Skip to content
Atlas of Saints

Summa Theologica

Section 20 · Saint Thomas Aquinas

Section XX · Location 20 of 80

Section 20 · Open to read

From Summa Theologica by Saint Thomas Aquinas

Edition: Summa Theologica, First Part, Questions 103–119: Treatise on the Divine Government, trans. Fathers of the English Dominican Province (1922)

First Part — Questions CXV–CXIX: Corporeal Action and Heavenly Bodies, Fate, How Man Teaches Man, the Immediate Creation of the Soul, and Bodily Propagation

Summa Theologica · Chapter 20 summary

Corporeal bodies genuinely act through their forms. Heavenly bodies can influence human passions only indirectly through the body without ever compelling the incorporeal intellect or free will. At the same time, 'fate' is merely the temporal ordering of secondary causes under Divine Providence.

Atlas of Saints wrote this summary of section 20 of Summa Theologica by Saint Thomas Aquinas. It uses our own words. It is not a quotation from the book.

Cite this summary

Atlas of Saints. “First Part — Questions CXV–CXIX: Corporeal Action and Heavenly Bodies, Fate, How Man Teaches Man, the Immediate Creation of the Soul, and Bodily Propagation” Summary of Summa Theologica, by Saint Thomas Aquinas. https://www.atlasofsaints.com/writings/summa-theologica/chapters/20#atlas-answer

Section breakdown

In Questions CXV through CXIX, Saint Thomas brings the First Part of the Summa Theologica to its close. He does this by turning from spiritual ministries to bodily causality and human generation. "WE have now to consider the action of the corporeal" (lines 6598..6598) creature. Against philosophers who denied real causality to material things, In Question CXV, bodily creatures genuinely act upon one another through their forms. At the same time, the active and passive powers implanted in matter from creation are what St. Augustine called "seminal reasons." Heavenly bodies move lower earthly bodies, yet they can never act directly upon the human intellect or will. This is because intellect and will are spiritual powers that do not operate through a bodily organ. Heavenly bodies can touch human choice only indirectly by stirring up bodily humors and sensitive passions (such as anger or fear). Because the multitude of human beings follow their bodily passions while only the wise govern their passions by reason, astrologers frequently guess right about the behavior of crowds while failing completely regarding individuals who exercise free will. In Question CXVI, Aquinas clarifies the word "fate". If by fate someone means a deterministic necessity imposed by the stars, fate is false and heretical. If, however, fate is taken in Boethius's sense as the disposition inherent in changeable secondary causes by which God's eternal Providence carries out its plan in time, then fate is completely subordinate to God's will and applies only to natural causes, never to God's immediate acts of creation, grace, and glory.

In Question CXVII, Aquinas examines one of the noblest forms of human causality: how one human being teaches another. Averroes claimed that a teacher merely clears away obstacles. At the same time, a single separate intellect pours science into the pupil. Plato claimed that the soul knows all things from birth and that teaching is merely reminding. Rejecting both extremes, Aquinas compares the teacher to a physician. A doctor heals a sick man. In response, the principal cause of healing is the patient's own internal vitality implanted by nature. At the same time, the doctor assists nature by supplying medicines and diet. In the very same way, every student possesses within his own soul the natural light of reason (the active intellect given by God) together with self-evident first principles. A human teacher genuinely causes knowledge in his student by proposing "some sensible examples, either by way of likeness or of" (lines 7848..7848) opposite, or by leading the student step by step from self-evident premises to the conclusions Virtually contained within them. Thus God alone teaches interiorly as the author of the mind's light. At the same time, human teachers and angels teach exteriorly as true secondary causes of learning.

Finally, in Questions CXVIII and CXIX, Aquinas explains how human beings come into existence through the cooperation of parents and God. The sensitive soul of an animal performs no operation without a bodily organ. Therefore, it is brought forth from the potentiality of matter by the formative power in the parent's semen. The human intellectual soul, however, possesses an immaterial operation of understanding in which bodily matter has no share. Therefore, it is impossible for the rational soul to be produced by bodily semen (traducianism). Instead, as the embryonic body is formed by the parents' generative power through successive stages of development—"ment, proceeding gradually from the imperfect to the per" (lines 8476..8476)fect—God immediately creates the rational soul out of nothing at the moment the body is ready to receive it. The context is set against Origen's error that all human souls were created together with the angels before the material world and later imprisoned in bodies as a punishment for sin. In this setting, Aquinas proves that the soul is naturally the substantial form of the body. Union with the body is for the soul's natural good, not its punishment. Question CXIX concludes by showing how food is converted into the living substance of the human body both to repair daily bodily loss and to supply the matter of generation. In doing so, he ends with a doxology to Christ. Its sacred Body was formed from the Virgin Mary by the power of the Holy Spirit.

The story inside

In Question CXV (6 articles), Aquinas proves against Plato and Avicenna that corporeal bodies genuinely act upon one another through their substantial and accidental forms. At the same time, active and passive powers implanted in matter by God are called 'seminal reasons' (Augustine). Heavenly bodies move lower terrestrial bodies, yet they cannot act directly upon the human intellect or will, which are incorporeal powers without bodily organs. Stars can affect human choice only indirectly by stirring bodily humors and passions, which is why astrologers often predict the behavior of crowds who follow their passions. By contrast, the wise man rules the stars by mastering his passions through reason. In Question CXVI (4 articles), 'fate' is rejected if taken as a deterministic necessity of the stars, and admitted only in Boethius's Christian sense as the ordering of secondary causes in time flowing from God's unchangeable eternal Providence. In Question CXVII (4 articles), Aquinas refutes both the Platonic claim that learning is merely remembering innate ideas and the Averroist claim that an external separate intellect simply pours knowledge into a passive human mind. Instead, just as a physician heals a patient not by replacing nature, but by assisting the body's own inner healing power with medicine and diet, a human teacher truly causes knowledge in a student by proposing sensible signs, words, and examples in an orderly sequence so that the student's own natural light of reason (the active intellect) advances from known principles to unknown conclusions.

Lessons worth keeping

  1. 1

    Heavenly bodies cannot act directly on the spiritual intellect or will. However, only indirectly on bodily passions, which free reason can always master.

  2. 2

    A human teacher genuinely causes science in a student. In the same way, a physician causes health. He does this by proposing ordered examples and arguments that guide the student's own active intellect from known principles to new conclusions.

  3. 3

    Parents transmit bodily human nature through generation. At the same time, every individual rational soul is created immediately out of nothing by God when infused into the body.

Test your recall

How do human teaching, physical nature, fate, and the generative power of parents operate under divine providence without overriding the spiritual soul?

Answer from memory first. Then check the summary and lessons above.

Notes & sources

3 notes

From Summa Theologica, First Part, Questions 103–119: Treatise on the Divine Government, trans. Fathers of the English Dominican Province (1922). Line numbers show where each passage appears in the digitized text.

  1. 1.
    Lines 6598–6599
    “WE have now to consider the action of the corporeal creature; and fate, which is ascribed to certain bodies.”
  2. 2.
    Lines 7479–7482
    “For God alone can change the will, as shown above (Q. CV., A. 4). Consequently the ordering of human actions, the principle of which is the will, must be ascribed to God alone.”
  3. 3.
    Lines 8179–8180
    “WE now consider the production of man from man: first, as to the soul; secondly, as to the body.”

Location: section 20 of 80 · 25%

Display settings