Skip to content
Atlas of Saints

Sancti Coelestini I Epistolae et Decreta (PL L)

Section 3 · Pope Saint Celestine I

Section III · Location 3 of 3

Section 3 · Open to read

From Sancti Coelestini I Epistolae et Decreta (PL L) by Pope Saint Celestine I

Edition: Epistles of Pope Saint Celestine I and Acts of the Council of Ephesus (NPNF Series II, Vol. XIV), trans. Henry R. Percival (1900)

The Eight Canons of the 200 Fathers of Ephesus, the Synodical Relation to Pope Celestine I, the Definition Against the Messalians, and Cyril's Formula of Reunion

Sancti Coelestini I Epistolae et Decreta (PL L) · Chapter 3 summary

In the concluding acts of the Council of Ephesus (lines 20769–22229), the orthodox fathers promulgate the Eight Canons condemning Nestorius, Caelestius (and clerical rebels) (issue the Session VI Definition forbidding any creed other than Nicaea after the orthodox (presbyter Charisius of Philadelphia exposes a Nestorian symbol composed by Theodore of Mopsuestia)) (protect the autocephalous rights of the Church of Cyprus in Session VII) (report their proceedings in the Synodical Letter to Pope Celestine I), and enact the synodal Definition against the Messalians (Euchites) along with decrees for Pamphylia and Thrace.

Atlas of Saints wrote this summary of section 3 of Sancti Coelestini I Epistolae et Decreta (PL L) by Pope Saint Celestine I. It uses our own words. It is not a quotation from the book.

Cite this summary

Atlas of Saints. “The Eight Canons of the 200 Fathers of Ephesus, the Synodical Relation to Pope Celestine I, the Definition Against the Messalians, and Cyril's Formula of Reunion” Summary of Sancti Coelestini I Epistolae et Decreta (PL L), by Pope Saint Celestine I. https://www.atlasofsaints.com/writings/epistolae-et-decreta-coelestini-i/chapters/3#atlas-answer

Section breakdown

Opening with the Eight Canons of the Council of Ephesus (lines 20769–21339) (the holy Synod establishes binding disciplinary rules against the Nestorian and Pelagian schisms). Canon I excommunicates any metropolitan who forsakes the ecumenical Synod and joins the schismatic 'apostasy' (the conciliabulum of John of Antioch) or embraces the opinions of Caelestius. Canons II–III depose bishops who signed Nestorius's deposition and then defected back (to the schismatics while restoring orthodox clerics deposed by Nestorius). Canon IV deposes clerics who fall into Nestorian or Caelestian heresy. Canon V declares that clerics condemned for canonical offenses cannot be restored uncanonically by Nestorius. Canon VI anathematizes laymen and deposes clerics who attempt to set aside the Council's decrees. And Following Session VI (Canon VII and Canon VIII enforce the creedal and jurisdictional decrees of the sixth and seventh sessions).

In the Session VI Definition of Faith (lines 21340–21605) (the orthodox presbyter and oeconomus Charisius of Philadelphia presents a formal complaint exposing how the emissaries James and Anthony used an exposition of faith composed by Theodore of Mopsuestia to trick weak Lydian Quarto-deciman converts into signing a Nestorian denial of the Theotokos under pretense of reconciliation). In response, the Council decrees that it is unlawful for any man to bring (forward, write, or compose a different Faith)(heteran pistin) as a rival to the Creed established by the holy Fathers assembled with the Holy Ghost at Nicaea (sentencing transgressing bishops and clerics to deposition and laymen to anathema). In Session VII (lines 21607–21789), after Rheginus, Archbishop of Constantia in Cyprus (testifies that the Bishop of Antioch has invaded Cyprus's ancient custom of ordaining its own metropolitan) (the Council decrees that the Prelates of Cyprus shall retain their ancient custom free from Antiochene encroachment and forbids any bishop to seize another province) (appending a synodal letter to Pamphylia regarding retired Bishop Eustathius and newly ordained Bishop Theodore).

In the Synodical Letter of the Council to Pope Celestine I (lines 21790–22025) (the fathers report to Rome how they waited sixteen days past the Pentecost summons for John of Antioch), deposed Nestorius after reading Celestine's and Cyril's letters (welcomed the Roman legates Arcadius), Projectus (and Philip in Sessions II–III) (cited Nestorius three times when he surrounded his house with soldiers), and expelled John of Antioch's schismatic party while condemning the Caelestian (Pelagian) commentaries. The acts close with two further synodal decrees. The *Definition against the Impious Messalians (also called Euchites or Enthusiasts, lines 22026–22192) (ratifying the Alexandrian and Constantinopolitan condemnations of the sect (anathematizing their book the Asceticon*), and deposing any cleric suspected of Messalianism who refuses to anathematize its errors) and the final Decree confirming Bishop Euprepius of Bizya and Cyriacus in Thrace while protecting orthodox Thracian clergy (lines 22193–22229).

The story inside

When the orthodox presbyter and oeconomus Charisius of Philadelphia stood before the sixth session (of the Council of Ephesus)(he laid on the table a counterfeit creed composed by Theodore of Mopsuestia (that Nestorian agents named James and Anthony had forced upon simple Lydian converts wishing to return to the Catholic Church)). Seeing how heretics smuggled Nestorian division into the Church under the disguise of new baptismal formulas (the Council promulgated its famous Definition: no one may ever compose or tender to converts any Creed other than the Creed of Nicaea) (under pain of deposition for bishops and clerics and anathema for laymen).

Lessons worth keeping

  1. 1

    In Canons I–VI (lines 20769–21339), the Council deposes metropolitans, bishops (and clerics who defect to John of Antioch's conciliabulum or embrace the doctrines of Nestorius and Caelestius), and protects orthodox clergy deposed by Nestorius.

  2. 2

    In Session VI (lines 21340–21605) (after the orthodox presbyter Charisius of Philadelphia exposes a Nestorian symbol by Theodore of Mopsuestia imposed by James and Anthony), the Council forbids composing or presenting any Creed other than Nicaea. In Session VII (lines 21607–21789)it upholds the independence of the Church of Cyprus under Archbishop Rheginus and settles (the Pamphylian episcopate of Eustathius and Theodore).

  3. 3

    In the Synodical Letter to Pope Celestine I (lines 21790–22025) and closing decrees (lines 22026–22229), the Council reports the deposition of Nestorius (the reception of legates Arcadius), Projectus, and Philip (and the condemnation of the Caelestians), and enacts the Definition against the Messalians (Euchites) and their book Asceticon alongside the Thracian decree for Bishop Euprepius.

Test your recall

What abuse exposed by the orthodox presbyter Charisius of Philadelphia led the Council of Ephesus in Session VI to forbid any Creed other than Nicaea, how did Session VII protect the Church of Cyprus, and what sect and book did the Council condemn in its Definition against the Messalians?

Answer from memory first. Then check the summary and lessons above.

Notes & sources

3 notes

From Epistles of Pope Saint Celestine I and Acts of the Council of Ephesus (NPNF Series II, Vol. XIV), trans. Henry R. Percival (1900). Line numbers show where each passage appears in the digitized text.

  1. 1.
    Lines 20781–20783
    “When we had assembled, according to the religious decree [of the Emperors], in the Metropolis of Ephesus, certain persons, a little more than thirty in number, withdrew from amongst us, having for the leader of”
  2. 2.
    Lines 21272–21274
    “This canon is interesting as shewing that thus early in the history of the Church, it was not unusual for those disciplined for their faults in one communion to go to another and there be welcomed and restored, to the”
  3. 3.
    Lines 21757–21759
    “in widowhood, and that the Savior's sheep should pass their time without a shepherd. But when he came to us weeping, not contending with the aforenamed most religious Bishop Theodore for his See or Church, but in”

Location: section 3 of 3 · 100%

Display settings