Section LIX · Location 59 of 80
Section 59 · Open to readFrom Summa Theologica by Saint Thomas Aquinas
Edition: Summa Theologica, Third Part (Supplement), Questions 34–68: Treatise on Holy Orders and Matrimony, trans. Fathers of the English Dominican Province (1922)
Supplement — Diriment Impediments Preceding Marriage: Error, Slavery, Vows, Consanguinity, Affinity, Spiritual and Legal Relationship, Impotence, Disparity of Worship, and Crime (Questions 50–61)
Summa Theologica · Chapter 59 summary
Error about the actual person being married (error personae) or unknown slavery invalidates marriage. This is because consent cannot bind where the essential object of consent is mistaken. A simple vow of chastity forbids marriage under pain of mortal sin while leaving the contracted bond valid. By contrast, a solemn vow of religious profession invalidates any attempted marriage.
Atlas of Saints wrote this summary of section 59 of Summa Theologica by Saint Thomas Aquinas. It uses our own words. It is not a quotation from the book.
Cite this summary
Atlas of Saints. “Supplement — Diriment Impediments Preceding Marriage: Error, Slavery, Vows, Consanguinity, Affinity, Spiritual and Legal Relationship, Impotence, Disparity of Worship, and Crime (Questions 50–61)” Summary of Summa Theologica, by Saint Thomas Aquinas. https://www.atlasofsaints.com/writings/summa-theologica/chapters/59#atlas-answer
Section breakdown
Questions 50–61 of the Supplement examine the diriment impediments that prevent a valid marriage from being contracted. Marriage is a free interpersonal contract ordered to the procreation of children and the friendship of human society. Therefore, anything that destroys free consent as to the person, contradicts the primary end of marriage, or violates divine and ecclesiastical law renders the contract null. Error concerning the identity of the person (such as Leah substituted for Rachel) or the unknown servile condition of a slave invalidates consent. A simple vow of chastity makes contracting marriage gravely sinful without annulling the bond. At the same time, a solemn vow of religious profession or sacred orders completely invalidates an attempted marriage. Consanguinity (blood kinship), affinity, spiritual relationship from Baptism or Confirmation, and legal adoption bar marriage to preserve family reverence and multiply friendship across society. Finally, perpetual antecedent impotence, madness, lack of age, disparity of worship between a baptized Christian and an unbaptized person, and wife-murder or adultery with a promise of marriage also constitute diriment impediments.
In Supplement Questions 50–53, the treatise defines the impediments to marriage and shows that error of person (as with Jacob and Leah), unknown slavery, solemn religious vows, and sacred orders invalidate an attempted marriage. At the same time, it defends a slave's natural right to marry even against a master's prohibition. Supplement Question 52 explains why unknown slavery is an impediment to marriage and why a slave may marry freely even without a master's consent. In Supplement Questions 54–57, the treatise explains why consanguinity, affinity, spiritual relationship from Baptism and Confirmation, and legal adoption bar marriage—both by natural law in the direct line and by Church law in collateral degrees to multiply social friendship and preserve household modesty.
Supplement In Question 55, affinity arises from marriage and how degrees of kinship are computed. In Supplement Questions 58–61, the treatise analyzes the impediments of perpetual antecedent impotence, spell, frenzy, incest, defect of age, disparity of worship (explaining the Pauline Privilege in 1 Corinthians 7), wife-murder, and solemn profession made before marriage consummation. Supplement Question 59 affirms that unbaptized persons contract true natural marriages. Moreover, he shows the Pauline Privilege when one spouse converts to the faith. Antecedent and perpetual impotence invalidates marriage because no one can bind himself by contract to what is physically impossible. By contrast, disparity of worship protects the faith of the Christian spouse and children.
The story inside
In the ancient and medieval world, masters claimed ownership over their slaves' labor and movements. Suppose a master forbade his slave to marry: was the slave bound in conscience to obey his master and remain unmarried? In Supplement Question 52, Article 2, the treatise gives a remarkable defense of universal human dignity. All human beings are equal by nature in the things that pertain to the preservation of the body and the species. Therefore, no human law or slavery can take away a person's natural right to eat, sleep, or marry. Therefore, a slave may lawfully contract a valid marriage without his master's knowledge or even against his master's express command. A master may never sell a married slave into a distant land where the spouses can no longer live together. Natural human rights to life and marriage belong equally to every human person. Moreover, he can never be extinguished by servitude or human law.
Lessons worth keeping
- 1
Error about the actual person being married (error personae) or unknown slavery invalidates marriage. This is because consent cannot bind where the essential object of consent is mistaken.
- 2
A simple vow of chastity forbids marriage under pain of mortal sin while leaving the contracted bond valid. By contrast, a solemn vow of religious profession invalidates any attempted marriage.
- 3
Consanguinity and affinity forbid marriage between close relatives to safeguard reverence within the home and to widen the circle of human friendship. He does this by uniting different families.
- 4
Antecedent and perpetual impotence invalidates marriage because no one can bind himself by contract to what is physically impossible. By contrast, disparity of worship protects the faith of the Christian spouse and children.
Test your recall
Why did error of person invalidate Jacob's first night with Leah, whereas error about a bride's wealth or noble rank does not invalidate a marriage?
Answer from memory first. Then check the summary and lessons above.
Notes & sources
3 notesFrom Summa Theologica, Third Part (Supplement), Questions 34–68: Treatise on Holy Orders and Matrimony, trans. Fathers of the English Dominican Province (1922). Line numbers show where each passage appears in the digitized text.
- 1.Lines 7589–7592
“Ohj. 2. Further, The less perfect a thing is the fewer its obstacles. Now matrimony is the least perfect of the sacraments. Therefore it should have either no impediments or very few.”
- 2.Lines 9313–9317
“Yet the addition of one person to another does not always make a different degree of consanguinity, since father and uncle are in the same degree of consanguinity, for they are side by side. Therefore consanguinity is not rightly divided into degrees.”
- 3.Lines 11353–11356
“Ohj. 2. Further, Father and son are related in the same degree as brother and brother. If therefore spiritual relationship passes from father to son, it will equally pass from brother to brother: and this is false.”
