Section II · Location 2 of 3
Section 2 · Open to readFrom Hodegos (Guide) by Saint Anastasius Sinaita
Edition: Viae Dux (Hodegos) adversus Acephalos, trans. Jacob Gretser, S.J. (ed., Migne PG 89) (1606)
Capita VIII–XII: Biblical and Nicene Proofs Distinguishing Nature and Hypostasis and the Four Alexandrian Disputations Against the Theodosians and Gaianites
Hodegos (Guide) · Chapter 2 summary
In Chapters VIII–XII, Anastasius proves from Moses, Solomon, the Gospels (and the Council of Nicaea that nature and hypostasis are never identical) (and records his four public disputations at Alexandria against the Theodosians and Gaianites).
Atlas of Saints wrote this summary of section 2 of Hodegos (Guide) by Saint Anastasius Sinaita. It uses our own words. It is not a quotation from the book.
Cite this summary
Atlas of Saints. “Capita VIII–XII: Biblical and Nicene Proofs Distinguishing Nature and Hypostasis and the Four Alexandrian Disputations Against the Theodosians and Gaianites” Summary of Hodegos (Guide), by Saint Anastasius Sinaita. https://www.atlasofsaints.com/writings/hodegos/chapters/2#atlas-answer
Section breakdown
In Chapters VIII and IX (Anastasius refutes the Severian claim that 'nature' and 'person' mean the same thing by marshaling proofs from the Old and New Testaments and from the 318 Fathers of Nicaea). In Genesis 1, God created one human nature, yet multiplied it into countless distinct persons (Adam, Eve, Abel, and Seth) who share one common flesh while remaining distinct hypostases. Likewise, the Nicene Creed anathematizes anyone who says the Son is from another hypostasis or ousia (using both terms in Trinitarian theology without ever reducing the three Persons to three natures).
In Chapter X, Anastasius records verbatim his four public disputations held at Alexandria against the Theodosians (followers of Severus) and Gaianites (followers of Julian of Halicarnassus). In the first two disputations. At that point, the Monophysites boast of quoting Athanasius, Cyril (and Julius on 'one incarnate nature of the Word,' Anastasius produces books bearing the titles of the Fathers that appear to teach opposite doctrines) (forcing his opponents to admit that patristic sentences cannot be torn from their context or accepted from interpolated apocrypha without testing them against the Nicene and Ephesine definitions).
In the third and fourth Alexandrian disputations and Chapters XI–XII, Anastasius puts his opponents (to the test through Socratic questioning and visual diagrams)(`etymologiae` and `scholia`). By forcing the Severians to confess that the Father, Son (and Holy Spirit share one divine nature yet only the Son was nailed to the Cross) (he proves from their own mouths that if nature and hypostasis were identical), the entire Trinity would have been crucified on Calvary.
The story inside
During his public disputation in Alexandria against the Severian leaders (recorded in Chapter X of the Hodegos) (Anastasius saw that his opponents refused to listen to Chalcedon and instead waved florilegia of isolated quotes attributed to Cyril and Athanasius). Anastasius calmly brought out a prepared codex containing forged or out-of-context passages (under the names of the great Fathers that seemed to contradict their own position). When the Severians cried out that those passages were corrupted or misunderstood, Anastasius sprang his trap: 'Then let us stop hurling isolated scraps of parchment at one another and judge every phrase by the common rule of Scripture and the Councils of Nicaea and Ephesus!'
Lessons worth keeping
- 1
Scripture proves that nature and hypostasis are distinct: Adam, Eve (and Seth share one common human nature while existing as distinct personal hypostases).
- 2
In his four Alexandrian disputations (Chapter X) (Anastasius demonstrates that isolated patristic quotes cannot be used to overthrow the rule of Nicaea and Ephesus).
- 3
If 'nature' and 'hypostasis' were identical as Severus claimed, then because the three Persons share one divine nature (the Father and the Holy Spirit would have been crucified with the Son).
Test your recall
How does Anastasius use Adam, Eve, and Seth in Chapter VIII to prove that nature and person are distinct, and how did he expose the misuse of patristic florilegia in his Alexandrian disputations?
Answer from memory first. Then check the summary and lessons above.
Notes & sources
3 notesFrom Viae Dux (Hodegos) adversus Acephalos, trans. Jacob Gretser, S.J. (ed., Migne PG 89) (1606). Line numbers show where each passage appears in the digitized text.
- 1.Lines 9949–9951
“RarsrpENTE Rege Chri(to Dco in fublimi δε excelfo throno;in fan&a, Catholica, Apoftolica -&orthodoxa Ecclefia noftra;eiqueadíiftentibus . E”
- 2.Lines 12443–12445
“οἱ co Qoi ὅται, kei bo mgss ἠρετίσαν τρ µυθκοις pt JAYOIG, αὶ B^ac- Quien ἑαυσσυ: καἰοῤῥίφαι.ὅπως de νοµίζασι,καλυθεάσωσι viu) αγίων quuod loy χαλκηδόν(Θ», κφὶ lu) wool) S eig ἐκκλη-”
- 3.Lines 14880–14882
“Ad hzc Ioanries & Gregorius Dormitantius refponde- runt. Ante ynionem confitemur duas naturas At post vnionem α[[ε- rimus Cbriffüm effevnam naturam incarnatam, Ad quz cgo. Arbi-”
