Skip to content
Atlas of Saints

Summa Theologica

Section 17 · Saint Thomas Aquinas

Section XVII · Location 17 of 80

Section 17 · Open to read

From Summa Theologica by Saint Thomas Aquinas

Edition: Summa Theologica, First Part, Questions 103–119: Treatise on the Divine Government, trans. Fathers of the English Dominican Province (1922)

First Part — Questions CIII–CV: Divine Government in General, the Preservation of Creatures in Being, and How God Moves Created Wills and Works Miracles

Summa Theologica · Chapter 17 summary

God governs all things toward the end of His own Goodness, designing the universal plan immediately. At the same time, he executes it through secondary causes. As a result, creatures may share the dignity of causality.

Atlas of Saints wrote this summary of section 17 of Summa Theologica by Saint Thomas Aquinas. It uses our own words. It is not a quotation from the book.

Cite this summary

Atlas of Saints. “First Part — Questions CIII–CV: Divine Government in General, the Preservation of Creatures in Being, and How God Moves Created Wills and Works Miracles” Summary of Summa Theologica, by Saint Thomas Aquinas. https://www.atlasofsaints.com/writings/summa-theologica/chapters/17#atlas-answer

Section breakdown

Saint Thomas Aquinas had completed his treatises on the creation and distinction of creatures. Therefore, he opens the Treatise on the Divine Government (Questions CIII–CXIX) by examining how God guides the universe to its appointed end. Against ancient materialists who attributed cosmic order to blind chance, In Question CIII, the world is governed by a supreme Intelligence. Unintelligent bodies in nature act constantly for the best result, which would be impossible unless they were directed by a wise Ruler. In the same way, an arrow flies to the target because it is aimed by the archer. What is the ultimate goal of this government? The end of an army is the good of its general. In the same way, the ultimate end of the universe is something distinct from the universe itself—namely, God's own infinite Goodness, which creatures seek. He does this by participating in and imitating Him according to their measure. Moreover, the perfection of government consists in unity and peace. Therefore, the universe is ruled not by competing principles of good and evil, as the Manicheans imagined, but by "one Lord: and both of these pertain to government. For" (lines 372..372) every multitude derives its unity from one first principle. In the design of His government, God knows and cares for even the smallest creature immediately. In its execution, however, He governs lower things through higher secondary causes—not from any defect in His power. However, out of the abundance of His goodness. As a result, creatures too may enjoy the dignity of being real causes.

In Question CIV, Aquinas demonstrates why creatures depend on God not only at the first moment of their creation, but at every single instant of their existence. A human architect causes only the becoming of a house out of pre-existing stone and wood, so the house stays standing after the architect goes home. God, by contrast, is the direct cause of the very being (esse) of every creature. In the same way, the sun is the direct cause of light in the atmosphere. On "it depends the other's being, as the being of the effect" (lines 1101..1101) depends on the presence of its cause. Consequently, as St. Augustine taught, if God were to withdraw His conserving action for a single moment, the entire universe would instantly vanish into nothingness. In the same way, the air goes dark the moment the sun sets. Yet God never annihilates anything He has made (neither spiritual substances nor material prime matter). This is because the perfection of divine power and grace is manifested not by reducing creatures to nothing, but by preserving them in being.

In Question CV, Aquinas explains how God moves created things to act. God can immediately move any body, and enlighten any created intellect by strengthening its power of understanding and impressing intelligible species. Move the human will from within. No angel or creature can ever act directly inside the human will. Only God, who created the will and implanted its natural inclination toward universal good, can move the will interiorly. This interior motion proceeds from the very Author of human nature. Therefore, it never forces the will violently, but moves it freely according to its own nature. Furthermore, God works inside every natural and voluntary action: "Reply Obj. 3. God not only gives things their form, but" (lines 1832..1832) also preserves them in being, and applies them to act. Moreover, he serves as the final end of every operation. God acts outside the order of the whole of created nature. In response, He works a true miracle. This is an event that causes wonder because its cause is hidden in God alone. Although all miracles are equally easy for God's omnipotence, they are ranked in three degrees by comparison with nature. The highest degree surpasses what nature can ever do (such as the sun standing still or Christ's glorified body entering through closed doors). The second degree accomplishes what nature can do. However, not in that order (such as restoring sight to the blind or raising the dead to life). Moreover, the third degree accomplishes instantly without natural agents what nature ordinarily does slowly (such as curing a fever at a single word).

The story inside

In Question CIII (8 articles), Saint Thomas proves that the world is governed by an unerring Intelligence. This is because natural bodies lacking knowledge act almost always in the best way for their end, like an arrow shot by an archer. The final end of the universe is something outside the universe—namely, God's own Goodness, which creatures seek. He does this by participating in and resembling Him. The world is governed by one Monarch, because unity is the perfection of peace and order. God knows and plans the governance of all things immediately. At the same time, He carries out its execution through secondary causes out of the abundance of His goodness. As a result, creatures may share the dignity of causality. Nothing can escape God's government, nor can anything resist His universal will. Even so, creatures may deviate from a particular order and fall under His penal justice. In Question CIV (4 articles), Aquinas explains that creatures need to be preserved in existence by God at every moment. A human builder causes the becoming of a house (composed of pre-existing stones and timber), so the house remains standing after the builder leaves. God, however, is the cause of the very being (esse) of all creatures. In the same way, the sun is the cause of light in the air. Therefore, as St. Augustine says, if God withdrew His creative power for a single instant, all creatures would immediately cease to exist. God preserves some things indirectly through secondary causes, and preserves spiritual substances immediately by His own power.

Lessons worth keeping

  1. 1

    God governs the universe toward His own Goodness. In doing so, he knows every detail immediately in His plan. At the same time, he executes it through secondary causes to share the dignity of causality with creatures.

  2. 2

    God causes the very being of creatures rather than merely their becoming. Therefore, every creature would instantly fall into nothingness if God ceased to conserve it.

  3. 3

    God alone moves the human will interiorly without forcing it, operates within every action of nature. Moreover, he works miracles across three degrees outside the order of created causes.

Test your recall

Why does God govern the universe toward His own goodness while also acting through created secondary causes instead of doing everything without them?

Answer from memory first. Then check the summary and lessons above.

Notes & sources

3 notes

From Summa Theologica, First Part, Questions 103–119: Treatise on the Divine Government, trans. Fathers of the English Dominican Province (1922). Line numbers show where each passage appears in the digitized text.

  1. 1.
    Lines 169–172
    “Obj. 2. Further, those things are governed which are moved towards some object. But the world does not appear to be so directed, but has stability in itself. Therefore it is not governed.”
  2. 2.
    Lines 787–790
    “Obj. 2. Further, a king does not justly punish those who do not rebel against his commands. Therefore if no one rebelled against God's commands, no one would be justly punished by God.”
  3. 3.
    Lines 1564–1567
    “On the contrary, The teacher moves the intellect of the one taught. But it is written (Ps. xciii. 10) that God teaches man knowledge. Therefore God moves the human intellect.”

Location: section 17 of 80 · 21%

Display settings