Section II · Location 2 of 4
Section 2 · Open to readFrom Epistolae Oecumenicae et XII Capitula contra Nestorium by Saint Cyril of Alexandria
Edition: The Seven Ecumenical Councils of the Undivided Church: Their Canons and Dogmatic Decrees (Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, Second Series, Vol. XIV), trans. Henry R. Percival (1900)
Section 2 — Commission of Pope Saint Celestine I and the Third Letter to Nestorius (November 430)
Epistolae Oecumenicae et XII Capitula contra Nestorium · Chapter 2 summary
Acting as plenipotentiary delegate of Pope Saint Celestine I after the Roman Synod of August 430 (Cyril convenes a council at Alexandria). Moreover, he sends his Third Oecumenical Letter requiring Nestorius to abjure his errors within ten days.
Atlas of Saints wrote this summary of section 2 of Epistolae Oecumenicae et XII Capitula contra Nestorium by Saint Cyril of Alexandria. It uses our own words. It is not a quotation from the book.
Cite this summary
Atlas of Saints. “Section 2 — Commission of Pope Saint Celestine I and the Third Letter to Nestorius (November 430)” Summary of Epistolae Oecumenicae et XII Capitula contra Nestorium, by Saint Cyril of Alexandria. https://www.atlasofsaints.com/writings/epistolae-oecumenicae-et-xii-capitula-contra-nes-cyril-of-alexandria/chapters/2#atlas-answer
Section breakdown
Nestorius answered Cyril's Second Letter with an evasive and defiant reply. Therefore, both patriarchs sent their correspondence to Pope Saint Celestine I in Rome. Cyril carefully prepared a Latin translation of the entire dossier and of the testimonies (of the Greek and Latin Fathers)(carried to Rome by his deacon Posidonius). In August 430 Pope Celestine assembled a synod at Rome which approved Cyril's Second Letter as fully orthodox (condemned Nestorius's teaching) (and commissioned Cyril to act as the Pope's plenipotentiary representative to execute the sentence). Unless Nestorius retracted in writing within ten days of receiving the final warning, he stood excommunicated and deposed.
In November 430 Cyril convened an Egyptian synod at Alexandria and dispatched four bishops (to Constantinople bearing Pope Celestine's decree along with Cyril's Third Synodical Letter to Nestorius)(beginning 'Cum Salvator noster'). In this Third Oecumenical Letter, Cyril sets forth the Nicene Creed (proves that the flesh of Christ is 'life-giving' in the Holy Eucharist precisely). This is because it is the very flesh of the Eternal Word, and appends twelve concise propositions (the Twelve Anathematisms) which Nestorius was required to subscribe as proof of his orthodoxy.
The story inside
Patriarch Cyril appealed to Rome in 430. Then he knew that Greek theological terms could easily be misunderstood in the West if left untranslated. He therefore had his letters to Nestorius, Nestorius's sermons (and a collection of patristic extracts translated into accurate Latin at Alexandria). Moreover, he sent them by the deacon Posidonius to Pope Celestine I (who immediately appointed Cyril to wield the authority of the Apostolic See at Constantinople and Ephesus).
Lessons worth keeping
- 1
The cooperation of Pope Saint Celestine I in Rome and Patriarch Saint Cyril in (Alexandria exemplifies how papal primacy and conciliar theology defended the Catholic faith).
- 2
Cyril's argument from the Eucharist in his Third Letter shows that the Bread (of Life gives eternal life only because Christ's body is the personal body of the Word of Life).
Test your recall
What mandate did Pope Saint Celestine I and the Roman Synod of August 430 give to Saint Cyril, and why did Cyril invoke the Holy Eucharist in his Third Letter to Nestorius?
Answer from memory first. Then check the summary and lessons above.
Notes & sources
1 noteFrom The Seven Ecumenical Councils of the Undivided Church: Their Canons and Dogmatic Decrees (Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, Second Series, Vol. XIV), trans. Henry R. Percival (1900). Line numbers show where each passage appears in the digitized text.
- 1.Lines 18765–18890
“512 said: "The holy Council at Chalcedon approved this teaching of Cyril of blessed memory, and received his Synodical letters, to one of which are appended the xij. anathemas" (Mansi, t. ix., p. 341; Hardouin, t. iij., p. 167). If, however, the anathematisms of Cyril were expressly confirmed at Chalcedon, there was even more reason for doing so at Ephesus. And Ibas, in his well-known letter to Maris, says expressly that the Synod of Ephesus confirmed the anathematisms of Cyril, and the same was asserted even by the bishops of Antioch at Ephesus in a letter to the Emperor. From all these considerations it would seem that Tillemont' s conclusion is well rounded that the Synod certainly discussed the anathemas of Cyril in detail, but that here, as in many other places, there are parts of the Acts lacking. I shall add the opinion of Petavius. (Petavius, De Incarnatione, Lib. VI., cap. xvij.) The Acts do not tell us what judgment the Synod of Ephesus gave with respect to the third letter of Cyril, and with regard to the anathemas attached to it. But the Acts in other respects also have not come down to us in their integrity. That that third letter was received and approved by the Ephesine Council there can be no doubt, and this the Catholics shewed in their dispute with the Acephali in the Collation held at Constantinople under the Emperor Justinian in the year of Christ 811. For at that memorable meeting some-tiring was shewn forth concerning this letter and its anathemas, which has a connection with the matter in hand, and therefore must not be omitted. At that meeting the Opposers, that is the Acephali, the enemies of the Council of Chalcedon, made this objection against that Council: "The [letter] of the Twelve Anathemas which is inserted in the holy Council of Ephesus, and which you cannot deny to be synodical, why did not Chalcedon receive it?" etc., etc. From this it is evident that the prevailing opinion, then as now, was that the Twelve Anathemas were defined as part of the faith by the Council of Ephesus. Perhaps I may close this treatment of the subject in the words of Denziger, being the caption he gives the xij. Anathematisms in his Enchiridion, under "Decrees of the Third Ecumenical Council, that of Ephesus." "The Third Synod received these anathematisms; the Fourth Synod placed them in its Acts and styled the Epistles of Cyril 'Canonical' ; the Fifth Synod defended them." 513 THE EPISTLE OF CYRIL TO NESTORIUS WITH THE XII. ANATHEMATISMS. (Labbe and Cossart, Concilia, Tom. Ill, col. 395; Migne, Parr. Groec, Tom. LXXVII. [Cyril, Opera, Tom. X.], col. 105 et seqq.) To the most reverend and God-loving fellow-minister Nestorius, Cyril and the synod assembled in Alexandria, of the Egyptian Province, Greeting in the Lord. When our Savior says clearly: "He that loveth father or mother more than me is not worthy of me: and he that loveth son or daughter more than me is not worthy of me," what is to become of us, from whom your Holiness requires that we love you more than Christ the Savior of us all? Who can help us in the day of judgment, or what kind of excuse shall we find for thus keeping silence so long, with regard to the blasphemies made by you against him? If you injured yourself alone, by teaching and holding such things, perhaps it would be less matter; but you have greatly scandalized the whole Church, and have cast among the people the leaven of a strange and new heresy. And not to those there [i.e. at Constantinople] on]y; but also to those everywhere [the books of your explanation were sent]. How can we any longer, under these circumstances, make a defense for our silence, or how shall we not be forced to remember that Christ said: "Think not that I am come to send peace on earth: I came not to send peace, but a sword. For I am come to set a man at variance against his father, and the daughter against her mother." For if faith be injured, let there be lost the honor due to parents, as stale and tottering, let even the law of tender love towards children and brothers be silenced, let death be better to the pious than living; "that they might obtain a better resurrection," as it is written. Behold, therefore, how we, together with the holy synod which met in great Rome, presided over by the most holy and most reverend brother and fellow-minister, Celestine the Bishop, also testify by this third letter to you, and counsel you to abstain from these mischievous and distorted dogmas, which you hold arid teach, and to receive the right faith, handed 514 down to the churches from the beginning through the holy Apostles and Evangelists, who "were eye-witnesses, and ministers of the Word." And if your holiness have not a mind to this according to the limits defined in the writings of our brother of blessed memory and most reverend fellow-minister Celestine, Bishop of the Church of Rome, be well assured then that you have no lot with us, nor place or standing (Xoyov) among the priests and bishops of God. For it is not possible for us to overlook the churches thus troubled, and the people scandalized, and the right faith set aside, and the sheep scattered by you, who ought to save them, if indeed we are ourselves adherents of the right faith, and followers of the devotion of the holy fathers. And we are in communion with all those laymen and clergymen cast out or deposed by your holiness on account of the faith; for it is not right that those, who resolved to believe rightly, should suffer by your choice; for they do well in opposing you. This very thing you have mentioned in your epistle written to our most holy and fellow-bishop Celestine of great Rome. But it would not be sufficient for your reverence to confess with us only the symbol of the faith set out some time ago by the Holy Ghost at the great and holy synod convened in Nice: for you have not held and interpreted it rightly, but rather perversely; even though you confess with your voice the form of words. But in addition, in writing and by oath, you must confess that you also anathematize those polluted and unholy dogmas of yours, and that you will hold and teach that which we all, bishops, teachers, and leaders of the people both East and West, hold. The holy synod of Rome and we all agreed on the epistle written to your Holiness from the Alexandrian Church as being right and blameless. We have added to these our own letters and that which it is necessary for you to hold and teach, and what you should be careful to avoid. Now this is the Faith of the Catholic and Apostolic Church to which all Orthodox Bishops, both East and West, agree: "We believe in one God, the Father Almighty, Maker of all things visible and invisible, and in one Lord Jesus Christ, the Only-begotten Son of God, begotten of his Father, that is, of the substance of the Father; God of God,”
