Skip to content
Atlas of Saints

Summa Theologica

Section 54 · Saint Thomas Aquinas

Section LIV · Location 54 of 80

Section 54 · Open to read

From Summa Theologica by Saint Thomas Aquinas

Edition: Summa Theologica, Third Part, Questions 84–90 and Supplement Questions 1–33: Treatise on Penance and Extreme Unction, trans. Fathers of the English Dominican Province (1917)

Contrition and Confession: Their Nature, Necessity, Minister, Quality, Effect, and the Seal of Confession (Supplement, Questions 1–11)

Summa Theologica · Chapter 54 summary

Contrition is a voluntary sorrow of the intellective will informed by charity that crushes the hardness of sin and includes the resolution to confess and make satisfaction. Sacramental confession of all mortal sins is necessary for salvation under the New Law. This is because Christ instituted priests as spiritual judges who cannot judge a case without knowing it.

Atlas of Saints wrote this summary of section 54 of Summa Theologica by Saint Thomas Aquinas. It uses our own words. It is not a quotation from the book.

Cite this summary

Atlas of Saints. “Contrition and Confession: Their Nature, Necessity, Minister, Quality, Effect, and the Seal of Confession (Supplement, Questions 1–11)” Summary of Summa Theologica, by Saint Thomas Aquinas. https://www.atlasofsaints.com/writings/summa-theologica/chapters/54#atlas-answer

Section breakdown

Beginning the Supplement compiled by Reginald of Piperno from Thomas Aquinas's Commentary on the Sentences, Questions 1–11 examine the first two parts of Penance: contrition and confession. Contrition is an assumed sorrow for sins together with the purpose of confessing them and making satisfaction. Proceeding from charity, it crushes the hard resistance of the sinner's will. In addition, he must extend to every mortal sin in particular, lasting throughout this earthly life. A degree of contrition intensified by charity can entirely remit both guilt and eternal or temporal punishment. Therefore, contrition is the chief inner part of Penance. Yet it always includes the vow to submit one's sins to the keys of the Church in sacramental confession. Confession is necessary for salvation by divine law for all who fall into mortal sin after Baptism, must be made to a priest possessing both the power of orders and jurisdiction (except in danger of death when any priest can absolve), must be vocal, integral, humble, and undivided. Moreover, it is guarded by the inviolable Seal of Confession, which no priest may ever break under any pretext, even to save his own life or prevent the overthrow of a commonwealth.

In Supplement Questions 1–5, the treatise defines contrition as an assumed sorrow for sins joined to the purpose of confessing and making satisfaction, shows that contrition must cover every mortal sin and endure throughout life. Proves that intense contrition can remit the entire debt of temporal punishment. Supplement Question 1 distinguishes contrition (which completely crushes the hardness of sin through charity) from attrition, which is an imperfect sorrow. In Supplement Questions 6–10, the treatise proves that sacramental confession is necessary for salvation by divine law, requires a priest holding jurisdiction except in danger of death, and must be integral. In doing so, it forbids a penitent from dividing his mortal sins between two confessors to hide his shame.

Supplement Question 6 explains why a sinner must confess his sins aloud to a priest even though God already knows every secret of the heart. In Supplement Question 11, the treatise establishes the absolute inviolability of the Seal of Confession. The priest hears confession as God's minister rather than as man. Therefore, he can truthfully swear in court that he knows nothing as man. May never reveal a sin heard in confession even to avoid death or public ruin. Supplement In Question 10, sacramental confession delivers from eternal death, opens the gate of heaven, and diminishes temporal punishment through the power of the keys. The Seal of Confession binds the priest by divine and natural law. This is because he knows the penitent's sins not as man, but as God's minister. No threat of death or excommunication can ever excuse breaking the Seal.

The story inside

What must a priest do if a judge or ruler commands him under pain of death or excommunication to reveal what he heard in sacramental confession, or if concealing the confession seems to threaten the community with grave harm? In Supplement Question 11, Articles 1 to 5, the treatise gives an uncompromising answer. Every sacrament is an outward sign of what happens inwardly. God hides the sins of the truly penitent. In the same way, the minister of Penance is bound by the very nature of the sacrament to hide whatever he hears in confession. Furthermore, in the tribunal of Penance the priest sits not as a mere human citizen. However, in the place of God. Therefore, without any lie, he can declare under oath in a human court that 'he knows nothing'. In doing so, he means that he knows nothing as man. In addition, he must suffer death rather than betray the Seal of Confession unless the penitent himself freely grants permission to speak. The Seal of Confession is a sacred trust of divine law that no human power, threat, or emergency can ever override.

Lessons worth keeping

  1. 1

    Contrition is a voluntary sorrow of the intellective will informed by charity that crushes the hardness of sin and includes the resolution to confess and make satisfaction.

  2. 2

    Sacramental confession of all mortal sins is necessary for salvation under the New Law. This is because Christ instituted priests as spiritual judges who cannot judge a case without knowing it.

  3. 3

    In the hour of danger of death, necessity overrides jurisdictional limits so that any priest—and even a layperson as a non-sacramental witness of desire when no priest can be found—may hear a dying penitent's confession.

  4. 4

    The Seal of Confession binds the priest by divine and natural law. This is because he knows the penitent's sins not as man, but as God's minister. No threat of death or excommunication can ever excuse breaking the Seal.

Test your recall

Why may a penitent not confess half his mortal sins to one priest and the other half to a second priest?

Answer from memory first. Then check the summary and lessons above.

Notes & sources

3 notes

From Summa Theologica, Third Part, Questions 84–90 and Supplement Questions 1–33: Treatise on Penance and Extreme Unction, trans. Fathers of the English Dominican Province (1917). Line numbers show where each passage appears in the digitized text.

  1. 1.
    Lines 4599–4601
    “We must now consider each single part of Penance, and (i) Contrition; (2) Confession; (3) Satisfaction. The consideration about Contrition will be fourfold: (i) What is it?”
  2. 2.
    Lines 6084–6088
    “As to whether the whole debt of punishment is always taken away by contrition, this question has already been moved above (Sent, iv., D. 14, Q. II., AA. i, 2; P. III., Q LXXXVL, A. 4), where the same question was raised with regard to Penance.”
  3. 3.
    Lines 7591–7593
    “But the priest himself can give his parishioner permission to confess to another. Much more, therefore, can his superior do this.”

Location: section 54 of 80 · 68%

Display settings