Section XXIII · Location 23 of 80
Section 23 · Open to readFrom Summa Theologica by Saint Thomas Aquinas
Edition: Aquinas Ethicus: The Moral Teaching of St. Thomas, Volume I, trans. Father Joseph Rickaby, S.J. (1896)
First Part of the Second Part — Questions XLIX–CXIV: Habits, Virtues, Sin, Eternal and Natural Law, Human Law, and Grace
Summa Theologica · Chapter 23 summary
Moral virtues are stable habits acquired by repeated acts (or infused by God) that perfect the appetites, are reciprocally connected through Prudence and Charity across the four Cardinal Virtues, and observe the golden mean of reason. At the same time, theological virtues have no excess toward God.
Atlas of Saints wrote this summary of section 23 of Summa Theologica by Saint Thomas Aquinas. It uses our own words. It is not a quotation from the book.
Cite this summary
Atlas of Saints. “First Part of the Second Part — Questions XLIX–CXIV: Habits, Virtues, Sin, Eternal and Natural Law, Human Law, and Grace” Summary of Summa Theologica, by Saint Thomas Aquinas. https://www.atlasofsaints.com/writings/summa-theologica/chapters/23#atlas-answer
Section breakdown
In Questions XLIX–CXIV of the Prima Secundae, Saint Thomas Aquinas traces how human actions are shaped from within by Habits, Virtues, and Vices. Moreover, he guided from above by Law and Grace. Our rational and appetitive powers are not locked into a single fixed response like a stone falling downward. Therefore, they need enduring dispositions (called habits) to incline them steadily toward good or evil operations. Natural habits are generated and strengthened by repeated acts. In the same way, repeated drops of water hollow out a stone. They are weakened or destroyed by contrary acts or long neglect. A good operational habit is a virtue, which Saint Augustine defines as "a good quality of the mind, whereby a man lives rightly, which no one uses badly."
Aquinas distinguishes intellectual virtues from moral virtues. "R. Moral virtue may be without some intellectual" (lines 8980..8980) virtues such as theoretical science or art. Yet it can never exist without Understanding (which grasps first moral principles) and Prudence (which directs concrete action). Socrates had argued that all virtue is simply knowledge and that no one ever sins knowingly. Aquinas replies that while a person may know universal moral principles in the abstract, an unruly passion of desire or anger can cloud his judgment in the heat of a particular choice unless his appetites are trained by moral virtue. The moral life hinges upon four Cardinal Virtues. These include Prudence (which commands right action in the practical reason), Justice (which puts right order into outward actions and dealings with others in the will), Fortitude (which firms the irascible appetite against fear of danger), and Temperance (which restrains the concupiscible appetite from disordered pleasures). These four virtues are organically connected like the fingers of one hand. No one can have true Prudence unless his appetites are rightly disposed toward good ends by Justice, Fortitude, and Temperance, and no one can have those moral virtues without Prudence to guide their choice of means. Every moral virtue consists in a "golden mean". At the same time, measured by right reason between excess and defect, the three theological virtues (Faith, Hope, and Charity) have God Himself as their immediate object and rule: therefore, we can never believe in God too much, hope in Him too much, or love Him too much.
Opposed to virtue is sin, which is any word, deed, or desire contrary to the eternal law. Sins differ in species according to their objects and arise from three interior sources. These include ignorance in the intellect (which diminishes guilt when not willful), infirmity or passion in the sensitive appetite (which lessens guilt because the heat of passion disturbs deliberation, though the sin remains mortal if reason still consents to a grave evil), and "certain malice" in the will (when a person deliberately chooses evil with open eyes, which is the gravest form of sin). Outside the soul, the world, men, and the devil can entice or persuade a person by presenting attractive images. However, the devil can never force the human will. Every sin remains the person's own free responsibility. "R. The stain of sin remains on the soul even" (lines 12180..12180) after the passing sinful act is over. This stain is the loss of the soul's bright beauty of grace and divine friendship. It cannot be wiped away until the human will is reunited to God by sanctifying grace. Mortal sin destroys the very principle of spiritual life (charity) by turning the soul away from God as its Last End. Therefore incurs an eternal debt of punishment (just as a citizen who commits treason against the state is banished forever). By contrast, venial sin disorders the soul regarding some created means without turning away from God, incurring only temporal punishment.
To instruct human beings and lead them to virtue, God governs through Law. Aquinas defines law as "an ordinance of reason for the common good, promulgated by him who has care of the community." At the summit stands the Eternal Law, the supreme plan of Divine Wisdom governing all creation. Rational creatures share consciously in that plan through the Natural Law. This is the light of natural reason by which we discern good and evil. Its foundational principle is "good is to be done and pursued, and evil is to be avoided", from which flow three levels of natural precepts corresponding to our human inclinations. This involves preserving human life, uniting in marriage to raise and educate children, and living peacefully in society while seeking truth about God. The Natural Law is the same for all people in its common first principles. In addition, he can never be blotted out of the human heart. Even so, bad customs and passions can obscure its secondary applications.
From the Natural Law, human legislators frame Human Law to promote the common good and peace. Yet Aquinas lays down a famous rule of political prudence in Question XCVI. Human civil law should not attempt to forbid every single vice from which virtuous people abstain. However, only the graver crimes (such as murder, theft, and fraud) from which the majority of imperfect people can abstain and which directly harm others and destroy human society. Civil law tries to outlaw every private imperfection at once, imperfect citizens. In that case, unable to bear the yoke, will break out into worse evils. Why, then, is a revealed Divine Law also needed? "R. Besides the natural law and human law it" (lines 12880..12880) was necessary for human salvation that there should be a Divine Law for four reasons. Because man is directed to a supernatural end of eternal beatitude beyond natural reason. Because human judgments about particular actions are uncertain. Because human law can judge only outward acts while perfection requires interior purity of heart. Moreover, because Divine Law leaves no evil unforbidden and unpunished. Finally, In Question CIX, in our fallen state of nature, man without sanctifying grace can still perform particular natural goods such as building houses or planting vineyards. At the same time, he cannot heal his own nature, love God above all things, fulfill all the commandments of the natural law, or avoid mortal sin for long without the supernatural healing and elevating grace of God.
The story inside
A habit is an abiding quality that disposes a power well or ill toward its operation. Rational powers are open to many courses of action. Therefore, they need habits, which are acquired and strengthened by repeated acts (or diminished by contrary acts and neglect). Virtue is a good operational habit by which a person lives rightly and which no one can use badly. Intellectual virtues (understanding, science, wisdom, art) give the capacity to act well. By contrast, moral virtues reside in the appetites and secure the actual right use of our powers. Moral virtues are distinct from intellectual virtues (turning against Socrates' claim that virtue is merely knowledge, since incontinence arises when passion overrides particular judgment) yet no moral virtue can exist without Prudence. Nor can Prudence exist without the moral virtues, which are all connected in Prudence and Charity. There are four Cardinal Virtues (Prudence, Justice, Fortitude, and Temperance) and moral virtues observe the 'golden mean' of reason. By contrast, theological virtues (Faith, Hope, Charity) have God Himself as their measure and therefore cannot be practiced to excess. Charity, Faith, and Hope considered in their act of love and vision abide in heaven.
Lessons worth keeping
- 1
Moral virtues are stable habits acquired by repeated acts (or infused by God), connected through Prudence and Charity across the four Cardinal Virtues.
- 2
Sin arises interiorly from ignorance, passion, or purposeful malice. Mortal sin destroys charity and turns the soul from its Last End. By contrast, venial sin disorders the means without destroying charity.
- 3
Law is an ordinance of reason for the common good. Human law wisely forbids only the graver vices that harm social peace. At the same time, Divine Law and supernatural Grace are required to heal fallen nature and lead man to eternal life.
Test your recall
How do the Eternal Law, the Natural Law, Human Law, and the New Law of Grace work together to guide human actions toward the common good?
Answer from memory first. Then check the summary and lessons above.
Notes & sources
3 notesFrom Aquinas Ethicus: The Moral Teaching of St. Thomas, Volume I, trans. Father Joseph Rickaby, S.J. (1896). Line numbers show where each passage appears in the digitized text.
- 1.Lines 8619–8621
“R. The virtue of the speculative intellect is that which perfects the said intellect for the consideration of truth, such being the good work proper to it.”
- 2.Lines 10478–10482
“But he whose sin stops short of turning away from God, is under a disorder that by the very nature of the sin admits of repair; and therefore he is said to sin venially, because he does not so sin as to deserve never-ending punishment.”
- 3.Lines 11879–11883
“R. An act bad of its kind can be totally excused from sin only by being rendered totally involuntary. Hence, given a passion that renders the act that follows upon it totally involuntary, there is a total excuse from sin: otherwise the excuse is not total.”
