Section XVIII · Location 18 of 80
Section 18 · Open to readFrom Summa Theologica by Saint Thomas Aquinas
Edition: Summa Theologica, First Part, Questions 103–119: Treatise on the Divine Government, trans. Fathers of the English Dominican Province (1922)
First Part — Questions CVI–CX: Angelic Illumination and Speech, the Nine Choirs of the Three Hierarchies, the Ordering of the Demons, and How Angels Act on Bodies
Summa Theologica · Chapter 18 summary
Superior angels enlighten inferior angels by strengthening their intellects and adapting universal truths to their capacity, and angels speak to one another without vocal sound. He does this by directing their mental concepts through the will.
Atlas of Saints wrote this summary of section 18 of Summa Theologica by Saint Thomas Aquinas. It uses our own words. It is not a quotation from the book.
Cite this summary
Atlas of Saints. “First Part — Questions CVI–CX: Angelic Illumination and Speech, the Nine Choirs of the Three Hierarchies, the Ordering of the Demons, and How Angels Act on Bodies” Summary of Summa Theologica, by Saint Thomas Aquinas. https://www.atlasofsaints.com/writings/summa-theologica/chapters/18#atlas-answer
Section breakdown
Saint Thomas turns from God's immediate governance to the secondary causes through which He executes His plan. Then he begins in Question CVI: "WE next consider how one creature moves another. This" (lines 2087..2087) consideration starts with the angels. The higher angels stand closer to the First Light of God. Therefore, they possess a more universal grasp of truth than the lower angels. A wise human teacher strengthens a student's mind. He does this by breaking a single vast principle down into clear examples suited to the student's capacity. In the same way, a superior angel enlightens an inferior angel. He does this by strengthening his intellectual light and dividing universal truth into more particular intelligible species. Yet no angel can ever move another angel's will interiorly (for that belongs to God alone) though one angel can incline another by way of moral persuasion. In doing so, he shows the goodness of what ought to be done. In Question CVII, Aquinas explains how angels speak: having no vocal organs, an angel speaks to another simply by an act of free will directing his interior mental concept toward that angel. This spiritual speech does not travel through physical air, local distance never hinders one angel from speaking to another. An angel speaks to God. Therefore, he directs his mind in admiration and praise to the Divine Majesty.
In Question CVIII, Aquinas harmonizes the teaching of St. Dionysius the Areopagite and St. Gregory the Great on the three angelic hierarchies and nine choirs. A hierarchy is a sacred principality ordered under one ruler, and among the angels the three hierarchies correspond to three ways of knowing the plans (rationes) of divine governance. The First Hierarchy sees those plans in God Himself. These include the *Seraphim excel in the fiery ardor of charity, the Cherubim in the fullness of divine wisdom, and the Thrones in receiving God's immediate judgments. The Second Hierarchy contemplates the universal causes of creation. These include the Dominations appoint what is to be done, the Virtues give unfailing strength to cosmic causes and miracles, and the Powers maintain order and repel hostile forces. The Third Hierarchy executes particular ministries. The Principalities preside over the welfare of nations and kingdoms, the Archangels announce great mysteries of salvation (as Gabriel announced the Incarnation), and the Angels* guard individual human beings. Every angel differs in species by nature. Even so, countless angels belong to each choir by shared gifts of grace—gifts given to angels and "to man in a more excellent way than to other animals." (lines 3361..3361). In heaven these nine orders endure forever. Redeemed human souls are taken up into the different angelic choirs (some among the Seraphim by ardent love, others among the Cherubim by wisdom, and others among the lower choirs) according to the degree of grace and merit they attained on earth.
In Question CIX, Aquinas asks whether the wicked demons also have a hierarchy. Sin did not destroy the demons' natural essence. Therefore, those who originally belonged to higher choirs retain greater natural power over lower demons: "Reply Obj. 2. If we consider the ordering of the demons" (lines 4002..4002) on the part of God's justice, He leaves them under a prelude of their natural rank. At the same time, on their own part they band together under Lucifer as thieves unite to commit a crime. Yet there is no true "illumination" among demons, because illumination leads to God's truth. Instead, higher demons merely manifest their plots to lower ones. All demons are strictly curbed by the superior power of the good angels. Finally, in Question CX, Aquinas examines how angels act on corporeal matter. The context is set against the Arabic philosopher Avicenna. He claimed that spiritual intelligences directly imprint substantial forms onto earthly matter without natural agents. In this setting, Aquinas proves that corporeal forms come from corporeal agents (or from God alone in creation). Angels and demons can act on bodies only by *local movement*—rapidly gathering and applying natural seeds and elements (as Pharaoh's magicians produced frogs through hidden natural seeds)—and therefore no wonder worked by an angel's or demon's own natural power is ever a true miracle, which belongs to God alone acting outside the whole order of created nature.
The story inside
In Question CVI (4 articles), Aquinas explains that a superior angel enlightens an inferior angel. He does this by strengthening his intellectual power and dividing universal truth into more particular species suited to the lower angel's capacity. In the same way, a master teacher breaks down a deep truth for a student. An angel cannot move another angel's will directly (that belongs to God alone) but only by way of persuasion. In doing so, he points out the goodness of an object. Inferior angels never enlighten superior angels, and higher angels generously share all that pertains to the execution of divine ministries. In Question CVII (5 articles), angels speak to one another without vocal sounds simply. They do this by directing their free will to manifest their mental concept to another angel. Because this speech is purely spiritual, local distance neither hinders it nor allows third parties to overhear when one angel addresses another. In Question CVIII (8 articles), Aquinas follows St. Dionysius and St. Gregory the Great. Then he shows that the blessed angels are divided into three hierarchies—each containing three orders—according to how they understand the rationes (plans) of divine governance. The First Hierarchy (Seraphim, Cherubim, and Thrones) contemplates those plans in God Himself. The Second Hierarchy (Dominations, Virtues, and Powers) grasps them in universal created causes. Moreover, the Third Hierarchy (Principalities, Archangels, and Angels) applies them to particular nations, provinces, and individuals. Every angel is a distinct species by nature. Even so, many thousands share the same choir by grade of office and charity.
Lessons worth keeping
- 1
Superior angels enlighten inferior angels by adapting universal truths to their capacity, and angels communicate without vocal sound. He does this by directing their concepts through free will.
- 2
The nine angelic choirs are arranged in three hierarchies—First (Seraphim, Cherubim, Thrones), Second (Dominations, Virtues, Powers), and Third (Principalities, Archangels, Angels)—into which redeemed humans are assumed according to merit.
- 3
Fallen demons remain subject to the restraint of the holy angels. Neither angels nor demons can directly create forms in matter or work strict miracles outside the order of nature.
Test your recall
How do higher angels enlighten lower angels by sharing more universal truth without ever forcing the human or angelic free will?
Answer from memory first. Then check the summary and lessons above.
Notes & sources
3 notesFrom Summa Theologica, First Part, Questions 103–119: Treatise on the Divine Government, trans. Fathers of the English Dominican Province (1922). Line numbers show where each passage appears in the digitized text.
- 1.Lines 2135–2137
“Obj. 3. Further, light is a form in the mind. But the rational mind is informed by God alone, without created intervention, as Augustine says (QQ. LXXXIII., qu. 51).”
- 2.Lines 2864–2865
“On the contrary, One man can speak to another alone; much more can this be the case among the angels.”
- 3.Lines 3558–3561
“Obj. 4. Further, Gregory (Horn. xxiv. in Evang.) places the Principalities above the Powers. These therefore are not placed immediately above the archangels, as Dionysius says (Cozl. Hier. ix.).”
