Section II · Location 2 of 3
Section 2 · Open to readFrom Contra Julianum by Saint Cyril of Alexandria
Edition: Pro Christiana Religione Adversus Julianum Imperatorem (and Letters and Fragments Against Julian), trans. Jean Aubert (Migne PG 76) and Wilmer Cave Wright (1863)
Sections 4–5: The Defense of Theotokos, Correspondence with Pope Celestine I, the Twelve Anathemas, and the Council of Ephesus (AD 431)
Contra Julianum · Chapter 2 summary
When Nestorius and his chaplain Anastasios preached at Constantinople against calling the Virgin Mary Theotokos (Cyril defended the hypostatic union in his Paschal and Dogmatic Letters) (appealed to Pope Celestine I in Rome), issued the Twelve Anathemas (and presided over the Third Ecumenical Council at Ephesus in June–July 431).
Atlas of Saints wrote this summary of section 2 of Contra Julianum by Saint Cyril of Alexandria. It uses our own words. It is not a quotation from the book.
Cite this summary
Atlas of Saints. “Sections 4–5: The Defense of Theotokos, Correspondence with Pope Celestine I, the Twelve Anathemas, and the Council of Ephesus (AD 431)” Summary of Contra Julianum, by Saint Cyril of Alexandria. https://www.atlasofsaints.com/writings/contra-julianum-cyril-of-alexandria/chapters/2#atlas-answer
Section breakdown
Soon after Nestorius became Patriarch of Constantinople in 428 (his Antiochene chaplain Anastasios declared from the pulpit: 'Let no one call Mary Theotokos). For Mary was only a woman. It is impossible that God should be born of a woman.' When Bishop Dorotheos cried out 'Anathema to anyone who calls Mary Theotokos!' and Nestorius himself preached a series of sermons rejecting the title in favor of Christotokos (Egyptian monks and Constantinople's faithful appealed to Cyril). In his Paschal Letter of 429 and his encyclical to the monks of Egypt (Cyril explained that Mary did not generate the divine nature) (but because she bore according to the flesh the Word united hypostatically to humanity) (she is truly Mother of God).
After his first fraternal letter to Nestorius drew a haughty refusal, Cyril sent his famous Second (Dogmatic) Letter in early 430 and submitted the entire dossier (translated into Latin by Deacon Posidonius) to Pope Celestine I in Rome. Holding a Roman synod in August 430 (Pope Celestine condemned Nestorius's teaching and commissioned Cyril as plenipotentiary of the Apostolic See to excommunicate and depose Nestorius unless he recanted in writing within ten days). In November 430 an Alexandrian synod sent Nestorius Pope Celestine's decree alongside Cyril's Third Letter containing the Twelve Anathemas. Meanwhile, Emperor Theodosius II convoked a general council to meet at Ephesus at Pentecost (7 June 431).
After waiting fifteen days past Pentecost at Ephesus while John of Antioch lingered on the road (Cyril and nearly two hundred bishops opened the Council in the double church of St). Mary on 22 June 431 despite the protests of the imperial commissioner Count Candidian. In a single day-long session, the bishops read the Nicene Creed, approved Cyril's Second and Third Letters (heard witnesses and extracts from Nestorius's works) (and deposed Nestorius). Four days later John of Antioch arrived with forty-three Syrian bishops and held (a rival conciliabulum purporting to depose Cyril and Memnon, but on 10–11 July 431 Pope Celestine's legates)(Bishops Arcadius and Projectus and Presbyter Philip) arrived from Rome and solemnly confirmed the acts of Session I.
The story inside
In 430, before taking final action against the Patriarch of the imperial capital (Cyril compiled a complete Greek and Latin file of Nestorius's sermons and his own letters and entrusted it to his deacon Posidonius for delivery to Pope Celestine I in Rome). At a Roman synod in August 430 (Celestine judged Cyril's doctrine identical with the apostolic faith and appointed Cyril to execute the sentence of Rome and Alexandria jointly). Moreover, Nestorius stood cut off from the universal Church unless he condemned his errors within ten days.
Lessons worth keeping
- 1
When Anastasios and Nestorius attacked the title Theotokos at Constantinople in 428–429 (Cyril defended the hypostatic union in his Paschal Letter and Dogmatic Letter).
- 2
In August 430 Pope Celestine I held a Roman synod condemning Nestorius and empowered (Cyril to execute the sentence if Nestorius did not recant within ten days).
- 3
On 22 June 431 Cyril and nearly 200 bishops deposed Nestorius at Ephesus. On 10–11 July 431 the Roman legates Arcadius, Projectus, and Philip confirmed the council's decree.
Test your recall
What triggered the public controversy over the title Theotokos in Constantinople in 428, and how did Pope Celestine I respond when Cyril sent Deacon Posidonius to Rome in 430?
Answer from memory first. Then check the summary and lessons above.
Notes & sources
3 notesFrom Pro Christiana Religione Adversus Julianum Imperatorem (and Letters and Fragments Against Julian), trans. Jean Aubert (Migne PG 76) and Wilmer Cave Wright (1863). Line numbers show where each passage appears in the digitized text.
- 1.Lines 9641–9643
“cannot be born of a human being." He proposed the word Christotokos instead. Then a bishop, Dorotheos of Markianopolis in Asia Minor, who”
- 2.Lines 9829–9831
“and Alexandria was wrong. St Cyril then, "com- pelled/ ' as he says, "by the command of God who demands vigilance, and by the ancient custom of”
- 3.Lines 10025–10027
“of monks at Ephesus from interfering. And Pope Celestin approved of the summoning of the council and sent his legates, Arcadius and Projectus, both”
