Section II · Location 2 of 4
Section 2 · Open to readFrom Treatise on Purgatory (Trattato del Purgatorio) by Saint Catherine of Genoa
Edition: The Treatise on Purgatory by St. Catherine of Genoa, Translated from the Original Italian, With a Preface by Very Rev. H. E. Manning, D.D., trans. Henry Edward Manning (Editor and Preface) (1858)
Section 2 — Chapters V–VIII: The Single Loaf of Bread and Why the Unclean Soul Casts Itself into Purgatory
Treatise on Purgatory (Trattato del Purgatorio) · Chapter 2 summary
Illustrating the soul's vehement hunger for God by the parable of a single loaf (of bread able to feed the whole world by its sight alone)(Catherine explains why an imperfectly cleansed soul willingly plunges into Purgatory).
Atlas of Saints wrote this summary of section 2 of Treatise on Purgatory (Trattato del Purgatorio) by Saint Catherine of Genoa. It uses our own words. It is not a quotation from the book.
Cite this summary
Atlas of Saints. “Section 2 — Chapters V–VIII: The Single Loaf of Bread and Why the Unclean Soul Casts Itself into Purgatory” Summary of Treatise on Purgatory (Trattato del Purgatorio), by Saint Catherine of Genoa. https://www.atlasofsaints.com/writings/treatise-on-purgatory/chapters/2#atlas-answer
Section breakdown
To explain the vehement longing by which God draws the purified soul to Himself, Catherine proposes a vivid comparison. Suppose there existed in the whole world only one loaf of bread capable (of satisfying the hunger of every living creature simply by being seen). Furthermore, a healthy man knew nothing else could feed him. The nearer he approached that bread without yet seeing it, the more intensely his hunger and craving would grow. If he knew he would never behold the bread, his hunger would be a living hell. He knew for certain that he would soon behold and feast upon it. In that case, his hope would sustain him even amid intolerable craving. Jesus Christ is that true Bread of the soul.
On God's part, Paradise has no locked gate. God is all mercy and stands with open arms to welcome us into His glory. Yet the Divine Essence is of such unimaginable purity that if a soul perceived (within itself even the smallest mote of imperfection)(it would cast itself into a thousand hells rather than stand stained before the Divine Majesty). Finding Purgatory ordained by God to take away its blemishes (the soul plunges into it willingly as a great mercy).
The story inside
The aim here is to help her listeners grasp why a soul already pardoned (by God suffers such piercing pain). At the same time, she waited for the beatific vision. Catherine asked them to imagine a starving man walking toward the only loaf (of bread in the world—a loaf whose mere sight satisfies all hunger). The man is healthy and certain that he will soon see the bread. Therefore, every step closer makes any delay more acute until the veil is lifted.
Lessons worth keeping
- 1
The keenest pain in Purgatory comes not from fear of punishment. However, from the soul's clear perception that its own voluntary faults delay its embrace of God's infinite goodness.
- 2
Purgatory is not an external barrier erected by a reluctant God. However, a merciful provision for souls that cannot bear to enter spotless Holiness while still carrying a blemish.
Test your recall
What does the single loaf of bread in Chapter VI represent, and why would a soul with a single mote of imperfection refuse to enter Paradise before being cleansed?
Answer from memory first. Then check the summary and lessons above.
Notes & sources
2 notesFrom The Treatise on Purgatory by St. Catherine of Genoa, Translated from the Original Italian, With a Preface by Very Rev. H. E. Manning, D.D., trans. Henry Edward Manning (Editor and Preface) (1858). Line numbers show where each passage appears in the digitized text.
- 1.Lines 746–866
“CHAPTER V. THE PEACE AND JOY OF PURGATORY. The souls in Purgatory having their wills perfectly conformed to the will of God, and hence partaking of His goodness, remain satisfied with their Digitized by Google 1 6 A Treatise condition, which is one of entire freedom from the guilt of sin. For when they passed out of this life, penitent, with all their sins confessed and resolved to sin no more, God straightway pardoned them ; and now they are as pure as when they were created ; the rust of sin alone is left, and this they get rid of by the punishment of fire. Cleansed thus from all sin, and united in will to God, they see God clearly according to the degree of light He imparts to them ; they are conscious too what a thing it is for them to enjoy God, that for this very end souls were created. Again, there is in them a conformity of will so uniting them to God, so drawing them to Him Digitized by Google on Purgatory. 17 through that natural instinct whereby God is, as it were, bound up with the soul, that no description, no figure, no example can give a clear idea of it as it is actually felt and apprehended by inward conscious- ness ; nevertheless I will mention something like it which suggests itself to me. CHAPTER VI. COMPARISON TO EXPLAIN THE IM- PETUOSITY AND LOVE BY WHICH THE SOULS IN PURGATORY DESIRE TO ENJOY GOD. Let us suppose that there existed in the world but one loaf ot bread to satisfy the hunger of every creature, and that the mere sight of it could Digitized by Google 1 8 A Treatise do this. In such a case a man, hav- ing naturally, if in good health, a desire for food, would find himself, so long as he was kept from dying or falling sick, getting more and more hungry; for his craving would continue undiminished, — he would know that the bread, and nothing but the bread, could satisfy him, and not being able to reach it, would remain in intolerablepain ; the nearer he got tothebreadwithoutseeingit,themore ardently would he crave for it, and would direct himself wholly towards it, as being the only thing which could afford relief ; and if he were assured that he never could see the bread he would have within him a perfect hell, and become like the Digitized by Google on Purgatory. 19 damned, who are cut off from all hopeofeverseeingGod their Saviour, who is the true Bread. The souls in purgatory, on the other hand, hope to see that Bread, and satiate themselves to the full therewith ; whence they hunger and suffer pain as great as will be their capacity of enjoying that Bread, which is Jesus Christ the true God, our Saviour and our love.”
- 2.Lines 946–1011
“CHAPTER VIII. THE NECESSITY OF PURGATORY, AND HOW TERRIBLE IT IS. Again I say that, on God's part, I see paradise has no gate, but that whosoever will may enter therein ; for God is all mercy, and stands with open arms to admit us to His glory. But still I see that the Being of God is so pure (far more than one can imagine), that should a soul see in itself even the least mote of im- perfection, it would rather cast itself into a thousand hells than go with that spot into the presence of the Divine Majesty. Therefore, seeing purgatory ordained to take away such blemishes, it plunges therein, Digitized by Google I on Purgatory. 23 and deems it a great mercy that it can thus remove them. No tongue can express, no mind can understand, how dreadful is purgatory. Its pain is like that of hell ; and yet (as I have said) I see any soul with the least stain of im- perfection accept it as a mercy, not thinking it of any moment when compared with being kept from its Love. It appears to me that the gtearest pain the souls in purgatory endure proceeds from their being sensible of something in themselves displeasing to God, and that it has been done voluntarily against so much goodness ; for, being in a state of grace, they know the truth, and how grievous is any obstacle Digitized by Google 24 A Treatise which does not let them approach God.”
