Skip to content
Atlas of Saints

The Philosophy of Teaching (De Magistro)

Section 1 · Saint Augustine of Hippo

Section I · Location 1 of 4

Section 1 · Open to read

From The Philosophy of Teaching (De Magistro) by Saint Augustine of Hippo

Edition: The Philosophy of Teaching (De Magistro), trans. Fr. Francis E. Tourscher, O.S.A. (1924)

Chapters I–IV: Why We Speak, How We Pray, and Whether Signs Can Show Things Without Other Signs

The Philosophy of Teaching (De Magistro) · Chapter 1 summary

Human speech aims either to teach or to remind. Words are audible signs, and while some bodily actions not already under way can be shown directly by performing them, words in conversation ordinarily explain signs by means of other signs.

Atlas of Saints wrote this summary of section 1 of The Philosophy of Teaching (De Magistro) by Saint Augustine of Hippo. It uses our own words. It is not a quotation from the book.

Cite this summary

Atlas of Saints. “Chapters I–IV: Why We Speak, How We Pray, and Whether Signs Can Show Things Without Other Signs” Summary of The Philosophy of Teaching (De Magistro), by Saint Augustine of Hippo. https://www.atlasofsaints.com/writings/de-magistro/chapters/1#atlas-answer

Section breakdown

In Chapter I, Augustine asks Adeodatus what people intend to do when they speak. Adeodatus answers that we speak either to teach or to learn. Augustine points out that even when we ask a question in order to learn, our spoken words are meant to teach the other person what we wish to hear. Adeodatus then suggests that we sometimes speak only to remind ourselves or others. Adeodatus also raises the objection that people sing for pleasure rather than to teach or recall. Augustine replies that the pleasure of song comes from musical rhythm and melody, which can be played on a flute or harp without any words at all. Speech itself belongs to the words, not the tune.

Adeodatus next asks about prayer. We pray to God. In response, we cannot suppose that we are teaching Him anything new or reminding Him of something He forgot. Augustine answers that Christ commanded His followers to pray in the closed inner chamber of the heart (Matthew 6:6), which signifies the quiet recesses of the rational soul, the temple of God (1 Corinthians 3:16; Psalm 4:5–6). God does not need spoken words to hear the heart's desire. Priests pray aloud in the liturgy. In response, they speak so that the people may hear and lift their minds to God. Jesus established His disciples the Lord's Prayer. In response, He did not teach them mere syllables. However, realities by means of words, so that believers might remind themselves to whom they pray and what they should ask. Even when we think through an argument silently, our memory turns over stored words to bring the realities they signify back to mind.

In Chapter II, father and son agree that all words are signs. That nothing can be a sign unless it signifies something. To test this rule, Augustine quotes an eight-word Latin line from Virgil's Aeneid (Book II, line 159): "Si nihil ex tanta superis placet urbe relinqui" ("If it pleases the powers above that nothing be left of so great a city"). Asked to explain what each word signifies, Adeodatus says that "si" ("if") signifies hesitation in the mind. When he reaches the second word, "nihil" ("nothing"), he declares it signifies that which does not exist. Augustine objects that if "nothing" signifies what is not, then it does not signify anything and cannot be a sign. Yet no sensible speaker utters the word "nothing" in vain. Augustine suggests that "nihil" signifies the state of the mind itself when it looks for an object and finds, or thinks it finds. Moreover, the object does not exist. Jokeingly warning that they must not let "nothing" delay them, Augustine moves on to the third word, "ex" ("out of"). Adeodatus offers the synonym "de" ("from") and defines it as separation from a place. Augustine points out the flaw in this method. Adeodatus has only explained words by means of other words (well-known signs by means of other signs) without showing the realities themselves.

In Chapter III, Adeodatus protests that in a conversation conducted in words, he can only answer with words. Augustine asks whether someone questioned about the word "paries" ("wall") could point to a wall with his finger. Moreover, he could show the reality without speaking. Adeodatus agrees that pointing works for visible bodies and visible bodily qualities like color, though not for sounds, smells, tastes, weight, or heat. Augustine adds that deaf people converse at length by gesture and that stage actors unfold entire stories through silent movement. Yet Adeodatus sees that a pointing finger or an actor's gesture is still a sign, not the wall or reality itself.

Augustine then asks what would happen if someone asked what walking is. At the same time, Adeodatus was sitting still, and Adeodatus simply stood up and walked. Adeodatus admits that thousands of actions (eating, drinking, sitting, standing, shouting) can be shown directly. He does this by doing them after the question is asked. This holds provided that the person is not already doing them. Adeodatus were already walking when asked what walking is, and tried to show it by walking faster. In that case, the questioner might mistake "walking" for "hurrying." Adeodatus adds one exception. Someone asks what speaking is while we are speaking. In that case, we must continue speaking in order to make it clear, showing speech by means of speech itself.

In Chapter IV, Augustine summarizes their three-part division: first, showing signs by means of signs. Second, he shows realities that are not signs by performing them after a question. Third, he shows realities by giving signs that direct the mind's attention. Examining the first group, they note that spoken words belong to hearing, gestures belong to sight. Written words are visible signs of audible words. Adeodatus names four nouns (Romulus, Rome, virtue, and river) which are audible signs of visible or intelligible realities. The word "noun" (nomen), in turn, is an audible sign of those audible signs.

Augustine next shows that every articulate sound uttered with meaning is a "word" (verbum). Specifically, this cites a line from Terence's Andria ("Fair words I ask"). Every horse is an animal and every word is a sign. In the same way, even though "sign" also has a narrower sense for military standards (signa militaria) and verbum has a narrower grammatical sense for verbs—so every noun is a word, though words like "si" and "ex" are not nouns in the ordinary sense. Finally, they discover that certain signs signify themselves along with other signs: "sign" is itself a sign, "word" is itself a word, and "noun" is itself a noun. By contrast, the four-syllable noun "conjunction" (conjunctio) signifies words that are not nouns and therefore does not signify itself.

The story inside

At age fifteen, Adeodatus sat down with his father Augustine to ask a simple question. What are we trying to do whenever we speak? By testing everyday habits (asking questions, singing, praying in the quiet of the heart, pointing at a wall, and rising to walk) they discovered that spoken and written words are signs that point beyond themselves. That explaining one word with another word still leaves us inside a circle of signs.

Lessons worth keeping

  1. 1

    All human speech aims either to teach or to remind. Even asking a question teaches the listener what the questioner wants to know.

  2. 2

    True prayer happens silently in the inner temple of the mind. At the same time, spoken prayers remind the person praying or teach others.

  3. 3

    Pointing a finger or acting out a story in pantomime still uses visible signs. Only an action performed afresh after a question (or speaking itself) shows a reality directly.

  4. 4

    Written words are visible signs of spoken words, and general terms like 'sign', 'word', and 'noun' signify themselves as well as other signs.

Test your recall

Why does Augustine say that we do not use words to teach or remind God when we pray, and what purpose do spoken prayers like the Lord's Prayer serve?

Answer from memory first. Then check the summary and lessons above.

Notes & sources

3 notes

From The Philosophy of Teaching (De Magistro), trans. Fr. Francis E. Tourscher, O.S.A. (1924). Line numbers show where each passage appears in the digitized text.

  1. 1.
    Lines 550–553
    “AUGUSTINE—What, as it appears to you, do we”
  2. 2.
    Lines 689–694
    “because we are thinking words, we are speaking”
  3. 3.
    Lines 1288–1290
    “among other things that they symbolize, symbolize”

Location: section 1 of 4 · 25%

Display settings