Skip to content
Atlas of Saints

Sancti Coelestini I Epistolae et Decreta (PL L)

Section 2 · Pope Saint Celestine I

Section II · Location 2 of 3

Section 2 · Open to read

From Sancti Coelestini I Epistolae et Decreta (PL L) by Pope Saint Celestine I

Edition: Epistles of Pope Saint Celestine I and Acts of the Council of Ephesus (NPNF Series II, Vol. XIV), trans. Henry R. Percival (1900)

Sessions II–III of Ephesus: The Letter of Pope Celestine I to the Synod, the Papal Legates Philip, Arcadius, and Projectus, and Confirmation of the Sentence

Sancti Coelestini I Epistolae et Decreta (PL L) · Chapter 2 summary

Arriving from Rome for Sessions II and III on 10–11 July 431, Pope Celestine I's legates (Bishops Arcadius and Projectus and the presbyter Philip) presented Celestine's synodical letter (inspected the acts of Session I) (and confirmed the deposition of Nestorius in the name of the Apostolic See).

Atlas of Saints wrote this summary of section 2 of Sancti Coelestini I Epistolae et Decreta (PL L) by Pope Saint Celestine I. It uses our own words. It is not a quotation from the book.

Cite this summary

Atlas of Saints. “Sessions II–III of Ephesus: The Letter of Pope Celestine I to the Synod, the Papal Legates Philip, Arcadius, and Projectus, and Confirmation of the Sentence” Summary of Sancti Coelestini I Epistolae et Decreta (PL L), by Pope Saint Celestine I. https://www.atlasofsaints.com/writings/epistolae-et-decreta-coelestini-i/chapters/2#atlas-answer

Section breakdown

On 10 July 431 (the Council assembled for its Second Session in the episcopal residence of Memnon at Ephesus to receive the legates sent from Rome by Pope Celestine I: Bishops Arcadius and Projectus and Philip), presbyter of the Roman Church. Opening the session, Philip requested that Pope Celestine's letter to the synod (dated 8 May 431) be read aloud in Latin and Greek and entered into the official acts. In his letter (Pope Celestine reminded the bishops that the assembly of priests manifests the presence of the Holy Spirit) (charged them as successors of the Apostles to guard the deposit of faith taught by Paul and John at Ephesus without addition or diminution) (and declared that his legates were sent to carry out what the Roman Synod had already determined).

When Peter the Alexandrian notary finished reading the Greek translation of Pope Celestine's epistle (all the bishops cried out together in acclamation: 'This is a just judgment)! To Celestine, a new Paul! To Cyril, a new Paul! To Celestine, the guardian of the faith! To Celestine, unanimous with the synod! One Celestine, one Cyril, one faith of the synod (one faith of the world!' Bishop Firmus of Caesarea in Cappadocia and the papal legate Bishop Projectus noted that the Roman See had already pronounced sentence and given a canonical rule to Cyril before the synod met) (and requested that the acts of Session I be shown to the legates so they might formally confirm them).

Reconvening the next day, 11 July 431 (for Session III after reading the full record of Session I in their quarters) (the three Roman legates declared that the synod had proceeded in strict accordance with the canons). Speaking before the council (Presbyter Philip proclaimed that Peter the Prince and Head of the Apostles continues to live and exercise judgment in his successors in the Roman See down to the present day), and therefore Pope Celestine, through his legates and Cyril, ratified the deposition of Nestorius. Arcadius, Projectus, and Philip then subscribed the council's rolls alongside Cyril and the Eastern metropolitans (uniting West and East in one canonical decree).

The story inside

When Pope Celestine I learned that Emperor Theodosius II had summoned a general council (at Ephesus for Pentecost 431)(he dispatched two Italian bishops) (Arcadius and Projectus) (and his presbyter Philip with strict instructions to uphold the judgment of Rome (and work in concert with Cyril of Alexandria)). Delayed by sea voyages (the legates reached Ephesus in July and presented Celestine's letter at Session II on 10 July 431). After inspecting the complete minutes of Session I overnight, Philip, Arcadius (and Projectus stood before Session III on 11 July 431 to pronounce that the sentence against Nestorius stood firm by the authority of Blessed Peter's successor Pope Celestine and the whole ecumenical synod).

Lessons worth keeping

  1. 1

    Pope Celestine I sent Bishops Arcadius and Projectus and Presbyter Philip to Ephesus (with his letter of 8 May 431 exhorting the council to guard the apostolic faith).

  2. 2

    Upon hearing Celestine's letter read in Greek at Session II (10 July 431), the bishops acclaimed 'One Celestine, one Cyril, one faith of the synod, one faith of the world!'

  3. 3

    At Session III (11 July 431), after reviewing the acts of Session I (the Roman legates formally confirmed and subscribed the deposition of Nestorius).

Test your recall

How did the bishops at Session II of Ephesus respond to the reading of Pope Celestine I's letter, and what action did the Roman legates take at Session III?

Answer from memory first. Then check the summary and lessons above.

Notes & sources

3 notes

From Epistles of Pope Saint Celestine I and Acts of the Council of Ephesus (NPNF Series II, Vol. XIV), trans. Henry R. Percival (1900). Line numbers show where each passage appears in the digitized text.

  1. 1.
    Lines 20372–20374
    “Philip the presbyter and legate of the Apostolic See said: We bless the holy and adorable Trinity that our lowliness has been deemed worthy to attend your holy Synod. For a long time ago (7td^oci)our most holy and”
  2. 2.
    Lines 20508–20509
    “that by the favor of the Lord who maketh twain to be one, there will be peace, and that arms will be laid aside since the very cause defends itself.”
  3. 3.
    Lines 20665–20667
    “Juvenal the bishop of Jerusalem said to Arcadius and Projectus the most reverend bishops, and to Philip the most reverend presbyter; Yesterday while this holy and great synod was in session, when your holiness was”

Location: section 2 of 3 · 67%

Display settings