Section I · Location 1 of 4
Section 1 · Open to readFrom Epistolae Oecumenicae et XII Capitula contra Nestorium by Saint Cyril of Alexandria
Edition: The Seven Ecumenical Councils of the Undivided Church: Their Canons and Dogmatic Decrees (Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, Second Series, Vol. XIV), trans. Henry R. Percival (1900)
Section 1 — The Outbreak of Nestorianism and Cyril's Second Oecumenical Letter to Nestorius (429–430)
Epistolae Oecumenicae et XII Capitula contra Nestorium · Chapter 1 summary
When Nestorius and his chaplain Anastasius deny the Virgin Mary's title of Theotokos at Constantinople (Cyril writes his Second Oecumenical Letter defining the personal union of the Eternal Word with human flesh).
Atlas of Saints wrote this summary of section 1 of Epistolae Oecumenicae et XII Capitula contra Nestorium by Saint Cyril of Alexandria. It uses our own words. It is not a quotation from the book.
Cite this summary
Atlas of Saints. “Section 1 — The Outbreak of Nestorianism and Cyril's Second Oecumenical Letter to Nestorius (429–430)” Summary of Epistolae Oecumenicae et XII Capitula contra Nestorium, by Saint Cyril of Alexandria. https://www.atlasofsaints.com/writings/epistolae-oecumenicae-et-xii-capitula-contra-nes-cyril-of-alexandria/chapters/1#atlas-answer
Section breakdown
Soon after Nestorius, a monk and preacher from Antioch formed in the school of Theodore of Mopsuestia (became Patriarch of Constantinople in 428) (his chaplain Anastasius preached a sermon declaring), 'Let no one call Mary Theotokos (Mother of God). For Mary was but a woman. It is impossible that God should be born of a woman.' Instead of rebuking his priest (Nestorius mounted the pulpit on Christmas Day 428 and in subsequent sermons defended the error). Through this, we learn that Mary gave birth only to a human person (Christotokos) in whom the Word of God dwelt as in a temple by a moral union of grace and dignity.
Copies of Nestorius's sermons disturbed the monks of Egypt. In response, Patriarch Cyril of Alexandria defended the Catholic faith in his Paschal Homily for 429. In addition, he recorded twice directly to Nestorius. His famous Second Letter to Nestorius (written in early 430) states the classic Catholic doctrine of the Incarnation. The Eternal Word did not merely associate a pre-existing man to Himself. However, he united human flesh animated by a rational soul to Himself 'according to hypostasis' (personally). Not that the divine nature was changed into flesh or originated from Mary. However. This is because the sacred body born of her was the Word's own body (the holy Fathers rightly called the Virgin Theotokos).
The story inside
Copies of Nestorius's Constantinople sermons reached the desert monasteries of Egypt in 429. In response (monks asked Patriarch Cyril whether they must stop calling the Blessed Virgin 'Mother of God.' Cyril replied in his Second Oecumenical Letter that the Virgin did not give birth to the bare Godhead), which is eternal from the Father. Yet because the flesh born of her womb belonged personally to the Eternal Word Himself (anyone who denies she is Mother of God divides Christ into two sons).
Lessons worth keeping
- 1
The title Theotokos ('Mother of God') is first of all a Christological safeguard. Mary is Mother of God because the Child conceived and born of her is one divine Person (God the Word).
- 2
In the Hypostatic Union (the divine and human natures remain unconfused and unchanged while united in the single Person of the Son).
Test your recall
How did Nestorius explain the union of God and man in Christ, and how did Saint Cyril's Second Oecumenical Letter justify calling the Blessed Virgin Mary Theotokos?
Answer from memory first. Then check the summary and lessons above.
Notes & sources
1 noteFrom The Seven Ecumenical Councils of the Undivided Church: Their Canons and Dogmatic Decrees (Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, Second Series, Vol. XIV), trans. Henry R. Percival (1900). Line numbers show where each passage appears in the digitized text.
- 1.Lines 99170–99359
“It was in the winter of 427-28 that the Antiochene Nestorius became Patriarch of Constantinople. His heretical teaching soon became known to Cyril. Against him Cyril taught the use of the term Theotokos in his Paschal letter for 429 and in a letter to the monks of Egypt. A correspondence with Nestorius followed, in a more moderate tone than might have been expected. Nestorius sent his sermons to Pope Celestine, but he received no reply, for the latter wrote to St. Cyril for further information. Rome had taken the side of St. John Chrysostom against Theophilus, but had neither censured the orthodoxy of the latter, nor consented to the patriarchal powers exercised by the bishops of Constantinople. To St. Celestine Cyril was not only the first prelate of the East, he was also the inheritor of the traditions of Athanasius and Peter. The pope's confidence was not misplaced. Cyril had learnt prudence. Peter had attempted unsuccessfully to appoint a Bishop of Constantinople; Theophilus had deposed another. Cyril, though in this case Alexandria was in the right, does not act in his own name, but denounces Nestorius to St. Celestine, since ancient custom, he says, persuaded him to bring the matter before the pope. He relates all that had occurred, and begs Celestine to decree what he thinks fit (rvnuaai ri SIkovv — a phrase which Dr. W. Bright chooses to weaken into "formulate his opinion"), and communicate it also to the bishops of Macedonia and of the East (i. e. the Antiochene Patriarchate). The pope's reply was of astonishing severity. He had already commissioned Cassian to write his wellknown treatise on the Incarnation. He now summoned a council (such Roman councils had somewhat the office of the modern Roman Congregations), and despatched a letter to Alexandria with enclosures to Constantinople, Philippi, Jerusalem, and Antioch. Cyril is to take to himself the authority of the Roman See, and to admonLsh Nestorius that unless he recants within ten days from the receipt of this ultimatum, he is separated from "our body" (the popes of the day have the habit of speaking of other churches as the members, of which they are the head; the body is, of course, the Catholic Church). If Nestorius does not submit, Cyril is to "provide for" the Church of Constantinople. Such a sentence of excommunication and deposition is not to be confounded with the mere withdrawal of actual communion by the popes from Cyril himself at an earlier date, from Theophilus, or, at Antioch, from Flavian or Melctius. It was the decree Cyril had asked for. As Cyril had twice written to Nestorius, his citation in the name of the pope is to be counted as a third warning, after which no grace is to be given. St. Cyril summoned a covmcil of his suffragans, and composed a letter to which were appended twelve propositions for Nestorius to anathematize. The epistle was not conciliatory, and Nestorius may well have been taken aback. The twelve propositions did not emanate from Rome, and were not at all equally clear; one or two of them were later among the authorities invoked by the Monophysite heretics in their own favour. Cyril was the head of the rival theological school to that of Antioch, where Nestorius had studied, and was the hereditary rival of the Constantinopolitan would-be patriarch. Cyril wrote also to John, Patriarch of Antioch, informing him of the facts, and insinuating that if John should support his old friend Nestorius, he would find himself isolated over against Rome, Macedonia, and Egypt. John took the hint, and urged Nestorius to yield. Meanwhile, in Constantinople itself large numbers of the people held aloof from Nestorius, and the Emperor Theodosius II had been persuaded to svunmon a general council to meet at Ephesus. The imperial letters were dispatched 19 November, whereas the bishops sent by Cyril arrived at Constantinople^^only on 7 December. Nestorius, somewhat naturally, refused to accept the message sent by his rival, and on the 13th or 14th of December preached publicly against Cyril as a calumniator, and as having used l>ribes (which was probably as true as it was usual) ; but he declared himself willing to use the word Theotokos. These sermons he sent to John of Antioch, who preferred them to the anathematizations of Cyril. Nestorius, however, issued twelve propositions with appended anathemas. If Cyril's propositions might be taken to deny the two natures in Christ, those of Nestorius hardly veiled his belief in two distinct persons. Theodoret urged John yet further, and wrote a treatise against Cyril, to which the latter replied with some warmth. He also wrote an "Answer" in five books to the sermons of Nestorius. As the fifteenth-century idea of an ceeumenical council superior to the poj^e had yet to be invented, and there was but one precedent for such an assembly, we need not be surprised that St. Celestine welcomed the initiative of the emperor, and hoped for peace through the assembly. (See Ephesu.s, Council of.) Nestorius found the churches of Ephesus closed to him, when he arrived with the imperial commissioner, Count Candidian, and his own friend, Coimt Irenseus. Cyril came with fifty of his bishops. Palestine, Crete, Asia Minor, and Greece added their quotient. But John of Antioch and his suffragans were delayed. Cyril may have believed, rightly or wrongly, that John did not wish to be present at the trial of his friend Nestorius, or that he wished to gain time for him, and he opened the council without John, on 22 Jime, in spite of the request of sixty-eight bishops for a delay. This was an initial error, which had disastrous results. The legates from Rome had not arrived, so that Cyril had no answer to the letter he had written to Celestine asking "whether the holy synod should receive a man who condemned what it preached, or, because the tinie of delay had elapsed, whether the sentence was still in force". Cyril might have presumed that the pope, in agreeing to send legates to the council, intended Nestorius to have a complete trial, but it was more convenient to assume that the Roman ultimatum had not been suspeiulod, and that the council was bound by it. He therefore took the place of president, not only as the highest in rank, but also as still holding the place of Celestine, though he camiot have received any fresh commission from the pope. Nestorius was summoned, in order that he might explain his neglect of Cyril's former monition in the name of the pope. He refused to receive the four bishops whom the coimcil sent to him. Consequently nothing remained but formal procedure. For the comicil was bound /)// llic rmxtns to depose Nestorius for contumacy, as he would not appear, and br/ the letter uj Cclextine to condemn him for heresy, as he had not recanted. Tlie correspondence between Rome, Alexandria, and Constantinople was read, and some testimonies were read from earlier writers to show the errors of Nestorius. The second letter of Cyril to Nestorius was approved by all the bishops. The reply of Nestorius was condemned. No discussion took place. The letter of Cyril and the ten anathematizations raised no comment. All was concluded at one sitting. The council declared that it was "of necessity impelled" by the canons and by the letter of Celestine to declare Nestorius deposed and excommunicated. The papal legates, who had been detained by bad weather, arrived on the 10th of July, and they solemnly confirmed the sentence by the authority of St. Peter, for the refusal of Nestorius to appear had made useless the permission which they brought from the pope to grant him forgiveness if he should repent. But meanwhile John of Antioch and his party had arrived on the 26th or 27th of June. They formed themselves into a rival council of fortythree bishops, and deposed Memnon, Bishop of Ephesus, and St. Cyril, accusing the latter of ApoUinarianism and even of Eunomianism. Both parties now appealed to the emperor, who took the amazing decision of sending a count to treat Nestorius, Cyril, and Memnon as being all three lawfully deposed. They were kept in close custody; but eventually the emperor took the orthodox view, though he dissolved the council ; Cyril was allowed to return to his diocese, and Nestorius went into retirement at Antioch. Later he was banished to the Great Oasis of Egypt. Meanwhile Pope Celestine was dead. His successor, St. Sixtus III, confirmed the council and attempted to get John of Antioch to anathematize Nestorius. For some time the strongest opponent of Cyril was Theodoret, but eventually he approved a letter of Cyril to Acacius of Berrhcea. John sent Paul, Bishop of Emesa, as his plenipotentiary to Alexandria, and he patched up a reconciliation with Cyril. Though Theodoret still refused to renounce the tlefence of Nestorius, John did so, and Cyril declared his joy in a letter to John. Isidore of Pelusium was now afraid that the impulsive Cyril might have yielded too much (Ep. i, 334). Tlie great patriarch composed many further treatises, dogmatic letters, and sermons. He died on the 9th or the 27th of June, 444, after an episcopate of nearly thirty- two years.”
