Skip to content
Atlas of Saints

Summa Theologica

Section 60 · Saint Thomas Aquinas

Section LX · Location 60 of 80

Section 60 · Open to read

From Summa Theologica by Saint Thomas Aquinas

Edition: Summa Theologica, Third Part (Supplement), Questions 34–68: Treatise on Holy Orders and Matrimony, trans. Fathers of the English Dominican Province (1922)

Supplement — Supervening Impediments, Second Marriages, the Marriage Debt, Plurality of Wives, Bigamy, Divorce, and Legitimation of Children (Questions 62–68)

Summa Theologica · Chapter 60 summary

A consummated Christian marriage is completely indissoluble while both spouses live. Even in cases of proven adultery, separation of bed and board leaves the marital bond intact. In the mutual obligation of the marriage debt, husband and wife are judged on entirely equal terms before God.

Atlas of Saints wrote this summary of section 60 of Summa Theologica by Saint Thomas Aquinas. It uses our own words. It is not a quotation from the book.

Cite this summary

Atlas of Saints. “Supplement — Supervening Impediments, Second Marriages, the Marriage Debt, Plurality of Wives, Bigamy, Divorce, and Legitimation of Children (Questions 62–68)” Summary of Summa Theologica, by Saint Thomas Aquinas. https://www.atlasofsaints.com/writings/summa-theologica/chapters/60#atlas-answer

Section breakdown

The final seven questions of the volume (Questions 62–68) examine what happens after marriage is contracted and consummated. Once a sacramental marriage is consummated, the bond is absolutely indissoluble during the lifetime of both spouses. Even for adultery, a spouse may separate from bed and board (`divortium quoad thorum`) by the judgment of the Church (or privately if the adultery is certain). Yet neither party may marry another. At the same time, the spouse lives, and the innocent spouse is encouraged though not bound to forgive a repentant partner. A spouse dies. In response, the marriage bond is dissolved by death, so a second or third marriage is completely lawful and a true sacrament, though lacks the full figurative perfection of a single marriage signifying Christ's one Church (which is why bigamy causes canonical irregularity for receiving Holy Orders). Within marriage, husbands and wives are strictly equal in the mutual obligation of the marriage debt. Finally, the treatise proves from natural law that plurality of wives is against the secondary precepts of nature (equal friendship and peace in the home). Moreover, the indissolubility of marriage forbids the bill of divorce. Furthermore, illegitimate children retain their natural right to parental support and can be legitimized by subsequent marriage or sovereign authority.

In Supplement Questions 62–64, the treatise proves that a consummated marriage is indissoluble even after adultery (which allows only separation of bed and board unless the innocent spouse forgives the penitent partner). In addition, it defends the lawfulness and sacramentality of second marriages after a spouse's death. Moreover, it establishes the strict equality of husband and wife in the marriage debt. Supplement In Question 62, husband and wife are judged on equal terms regarding marital fidelity and the right to separate on account of adultery. In Supplement Questions 65–66, the treatise demonstrates that having multiple wives is contrary to the natural law. This is because it destroys the equality of friendship between husband and wife and peace in the household (though dispensed by God for the Old Testament patriarchs to multiply the people of faith). In addition, he shows why marrying twice or marrying a widow creates a canonical irregularity for Holy Orders due to the defect in signifying Christ's union with one virgin Church.

Supplement Question 65 demonstrates why polyandry violates the primary end of natural law and why polygyny violates the secondary end of equal friendship and domestic peace. In Supplement Questions 67–68, the treatise proves that the indissolubility of marriage belongs to natural law, explains that the Mosaic bill of divorce was tolerated only to avoid the greater evil of wife-murder. Establishes that parents are bound by natural law to provide for illegitimate children, who may be legitimized by subsequent marriage or legal authority. Supplement Question 67 explains why Moses permitted the bill of divorce only to prevent wife-murder among the hard-hearted, and why Christ restored lifelong indissolubility. Marriage is indissoluble by natural and divine law. Therefore, Christ restored marriage to its original unity and abolished the Mosaic permission of the bill of divorce.

The story inside

Why does natural reason itself (even apart from Christian revelation) require that one husband have only one wife? In Supplement Question 65, Article 1, the treatise analyzes the three ends of marriage. While having multiple husbands (polyandry) destroys the first end of marriage by making paternity uncertain, having multiple wives (polygyny) destroys the second and third ends of marriage. The shared moral education of children and the friendship of husband and wife as free companions. As Aristotle notes, friendship consists in equality. Wherever a man has several wives, the wife is no longer treated as an equal partner sharing one undivided heart. However, he is reduced to the condition of a servant. Bitter jealousy inevitably fills the home—as experience constantly shows. Monogamous marriage is rooted in natural law because only the exclusive union of one man and one woman preserves the wife's dignity as an equal friend.

Lessons worth keeping

  1. 1

    A consummated Christian marriage is completely indissoluble while both spouses live. Even in cases of proven adultery, separation of bed and board leaves the marital bond intact.

  2. 2

    In the mutual obligation of the marriage debt, husband and wife are judged on entirely equal terms before God.

  3. 3

    Plurality of wives (polygamy) contradicts the secondary ends of natural law. This is because it reduces the wife to servitude, destroys equal marital friendship, and breeds domestic strife.

  4. 4

    Marriage is indissoluble by natural and divine law. Therefore, Christ restored marriage to its original unity and abolished the Mosaic permission of the bill of divorce.

Test your recall

Are husband and wife judged by the same moral rule regarding adultery and the marriage debt?

Answer from memory first. Then check the summary and lessons above.

Notes & sources

3 notes

From Summa Theologica, Third Part (Supplement), Questions 34–68: Treatise on Holy Orders and Matrimony, trans. Fathers of the English Dominican Province (1922). Line numbers show where each passage appears in the digitized text.

  1. 1.
    Lines 13592–13595
    “Ohj. 4. Further, The unnatural vice is further removed from the marriage goods than fornication is, the manner of which is natural. Therefore it ought to have been a cause of separation rather than fornication.”
  2. 2.
    Lines 14659–14662
    “Ohj. 2. Further, Leprosy is a worse complaint than suffering from monthly periods, and would seem to cause a greater corruption in the offspring. Yet a leper can ask for the debt. Therefore, etc.”
  3. 3.
    Lines 15880–15882
    “Obj. 2. Further, A deadly sin should be punished with death. But the Old Law did not punish with death intercourse with a concubine, save in a certain case (Deut. xxii. 25).”

Location: section 60 of 80 · 75%

Display settings