Section III · Location 3 of 3
Section 3 · Open to readFrom Contra Julianum by Saint Cyril of Alexandria
Edition: Pro Christiana Religione Adversus Julianum Imperatorem (and Letters and Fragments Against Julian), trans. Jean Aubert (Migne PG 76) and Wilmer Cave Wright (1863)
Sections 6–10: The Reunion of 433 with John of Antioch, Cyril's Final Years, Table of Dates, and His Works Including the Ten Books Against Julian the Apostate
Contra Julianum · Chapter 3 summary
After two years of negotiation following Ephesus (John of Antioch signed the Formula of Reunion in 433 accepting Mary as Theotokos and the condemnation of Nestorius) (driving extreme Nestorians eastward through Edessa and Nisibis into the Persian Church while Cyril governed Alexandria until his death on 27 June 444 and left behind his massive doctrinal corpus including his refutation of Emperor Julian's three books Against the Christians).
Atlas of Saints wrote this summary of section 3 of Contra Julianum by Saint Cyril of Alexandria. It uses our own words. It is not a quotation from the book.
Cite this summary
Atlas of Saints. “Sections 6–10: The Reunion of 433 with John of Antioch, Cyril's Final Years, Table of Dates, and His Works Including the Ten Books Against Julian the Apostate” Summary of Contra Julianum, by Saint Cyril of Alexandria. https://www.atlasofsaints.com/writings/contra-julianum-cyril-of-alexandria/chapters/3#atlas-answer
Section breakdown
Because Count Candidian had initially sent a partial report from Ephesus (Emperor Theodosius II at first detained both Cyril and Nestorius until Pope Celestine's legates and the conciliar fathers made the truth known at Constantinople). Nestorius was deposed and retired to his former monastery at Antioch before being banished to Petra and Upper Egypt. There, he died quietly around 439 (though Bethune-Baker in 1908 argued he survived until 451). After two years of correspondence, Bishop John of Antioch and the moderate Syrian bishops (signed the Formula of Reunion in 433: John accepted the condemnation of Nestorius and the title Theotokos)('Mother of God'). Meanwhile (Cyril signed a joint confession affirming that Christ is consubstantial with the Father as to His Godhead and consubstantial with us as to His manhood in a union of two natures without confusion), which Cyril celebrated in his thirty-ninth Epistle ('the symbol of Ephesus').
Refusing the peace of 433, the extreme partisans of Nestorius (who revered Diodore of Tarsus and Theodore of Mopsuestia as their masters) rallied around Bishop Ibas at the theological school of Edessa until Emperor Zeno closed the school in 489. Crossing the Roman frontier into the Persian Empire, the scholar Barsumas, Bishop of Nisibis, (persuaded the Persian King Perozes)(457–484)to expel orthodox Catholics and make Nestorianism the sole tolerated Christian confession in Persia (under the Catholicos of Seleucia-Ctesiphon). This ancient Nestorian church spread across Mesopotamia, Malabar in India, and China (as recorded on the monument of Singan-fu), and survives in the mountains of Kurdistan and around Lake Urmiah (under its hereditary Patriarch Mar Simeon under the name 'Meshihaye')(Messiah-men).
Cyril spent the last eleven years of his life governing the Patriarchate of Alexandria (in peace until his death on 27 June 444 after a thirty-two-year episcopate)(kept as his feast on June 9 in the Greek Menaia and on February 9 in the Roman calendar. There, Pope Leo XIII proclaimed him a Doctor of the Church in 1882). In his survey of Cyril's theology and ten-volume Migne corpus (PG 68–77), Fortescue highlights Cyril's scriptural commentaries (his anti-Arian 'Thesaurus' and dialogues on the Trinity) (his five books against Nestorius) (his Paschal Homilies fixing the Alexandrian date of Easter), his letters, and his great apologetic treatise 'For the Holy Religion (of the Christians Against the Books of the Atheist Julian')('Contra Julianum')—composed in answer to Emperor Julian the Apostate's three books 'Against the Christians' (and dedicated to Emperor Theodosius II)(of which Books I–X and Greek and Syriac fragments survive).
The story inside
When Bishop John of Antioch and the Syrian moderates sought to heal the schism (after Ephesus without surrendering the truth of Christ's complete humanity)(they sent a confession of faith to Alexandria in 433 acknowledging the Blessed Virgin (as Theotokos and affirming one Christ in two natures united without confusion)). Rather than insisting on his own earlier verbal formulas where orthodox faith was secure, (Cyril welcomed the confession with joy in his thirty-ninth Epistle)('the symbol of Ephesus') (restoring communion between Alexandria), Antioch (and Rome while leaving only the obstinate partisans of Nestorius outside the peace of the Church).
Lessons worth keeping
- 1
In 433 John of Antioch and Cyril sealed the Formula of Reunion ('the symbol of Ephesus' in Epistle 39) (confessing one Christ and Mary as Theotokos while Nestorius went into exile and died around 439).
- 2
Driven from the school of Edessa in 489, followers of Diodore, Theodore, Ibas (and Barsumas of Nisibis established the Nestorian church in the Persian Empire) (surviving among the Kurdistan and Urmiah 'Meshihaye' under Mar Simeon).
- 3
Cyril died on 27 June 444 (feast June 9 in Greece, February 9 in Rome. Doctor of the Church under Leo XIII) (leaving a vast corpus crowned by his apologetic refutation of Emperor Julian's three books Against the Christians).
Test your recall
How did Cyril and John of Antioch seal the Reunion of 433, how did Nestorianism spread through Edessa and Nisibis into Persia, and when did Cyril of Alexandria die?
Answer from memory first. Then check the summary and lessons above.
Notes & sources
3 notesFrom Pro Christiana Religione Adversus Julianum Imperatorem (and Letters and Fragments Against Julian), trans. Jean Aubert (Migne PG 76) and Wilmer Cave Wright (1863). Line numbers show where each passage appears in the digitized text.
- 1.Lines 10206–10208
“but couldn't, when we stood in the double church became tre- mendously excited, and for the first time said something in* telligible : /tdXtara, /-tdXwTa, iravayla 0cot6kos ! All the Turks in”
- 2.Lines 10379–10381
“of his last acts was a prudent and charitable one. He stopped an agitation among Catholics to have Theodore of Mopsuestia condemned too. It is true”
- 3.Lines 10547–10549
“Gospel acc. to St Luke by S. Cyril (Oxford, 1859, 2 vols, 8vo), and W. Wright, Fragments of the Homilies of Cyril of Alex, on the Gospel ofS. Luke,”
