform any work proportioned to everlasting life without supernatural elevating grace. In Questions 110–112, Aquinas establishes that sanctifying grace is a supernatural quality infused into the essence of the soul as a participation in the divine nature. In addition, he separates operating and cooperating grace as well as sanctifying and gratuitous grace. Moreover, he proves that God alone is the cause of grace and that no one in this life without special privilege can know with the certainty of faith that he possesses grace.
In Question 112, our preparation for grace does not precede God's action. This is because the very movement of our free will toward God is awakened by God's operating grace. In Questions 113–114, Aquinas analyzes the justification of the ungodly in its four simultaneous elements (infusion of grace, movement of free will toward God by faith, movement of free will against sin, and remission of guilt). This shows why in its supernatural goal it is greater than the creation of heaven and earth. Moreover, he proves that the justified person merits eternal life condignly by the power of the Holy Spirit. In addition, he can merit the first grace for another only congruously. Question 114 reconciles Saint Paul's 'The grace of God, life everlasting' (Romans 6:23) with Christian merit. He does this by showing that our merits are themselves God's gifts. No one can merit the first grace for himself. However, once justified by grace, a Christian's good works merit an increase of grace and eternal life condignly insofar as they proceed from the Holy Spirit, and congruously insofar as they proceed from free will.
The story inside
In commenting on John 14:12, Saint Augustine wrote a startling sentence: 'For a just man to be made from a sinner is a greater work than to create heaven and earth.' In Question 113, Article 9, Aquinas asks how this can be true when creating the universe out of sheer nothingness displays infinite power. He answers by distinguishing two ways of measuring the greatness of a work. By the manner of acting and by the greatness of what is produced. Considered according to the manner of acting, the creation of heaven and earth out of nothing is the greatest work. This is because nothingness is infinitely distant from being and offers no preexisting subject at all. Yet considered according to the greatness of the effect produced, the justification of the ungodly is even greater than the creation of the physical cosmos! For the creation of heaven and earth terminates in the good of changeable corporeal nature, which passes away, whereas the justification of the ungodly terminates in the eternal good of a participation in the divine nature itself. In doing so, he lifts a sinner into the supernatural friendship and glory of God forever. Every time God forgives and sanctifies a single human soul, He accomplishes a work whose eternal dignity surpasses the entire material universe.
Lessons worth keeping
- 1
In the state of fallen nature, human reason and will are wounded (though not totally destroyed). As a result, without healing and elevating grace a human being cannot love God above all things, avoid all mortal sin for long, prepare himself for grace, or persevere to the end.
- 2
Habitual (sanctifying) grace is a supernatural quality infused by God into the very essence of the soul prior to the infused virtues. In doing so, he made the human person a partaker of the divine nature (2 Peter 1:4).
- 3
The justification of a sinner involves four ordered elements that occur simultaneously in a single instant. The infusion of grace, the free will's movement toward God by faith, the free will's detestation of sin, and the remission of guilt—and considered in the magnitude of its supernatural terminus, the justification of one sinner is a greater work than the creation of heaven and earth.
- 4
No one can merit the first grace for himself. However, once justified by grace, a Christian's good works merit an increase of grace and eternal life condignly insofar as they proceed from the Holy Spirit, and congruously insofar as they proceed from free will.
Test your recall
Why can a person already in sanctifying grace still not persevere to the end of life without a further special help of grace from God?
Answer from memory first. Then check the summary and lessons above.
Notes & sources
3 notesFrom Summa Theologica, First Part of the Second Part, Questions 90–114: Treatise on Law and Grace, trans. Fathers of the English Dominican Province (1915). Line numbers show where each passage appears in the digitized text.
- 1.Lines 14563–14566
“We must now consider the exterior principle of human acts, i.e., God, in so far as, through grace, we are helped by Him to do right: and, first, we must consider the grace of God; secondly, its cause; thirdly, its effects.”
- 2.Lines 15829–15831
“For Augustine says [De Spir. et Litt. xiv.) that operating grace is faith that worketh by charity. But faith that worketh by charity is a virtue. Therefore grace is a virtue.”
- 3.Lines 16913–16916
“Now the soul has most certain knowledge of those things that are in it by their physical reality, as appears from Augustine [Gen. ad lit. xii.). Hence grace may be known most certainly by one who has grace.”
