Skip to content
Atlas of Saints

Contra Julianum

Section 1 · Saint Cyril of Alexandria

Section I · Location 1 of 3

Section 1 · Open to read

From Contra Julianum by Saint Cyril of Alexandria

Edition: Pro Christiana Religione Adversus Julianum Imperatorem (and Letters and Fragments Against Julian), trans. Jean Aubert (Migne PG 76) and Wilmer Cave Wright (1863)

Sections 1–3: Cyril's Early Life under Uncle Theophilos, the Oak-Tree Synod, Patriarch of Alexandria, the Novatians, the Jews, Hypatia, and the Rise of Nestorius

Contra Julianum · Chapter 1 summary

Tracing Cyril's early life under his uncle Patriarch Theophilos and his turbulent first years as Patriarch of Alexandria (412–428) (Fortescue examines the historical evidence surrounding the Novatians), the Jews (the murder of Hypatia in 415) (and the rise of Nestorius's Christological error at Constantinople).

Atlas of Saints wrote this summary of section 1 of Contra Julianum by Saint Cyril of Alexandria. It uses our own words. It is not a quotation from the book.

Cite this summary

Atlas of Saints. “Sections 1–3: Cyril's Early Life under Uncle Theophilos, the Oak-Tree Synod, Patriarch of Alexandria, the Novatians, the Jews, Hypatia, and the Rise of Nestorius” Summary of Contra Julianum, by Saint Cyril of Alexandria. https://www.atlasofsaints.com/writings/contra-julianum-cyril-of-alexandria/chapters/1#atlas-answer

Section breakdown

Born at Alexandria around 376 (Cyril received a thorough education in both Greek letters and Christian theology before accompanying his uncle), Patriarch Theophilos, to the Synod of the Oak (AD 403) that deposed St. John Chrysostom. Out of loyalty to his uncle's memory, Cyril resisted restoring Chrysostom's name (to the Alexandrian diptychs until 417, when St). Isidore of Pelusium persuaded him to yield for the peace of the Church. Elected Patriarch of Alexandria on 17 October 412 after a three-day contest with Archdeacon Timothy (Cyril moved swiftly to close the churches of the Novatian schismatics and clashed with the imperial prefect Orestes after a violent conflict between Alexandrian Jews and Christians led to the expulsion of the Jewish faction and the descent of five hundred Nitrian monks into the city).

In March 415, a fanatical street mob led by a minor cleric (lector) named Peter waylaid the famous Neoplatonist philosopher and mathematician Hypatia (daughter of Theon and close adviser to Prefect Orestes) dragged her to the Kaisarion church (and murdered her). Examining the contemporary historian Socrates Scholasticus (Hist. Eccl. VII.15), who had no fondness for Cyril (Fortescue shows that Socrates attributes the crime directly to Peter the Reader and his conspirators and merely remarks that the outrage brought disgrace upon Cyril and the Alexandrian Church). By contrast (only the sixth-century pagan Damascius later invented the charge that Cyril plotted her death out of jealousy—a slander popularized in modern English fiction by Charles Kingsley).

Section 3 sets forth the theological crisis that called forth Cyril's lifelong defense of the Incarnation. In 428 Emperor Theodosius II appointed the Antiochene monk and preacher Nestorius as Patriarch of Constantinople. Trained in the extreme Antiochene school of Diodore of Tarsus and Theodore of Mopsuestia, (Nestorius confused concrete nature with person)(hypostasis) and argued that because God the Word is immutable (He could not personally become man or be born of a woman). Instead, the Word dwelt in the human Jesus of Nazareth by a moral union of favor and dignity (making Christ a God-bearing man rather than God incarnate).

The story inside

In 417, five years after Cyril succeeded his uncle Theophilos on the throne of St. Mark, the aged monk St. Isidore of Pelusium wrote a blunt letter from his desert monastery to the young Patriarch of Alexandria. For fourteen years Cyril had refused to insert the name of the exiled St. John Chrysostom into the liturgical diptychs of Alexandria because his uncle Theophilos had led (the Synod of the Oak against Chrysostom). Isidore warned Cyril not to let family partiality perpetuate a schism with Rome and Antioch. Accepting the rebuke, Cyril restored Chrysostom's name to the diptychs and re-established full communion across the Christian world.

Lessons worth keeping

  1. 1

    Educated at Alexandria and present at the Synod of the Oak (403), Cyril became Patriarch in 412 and restored St. John Chrysostom's name to the diptychs in 417.

  2. 2

    Contemporary testimony in Socrates Scholasticus (VII.15) shows that Hypatia was murdered in March 415 by a mob led by Peter the Reader (not by Cyril's order).

  3. 3

    Appointed Patriarch of Constantinople in 428, Nestorius taught a moral union between the Word (and the man Jesus, denying that Mary is truly Mother of God)(Theotokos).

Test your recall

What does the contemporary historian Socrates Scholasticus actually record about the murder of Hypatia in 415, and what Christological error did Nestorius bring from Antioch in 428?

Answer from memory first. Then check the summary and lessons above.

Notes & sources

3 notes

From Pro Christiana Religione Adversus Julianum Imperatorem (and Letters and Fragments Against Julian), trans. Jean Aubert (Migne PG 76) and Wilmer Cave Wright (1863). Line numbers show where each passage appears in the digitized text.

  1. 1.
    Lines 9037–9039
    “undeserved unpopularity chiefly because during his reign a Christian mob murdered Hypatia. He is not the most attractive of the”
  2. 2.
    Lines 9243–9245
    “only is there no sort of evidence that he had any- thing to do with it, there are positive reasons for knowing that he had not. After the murder a depu-”
  3. 3.
    Lines 9449–9451
    “Christ was born as a little child, grew in wisdom and age and grace, 1 was surprised, 2 wept, 8 suf- fered pain, died. None of these things can be true”

Location: section 1 of 3 · 33%

Display settings