Section LIII · Location 53 of 80
Section 53 · Open to readFrom Summa Theologica by Saint Thomas Aquinas
Edition: Summa Theologica, Third Part, Questions 84–90 and Supplement Questions 1–33: Treatise on Penance and Extreme Unction, trans. Fathers of the English Dominican Province (1917)
The Sacrament and Virtue of Penance, the Pardon of Mortal and Venial Sin, and the Recovery of Virtue (Third Part, Questions 84–90)
Summa Theologica · Chapter 53 summary
Penance is the sacrament of spiritual healing after Baptism. The penitent's acts of contrition, confession, and satisfaction serve as its matter. The priest's absolution is its form. As a virtue, penance is a species of justice by which a sinner grieves over offense committed against God and purposes to amend his life.
Atlas of Saints wrote this summary of section 53 of Summa Theologica by Saint Thomas Aquinas. It uses our own words. It is not a quotation from the book.
Cite this summary
Atlas of Saints. “The Sacrament and Virtue of Penance, the Pardon of Mortal and Venial Sin, and the Recovery of Virtue (Third Part, Questions 84–90)” Summary of Summa Theologica, by Saint Thomas Aquinas. https://www.atlasofsaints.com/writings/summa-theologica/chapters/53#atlas-answer
Section breakdown
In Questions 84–90 of the Third Part (the final questions penned by Saint Thomas Aquinas before he ceased writing in December 1273) Aquinas examines the Sacrament and Virtue of Penance. Baptism is a spiritual birth given once using external water. By contrast, Penance is a spiritual healing for sins committed after Baptism. Its quasi-matter consists in the penitent's own acts of contrition, confession, and satisfaction. Moreover, its sacramental form consists in the priest's words of absolution ('I absolve thee'). As a special moral virtue annexed to justice, penance grieves over past sin with the intention of removing it and making satisfaction to God. Because all mortal sins turn the soul away from God, God never pardons one mortal sin without pardoning all mortal sins through the infusion of sanctifying grace and charity, which also restores dead works to life and recovers all the virtues.
In Questions 84–85, Thomas Aquinas proves that Penance is a true sacrament of the New Law whose matter is the penitent's human acts and whose form is priestly absolution. Moreover, he marks out the virtue of penance as a special moral virtue under justice initiated by filial fear and perfected by charity. Question 84 contrasts sacraments that apply external bodily matter like water in Baptism with Penance, whose proximate matter is the penitent's own acts. In Questions 86–88, Aquinas demonstrates that no mortal sin can be pardoned without sanctifying grace. Moreover, all mortal sins are remitted together. Moreover, venial sins are remitted by any fervent movement of grace or sacramental blessing. Furthermore, past pardoned sins do not return in their guilt when a person sins again, though ingratitude aggravates the new sin.
Question 86 cites King David's repentance before the Prophet Nathan (2 Kings 12:13) to show how contrition united to the desire for the keys obtains pardon of mortal sin. In Questions 89–90, Aquinas shows that Penance restores all infused virtues and revives deadened merits (even if a penitent rises with a lower degree of grace than before his fall). Moreover, he establishes that contrition, confession, and satisfaction are the three integral parts of Penance. In Question 89, sanctifying grace restores the penitent to divine friendship and revives previous meritorious works. A penitent rises from sin through Penance. In response, all the virtues are restored in equal degree. The good works done while in charity (which had been deadened by mortal sin) revive.
The story inside
Can a sinner ask God to forgive his theft. At the same time, he refuses to repent of his hatred or adultery? In Question 86, Article 3, Aquinas explains why it is impossible for one mortal sin to be pardoned without all other mortal sins being pardoned at the very same time. Every mortal sin consists in turning the heart away from God, our ultimate End. A person cannot be simultaneously a friend of God and an enemy of God. Therefore, no mortal sin can be forgiven except through the infusion of sanctifying grace and charity, which unites the soul to God. Just as a single beam of sunlight entering a dark room drives out all darkness at once, the infusion of charity expels the guilt of every mortal sin together. True repentance cannot bargain with God to keep a single mortal sin. Divine charity either heals the whole heart or cannot enter at all.
Lessons worth keeping
- 1
Penance is the sacrament of spiritual healing after Baptism. The penitent's acts of contrition, confession, and satisfaction serve as its matter. The priest's absolution is its form.
- 2
As a virtue, penance is a species of justice by which a sinner grieves over offense committed against God and purposes to amend his life.
- 3
No mortal sin can ever be pardoned without the infusion of sanctifying grace and charity, so God never forgives one mortal sin without forgiving all of them together.
- 4
A penitent rises from sin through Penance. In response, all the virtues are restored in equal degree. The good works done while in charity (which had been deadened by mortal sin) revive.
Test your recall
If someone falls into a new mortal sin after being absolved, do all his previously forgiven sins come back to life?
Answer from memory first. Then check the summary and lessons above.
Notes & sources
3 notesFrom Summa Theologica, Third Part, Questions 84–90 and Supplement Questions 1–33: Treatise on Penance and Extreme Unction, trans. Fathers of the English Dominican Province (1917). Line numbers show where each passage appears in the digitized text.
- 1.Lines 207–211
“We must now consider the Sacrament of Penance. We shall consider (i) Penance itself: (2) Its effect: (3) Its parts: (4) The recipients of this sacrament: (5) The power of the ministers, which pertains to the keys: (6) The solemnization of this sacrament.”
- 2.Lines 1919–1921
“Now no virtue is compatible with sin in the soul. Therefore no virtue precedes penance, which is itself the first of all, and opens the door to the others by expelling sin.”
- 3.Lines 3112–3113
“Yet he does not fall back into that which had been forgiven, nor will he be condemned for original sin.”
