Section XXXVII · Location 37 of 80
Section 37 · Open to readFrom Summa Theologica by Saint Thomas Aquinas
Edition: Summa Theologica, Second Part of the Second Part, Questions 101–140: Piety, Observance, and the Treatise on Fortitude, trans. Fathers of the English Dominican Province (1922)
Second Part of the Second Part — Piety, Observance, Dulia, Obedience, Disobedience, Gratitude, Ingratitude, Vengeance, and Truthfulness (Questions 101–109)
Summa Theologica · Chapter 37 summary
Piety renders honor and necessary support to parents and country as the secondary principles of our birth and education, subordinate only to the worship of God. Obedience is owed to legitimate superiors within the scope of their authority. At the same time, interior acts of the will and natural rights of bodily life and marriage remain free.
Atlas of Saints wrote this summary of section 37 of Summa Theologica by Saint Thomas Aquinas. It uses our own words. It is not a quotation from the book.
Cite this summary
Atlas of Saints. “Second Part of the Second Part — Piety, Observance, Dulia, Obedience, Disobedience, Gratitude, Ingratitude, Vengeance, and Truthfulness (Questions 101–109)” Summary of Summa Theologica, by Saint Thomas Aquinas. https://www.atlasofsaints.com/writings/summa-theologica/chapters/37#atlas-answer
Section breakdown
Continuing the potential parts of justice in the Secunda Secundae, Questions 101 through 109 examine the virtues that render due honor, service, or fidelity to fellow human beings where either strict equality is impossible or the debt is moral rather than legal. After God, our parents and our country are the secondary principles of our existence and upbringing. Piety (Question 101) offers them due reverence and material support in need. In doing so, he yields only when parental demands conflict with the higher claims of religion toward God. Observance and dulia (Questions 102–103) render honor and cult to persons in positions of dignity and excellence. At the same time, obedience (Questions 104–105) promptly fulfills the lawful commands of superiors within their sphere of authority. Even so, subjects must never obey any command contrary to God. Cannot be bound in the purely interior movements of the will or the basic preservation of bodily nature. Questions 106–109 then treat gratitude (which repays benefactors with a generous heart beyond the measure of the gift), lawful vengeance (which seeks to restrain evil rather than rejoice in another's pain), and truthfulness, which orders human speech and action to manifest reality honestly as required for life in society.
In Questions 101–103, Thomas Aquinas teaches that filial piety renders reverence and material support to parents and fatherland as secondary principles of our being. In doing so, he gives way to religion only if parental cares hinder the service of God. Question 102 distinguishes the special debt of piety owed to parents and fatherland from the observance owed to rulers and masters. In Questions 104–105, Aquinas establishes the limits of human obedience. Subjects owe obedience only in external acts pertaining to the superior's office, remain equal by nature in matters of bodily sustenance and marriage. In addition, he must disobey any command contrary to God.
Question 105 explains the moral gravity of disobedience and how formal contempt of authority constitutes a mortal sin. In Questions 106–109, Aquinas analyzes gratitude, lawful vengeance (aimed at correcting fault and preserving peace rather than hating the sinner), and truthfulness as foundational bonds of human society. In Question 108, lawful vengeance must proceed from charity and zeal for justice to restrain evil, never from hatred. Truthfulness is a necessary moral virtue annexed to justice. This is because human beings cannot live together in society unless they can trust one another's words.
The story inside
How far does the duty of obedience to kings, lords, or masters actually reach? Some ancient writers treated subjects or servants as if every part of their life belonged to their ruler. Following Seneca and natural law, Aquinas draws a sharp boundary in Question 104, Article 5. First, no human superior can ever judge or command the interior movements of the human mind and will, which are subject to God alone. Second, even in bodily matters, all human beings are equal by nature in everything that pertains to the sustainment of the body and the generation of children. Therefore, no master can forbid a servant to eat, sleep, marry, or keep virginity, and subjects owe obedience only in external civic or organizational duties within the ruler's lawful authority. Legitimate authority is bounded by natural human equality, interior freedom of conscience, and the higher law of God.
Lessons worth keeping
- 1
Piety renders honor and necessary support to parents and country as the secondary principles of our birth and education, subordinate only to the worship of God.
- 2
Obedience is owed to legitimate superiors within the scope of their authority. At the same time, interior acts of the will and natural rights of bodily life and marriage remain free.
- 3
A subject must never obey a human superior who commands anything contrary to God's law. Nor is a subject bound to obey an unjust usurper except to avoid scandal or danger.
- 4
Truthfulness is a necessary moral virtue annexed to justice. This is because human beings cannot live together in society unless they can trust one another's words.
Test your recall
If a person's aging parents are in grave need of food and care, may he abandon them to enter a monastery?
Answer from memory first. Then check the summary and lessons above.
Notes & sources
3 notesFrom Summa Theologica, Second Part of the Second Part, Questions 101–140: Piety, Observance, and the Treatise on Fortitude, trans. Fathers of the English Dominican Province (1922). Line numbers show where each passage appears in the digitized text.
- 1.Lines 200–204
“After religion we must consider piety, the consideration of which will render the opposite vices manifest. Accordingly four points of inquiry arise with regard to piety: (i) To whom does piety extend? (2) What does piety make one offer a person? (3) Whether piety is a special virtue?”
- 2.Lines 1916–1918
“And the comparison with human law does not stand, because thereby one man is subject to another. Yet man is bound by divine law to obey his fellow-man.”
- 3.Lines 2954–2957
“Ohj. 2. Further, No one should afford another an occasion of committing sin. But the ungrateful in receiving a favour is given an occasion of ingratitude. Therefore favours should not be bestowed on the ungrateful.”
