Skip to content
Atlas of Saints

Sancti Coelestini I Epistolae et Decreta (PL L)

Section 1 · Pope Saint Celestine I

Section I · Location 1 of 3

Section 1 · Open to read

From Sancti Coelestini I Epistolae et Decreta (PL L) by Pope Saint Celestine I

Edition: Epistles of Pope Saint Celestine I and Acts of the Council of Ephesus (NPNF Series II, Vol. XIV), trans. Henry R. Percival (1900)

Session I of Ephesus (AD 431): St. Cyril's Epistles to Nestorius, the Twelve Anathematisms, and the Decree of Deposition

Sancti Coelestini I Epistolae et Decreta (PL L) · Chapter 1 summary

In Session I of the Council of Ephesus (22 June 431), the bishops tested Cyril's Second and Third Epistles against Nestorius's teaching (set forth the Twelve Anathematisms with their counter-statements and theological defenses) (read Capreolus of Carthage's letter) (and deposed Nestorius in obedience to the canons and Pope Celestine I's letter).

Atlas of Saints wrote this summary of section 1 of Sancti Coelestini I Epistolae et Decreta (PL L) by Pope Saint Celestine I. It uses our own words. It is not a quotation from the book.

Cite this summary

Atlas of Saints. “Session I of Ephesus (AD 431): St. Cyril's Epistles to Nestorius, the Twelve Anathematisms, and the Decree of Deposition” Summary of Sancti Coelestini I Epistolae et Decreta (PL L), by Pope Saint Celestine I. https://www.atlasofsaints.com/writings/epistolae-et-decreta-coelestini-i/chapters/1#atlas-answer

Section breakdown

Following the Historical Introduction on the rise of the Nestorian controversy and the note (on Emperor Theodosius II's convocation edict)(the First Session of the Third Ecumenical Council assembled in the Church of Mary (at Ephesus on 22 June 431 under the presidency of Cyril of Alexandria)). After recounting how Nestorius had rejected three canonical citations and surrounded his house (with armed soldiers, the bishops had the Nicene Creed read aloud as the standard of faith and listened to Cyril's Second Epistle to Nestorius)('The Catholic Epistle', 'Obloquuntur'), which proved that the Eternal Word united human flesh hypostatically to Himself in (the Virgin's womb so that Emmanuel is one Lord and Mary is truly Mother of God)(Theotokos). At the motion of Palladius of Amasea, Nestorius's reply ('Obloquy of mine...') was read and unanimously anathematized by the bishops. Juvenal of Jerusalem then called for the letter of Pope Celestine I and the Roman Synod. Next comes Peter the primicerius of the notaries reading Cyril's synodal Third Epistle ('Cum Salvator noster').

Appended to Cyril's Third Epistle stand the famous Twelve Anathematisms, which the volume prints alongside Nestorius's Twelve Counter-Anathematisms (the critical objections of Theodoret of Cyrus and Andrew of Samosata) (Cyril's detailed apologetic explanations), and two doctrinal Excursuses on the word Theotokos ('Mother of God') and on how our Lord wrought miracles. Across the Twelve Anathematisms (Cyril condemns anyone who denies that Emmanuel is truly God and therefore the holy (Virgin is Mother of God)) (anyone who divides the one Christ after the union into two persons joined only by dignity or authority), anyone who calls Christ a mere God-bearing man rather than the Word made flesh (or anyone who denies that the Eucharistic flesh of the Lord is life-giving because (it is the very flesh of the Divine Word)).

In the closing portion of Session I (Bishop Flavian of Philippi moved that extracts from the Fathers and from Nestorius's own (writings be entered into the record)), and the council read the letter sent from North Africa by Archbishop Capreolus of Carthage (brought by his deacon Bessula) (which urged the synod to uphold the ancient apostolic faith and repress novel doctrines (already condemned by the Apostolic See and the bishops)). Compelled both by the sacred canons and by the letter of their most holy father and fellow-minister Celestine (Bishop of the Roman Church), the synod pronounced solemn sentence in the name of our Lord Jesus Christ (whom Nestorius had blasphemed) deposing Nestorius from the episcopal dignity and excluding him from all priestly communion.

The story inside

Inside the Great Church of St. Mary at Ephesus on 22 June 431, after Nestorius refused three formal summonses (the assembled bishops heard the Nicene Creed), Cyril's Second Epistle, and Nestorius's reply (crying out with one voice to anathematize anyone who refused to confess that God (the Word was born of the Virgin)). After Peter the primicerius read Cyril's Third Epistle with the Twelve Anathematisms (and the synod received Archbishop Capreolus of Carthage's letter against doctrinal novelties)(the fathers decreed the deposition of Nestorius) (explicitly declaring that they acted under the compulsion of the canons and the letter (of Pope Celestine of Rome)).

Lessons worth keeping

  1. 1

    At Session I of Ephesus (22 June 431), the bishops tested Cyril's Second Epistle ('Obloquuntur') and Nestorius's reply against the Nicene Creed before reading Pope Celestine's letter and Cyril's Third Epistle.

  2. 2

    Cyril's Twelve Anathematisms (paired in the volume with Nestorius's Twelve Counter-Anathematisms, Theodoret's criticisms, and Excursuses on Theotokos and Christ's miracles) define the hypostatic union and the life-giving Eucharistic flesh of the Word.

  3. 3

    After hearing Flavian of Philippi's motion and Archbishop Capreolus of Carthage's letter (the council deposed Nestorius as 'compelled thereto by the canons and by the letter of our most holy father and fellow-servant Coelestine), the Roman bishop.'

Test your recall

How did Session I of the Council of Ephesus proceed from the reading of Cyril's Second and Third Epistles and the Twelve Anathematisms to Capreolus of Carthage's letter and the final decree deposing Nestorius?

Answer from memory first. Then check the summary and lessons above.

Notes & sources

3 notes

From Epistles of Pope Saint Celestine I and Acts of the Council of Ephesus (NPNF Series II, Vol. XIV), trans. Henry R. Percival (1900). Line numbers show where each passage appears in the digitized text.

  1. 1.
    Lines 18156–18158
    “Excursus to Canon iv., On Pelagianism. Excursus to Canon vii., On the words tugtiv exepocv A Letter from the Synod to the Synod in Pamphylia.”
  2. 2.
    Lines 18862–18864
    “priests and bishops of God. For it is not possible for us to overlook the churches thus troubled, and the people scandalized, and the right faith set aside, and the sheep scattered by you, who ought to save them, if indeed”
  3. 3.
    Lines 19619–19621
    “For the wise Evangelist, introducing the Word as become flesh, shows him economically submitting himself to his own flesh and going through the laws of his own nature. But it belongs to humanity to increase in stature”

Location: section 1 of 3 · 33%

Display settings