Skip to content
Atlas of Saints

Summa Theologica

Section 14 · Saint Thomas Aquinas

Section XIV · Location 14 of 80

Section 14 · Open to read

From Summa Theologica by Saint Thomas Aquinas

Edition: Summa Theologica, First Part, Questions 75–102: Treatise on Man, trans. Fathers of the English Dominican Province (1912)

First Part — How the Human Soul Knows Bodily, Immaterial, and Separated Things (Questions 84–89)

Summa Theologica · Chapter 14 summary

In the present life, the human intellect cannot actually understand anything without turning to sensory phantasms, from which the active intellect abstracts universal intelligible species. Universal intelligible species are not what the intellect understands first. However, the means (quo) by which the intellect understands the real natures of things outside the mind.

Atlas of Saints wrote this summary of section 14 of Summa Theologica by Saint Thomas Aquinas. It uses our own words. It is not a quotation from the book.

Cite this summary

Atlas of Saints. “First Part — How the Human Soul Knows Bodily, Immaterial, and Separated Things (Questions 84–89)” Summary of Summa Theologica, by Saint Thomas Aquinas. https://www.atlasofsaints.com/writings/summa-theologica/chapters/14#atlas-answer

Section breakdown

How does the human soul acquire knowledge. At the same time, united to the body, and what can it know when separated by death? Aquinas rejects both Democritus's materialism, which reduced thought to physical impressions, and Plato's innate ideas, which bypassed the senses. In this life, the natural object of the human intellect is the quiddity or nature of material things, which the active intellect abstracts from sensory phantasms. The soul knows itself not by looking directly at its bare essence, but through its own acts of understanding. It knows singulars indirectly by turning back to the phantasms. Moreover, it knows immaterial substances in this life only by analogy with sensible things. By contrast, after death the separated soul understands through divinely infused intelligible likenesses.

In Questions 84–85, Thomas Aquinas proves that the human intellect in this life understands material natures. He does this by abstracting intelligible species from sensory phantasms. Furthermore, these species are the means of knowing external reality rather than the primary object of thought. In Question 84, all human natural knowledge begins in the senses because a person born blind completely lacks concepts of colors. In Questions 86–88, Aquinas shows that our intellect knows singular material things indirectly by reflecting on phantasms. He also knows future contingents only in their causes. In addition, he knows itself through its own acts rather than by direct intuition of its essence. Moreover, he cannot naturally behold the essences of angels or God in this life.

In Question 85, the simple intellect composes and divides propositions when judging the truth of complex realities. In Question 89, Aquinas explains that the soul separated by death understands through divinely infused species, retains the intellectual habits acquired on earth. Knows other separated souls and local natural realities as ordained by God. Moreover, he does not naturally know all particular earthly events unless informed by God, angels, or newly arrived souls. Question 89 explains why the soul is united to the body for its own natural perfection rather than as a punishment. Indeed, bodily senses allow it to gather distinct knowledge of material things. The soul is separated from the body at death. Then it retains its habitual knowledge and understands through species flowing from the divine light, though less distinctly in detail than through bodily phantasms.

The story inside

If the human intellect does not use a bodily organ to think, why does a person suffering from fever, brain injury, or lethargy lose the ability to use even the knowledge he already acquired? In Question 84, Article 7, Aquinas highlights this everyday clinical observation to prove that the soul's natural mode of understanding in this life requires turning to the phantasms stored in the bodily powers of imagination, memory, and the cogitative sense. Even when a scholar possesses a complete habit of science in his immaterial intellect, he cannot call that knowledge into actual use—nor explain it to himself or others by examples—without forming sensory images in the brain. Therefore, when the organ of imagination is damaged, the intellect is hindered in its act. This proves that body and soul work together in every earthly act of human thought. Even our highest abstract thinking in this life relies on the humble cooperation of our bodily senses and imagination.

Lessons worth keeping

  1. 1

    In the present life, the human intellect cannot actually understand anything without turning to sensory phantasms, from which the active intellect abstracts universal intelligible species.

  2. 2

    Universal intelligible species are not what the intellect understands first. However, the means (quo) by which the intellect understands the real natures of things outside the mind.

  3. 3

    The human soul knows its own existence and nature through its acts of understanding. Moreover, he knows immaterial substances in this life by comparison with material things.

  4. 4

    The soul is separated from the body at death. Then it retains its habitual knowledge and understands through species flowing from the divine light, though less distinctly in detail than through bodily phantasms.

Test your recall

What would follow if the intelligible species in our mind were the very things we understand rather than the means by which we understand?

Answer from memory first. Then check the summary and lessons above.

Notes & sources

3 notes

From Summa Theologica, First Part, Questions 75–102: Treatise on Man, trans. Fathers of the English Dominican Province (1912). Line numbers show where each passage appears in the digitized text.

  1. 1.
    Lines 7090–7093
    “In treating of these acts we shall proceed in the following order: First, we shall inquire how the soul understands when united to the body; secondly, how it understands when separated therefrom.”
  2. 2.
    Lines 8910–8911
    “But whatever thing's the intellect understands under different species, it does not understand at the same time.”
  3. 3.
    Lines 10003–10006
    “Ohj. 2. Further, whatever is known is known by some act. If, then, the intellect knows its own act, it knows it by some act, and again it knows that act by some other act; this is to proceed indefinitely, which seems impossible.”

Location: section 14 of 80 · 18%

Display settings