Section XVI · Location 16 of 80
Section 16 · Open to readFrom Summa Theologica by Saint Thomas Aquinas
Edition: Summa Theologica, First Part, Questions 75–102: Treatise on Man, trans. Fathers of the English Dominican Province (1912)
First Part — Original Justice, the State of Innocence, and Paradise (Questions 95–102)
Summa Theologica · Chapter 16 summary
The first man was created in sanctifying grace, which was the root of original justice keeping the passions subject to reason and the body subject to the soul. In the state of innocence, there was no servile slavery by which one human used another for mere private profit. However, only free governance directing others to their own good or the common good.
Atlas of Saints wrote this summary of section 16 of Summa Theologica by Saint Thomas Aquinas. It uses our own words. It is not a quotation from the book.
Cite this summary
Atlas of Saints. “First Part — Original Justice, the State of Innocence, and Paradise (Questions 95–102)” Summary of Summa Theologica, by Saint Thomas Aquinas. https://www.atlasofsaints.com/writings/summa-theologica/chapters/16#atlas-answer
Section breakdown
Concluding the Treatise on Man, Aquinas examines the state and condition of the first humans before the Fall. Their will endowed with grace and original justice (Question 95), their dominion over animals and creation (Question 96), their bodily immortality and preservation by the tree of life (Question 97), the generation of offspring without disordered lust (Question 98), the bodily, moral, and intellectual condition of children had they been born in innocence (Questions 99–101), and the earthly Paradise in which God placed Adam and Eve (Question 102). Original justice was a supernatural gift whereby the human mind was subject to God. The lower powers were wholly subject to reason. The body was subject to the soul without sickness or death.
In Questions 95–96, Thomas Aquinas shows that the first man was created in sanctifying grace (which sustained the harmony of original justice, ordered passions without rebellion, and all virtues). Moreover, he exercised dominion over all animals as well as free, non-servile directive governance among human beings. In Question 95, in the state of innocence Adam possessed all virtues in habit. Even so, virtues presupposing sin or misery (such as penance and mercy) existed only habitually and not in act. In Questions 97–98, Aquinas proves that in the state of innocence the human body was immortal and impassible through the supernatural gift of original justice supported by food and the tree of life. Furthermore, human multiplication would have occurred through bodily marriage ordered by reason without disordered concupiscence.
In Question 97, the tree of life had a finite bodily power to renew moisture and ward off aging for a set time until man was translated to spiritual immortality. In Questions 99–102, Aquinas establishes that children born in innocence would have been born with original righteousness and grown naturally in bodily strength and experimental knowledge. Furthermore, God created Adam outside the corporeal earthly Paradise before placing him there to dress and keep it. Question 102 opens the inquiry into whether the earthly Paradise is a real corporeal place suited to the primitive state of innocence. God created Adam outside Paradise and then placed him in the earthly garden. As a result, humanity would recognize the privileges of Paradise as a supernatural gift of grace rather than a natural right.
The story inside
Would all human beings have been completely without rulers or authority if Adam had never sinned? In Question 96, Article 4, Aquinas distinguishes two fundamentally different kinds of authority: servile mastership and free political governance. A slave differs from a free person in that a free person exists for his own sake ('is his own cause'). By contrast, a slave is ordered as a mere tool to another person's utility. This is a painful condition that could never exist before sin. Yet human beings are naturally social animals. A society of many people dissolves unless someone directs it to the common good. Furthermore, even in innocence, some individuals would have advanced further in wisdom and justice than others. Therefore, in the state of innocence, wiser citizens would have governed others freely for the governed citizens' own welfare and for the common good, without any domination or exploitation. True authority is not domination over others for private gain. However, unselfish service directing free persons toward the common good.
Lessons worth keeping
- 1
The first man was created in sanctifying grace, which was the root of original justice keeping the passions subject to reason and the body subject to the soul.
- 2
In the state of innocence, there was no servile slavery by which one human used another for mere private profit. However, only free governance directing others to their own good or the common good.
- 3
Adam's body before sin was immortal not by any intrinsic physical indestructibility. However, by a supernatural force of grace in the soul assisted by the food of the tree of life.
- 4
God created Adam outside Paradise and then placed him in the earthly garden. As a result, humanity would recognize the privileges of Paradise as a supernatural gift of grace rather than a natural right.
Test your recall
Were Adam's good works in the state of innocence more meritorious than ours after the Fall?
Answer from memory first. Then check the summary and lessons above.
Notes & sources
3 notesFrom Summa Theologica, First Part, Questions 75–102: Treatise on Man, trans. Fathers of the English Dominican Province (1912). Line numbers show where each passage appears in the digitized text.
- 1.Lines 14248–14251
“We next consider what belongs to the will of the first man; concerning which there are two points for treatment: (i) The grace and righteousness of the first man; (2) the use of righteousness as regards his dominion over other things.”
- 2.Lines 14997–15000
“But man was made subject to man as a penalty; for after sin it was said to the woman (Gen. iii. 16): Thou shalt be under thy husband's power. Therefore in the state of innocence man would not have been subject to man.”
- 3.Lines 15701–15705
“Therefore continence would not have been praiseworthy in the state of innocence, whereas it is praiseworthy in our present state, not because it removes fecundity, but because it excludes inordinate desire. In that state fecundity would have been without lust.”
