Section III · Location 3 of 3
Section 3 · Open to readFrom De fide ad Gratianum Augustum by Saint Ambrose
Edition: The Catholic Encyclopedia, Volume I: Aachen–Assize (1907)
Section 3 — The Council of Aquileia (381), De Spiritu Sancto, and the Defense of the Milanese Basilicas
De fide ad Gratianum Augustum · Chapter 3 summary
The doctrinal victory of De Fide culminates at the Council of Aquileia (381), where Ambrose convicts Palladius and Secundianus out of Arius's own letter, and in the 385–386 defense of the Milanese basilicas against Empress Justina.
Atlas of Saints wrote this summary of section 3 of De fide ad Gratianum Augustum by Saint Ambrose. It uses our own words. It is not a quotation from the book.
Cite this summary
Atlas of Saints. “Section 3 — The Council of Aquileia (381), De Spiritu Sancto, and the Defense of the Milanese Basilicas” Summary of De fide ad Gratianum Augustum, by Saint Ambrose. https://www.atlasofsaints.com/writings/de-fide-ad-gratianum/chapters/3#atlas-answer
Section breakdown
The theological arguments forged in De Fide ad Gratianum bore immediate ecclesiastical fruit. In September 381 Emperor Gratian convoked the Council of Aquileia. There thirty-five bishops assembled under the leadership of Bishop Valerian and Saint Ambrose to examine the Illyrian Arian bishops Palladius and Secundianus. Reading aloud the blasphemous letter of Arius sentence by sentence, Ambrose pressed Palladius to condemn each error. Palladius and Secundianus refused to confess that the Son is true God equal to the Father. In response, the council unanimously deposed them.
In the same year (381) Ambrose fulfilled his promise to Gratian. He did this by adding three books De Spiritu Sancto (drawing upon Basil the Great, Didymus the Blind, and Athanasius to prove the consubstantial divinity of the Holy Ghost) and in 382 De Incarnatione Dominici Sacramenti. The Arian Empress-Mother Justina demanded the Portian and New Basilicas of Milan for the Arians in 385–386. In response, Ambrose stood fast with his people inside the besieged church. In doing so, he showed them antiphonal Trinitarian hymns and declared that a bishop may surrender his own life. However, he can never hand over the temple of God.
The story inside
During Holy Week in 385 and 386, the Arian Empress Justina sent Gothic troops to surround the basilica in Milan. In addition, he demanded that Ambrose hand over the church for Arian worship. In response, Ambrose remained inside the sanctuary day and night with his flock, including Saint Monica. The aim here is to keep the people's courage high and confess the Trinity she was attacking. Ambrose introduced the Eastern custom of singing antiphonal hymns and psalms. In doing so, he moved the very soldiers outside to join the Catholic chant.
Lessons worth keeping
- 1
The five books of De Fide and the three books of De Spiritu Sancto together form the classic Latin patristic defense of the consubstantial Trinity before Augustine.
- 2
Sacred liturgy and Trinitarian hymnody unite clergy and laity when civil power attempts to usurp the Church's sanctuaries.
Test your recall
Which two Arian bishops were deposed at the Council of Aquileia in 381 through Saint Ambrose's examination, and how did Ambrose sustain his flock during Empress Justina's siege of the Milanese basilica?
Answer from memory first. Then check the summary and lessons above.
Notes & sources
2 notesFrom The Catholic Encyclopedia, Volume I: Aachen–Assize (1907). Line numbers show where each passage appears in the digitized text.
- 1.Lines 65489–65564
“Ambrose and the .-Vrians. — It was but natural that a prelate so high-minded, so affable, so kind to the poor, so completely devoting his great gifts to the service of Christ and of humanity, should soon win the enthusiastic love of his people. Rarely, if ever, has a Christian bishop Ijccn so universally popular, in the Ix'st sense of tliat much abused term, as Ambrose of Milan. This popularity, conjoined with his intrepidity, was the secret of his success in routing enthroned iniquity. The heretical Empress Justina and her barbarian advisers would many a time fain have silenced him by exile or assassination, but, like Herod in the case of the Baptist, they "feared the multitude". His heroic struggles against the aggressions of the .secular power have immortalized him as the model and forerunner of future Hlldebrands, Iteckets, and other champions of religious liberty. The elder Valentinian died suddenly in .'J7.5, the year following the consecration of .-Vnibrose, leaving his Arian brother Valens to scourge the East, and his oldest son, Grjitian, to rule the provinces formerly presided o\er by Ambrosius, with no provision for the go\ernment of Italy. The armv seized the reins and proclaimed emperor the son of Valentinian by his second wife. Justina, a boy four years old. Gratian good-naturedly acquiesced, and assigned to his half-brother the sovereignty of Italy, Illyricum, and Africa. Justina had prudently concealed her Arian views during the lifetime of her ortliodo.x husband, but now, al^etted by a powerful and mainly (Jothic faction at court, proclaimed her determination to rear her child in that heresy, and once more attempt to Arianize the West. This of necessity brought her into direct collision with the Bishop of Milan, who had quenched the last embers of Arianism in his diocese. That heresy had never been popular among the common people; it owed its artificial vitality to the intrigues of courtiers and sovereigns. As a preliminary to the impending contest, Ambrose, at the re<iuest of Gratian, who was about to lead an army to the relief of V'alens, and wished to have at hand an antidote against tJriental sophist rv, wrote his noble work, "be Tide ad Gratianum Augustum ", afterwards expanded, and extant in five books. The first passage at arms between Ambrose and the Empress was on the occasion of an episcopal election at Sirmium, the capital of Illyricum, and at the time the residence of Justina. Notwithstanding her efforts, Ambrose was successful in securing the election of a Catholic bishop. He followed up this victory by procuring, at the Council of Aquileia (381), over which ho presided, the deposition of the only remaining Arianizing prelates of the West. Palladius and Secundianiis, Ixitli Illyrians. The battle royal between Ambrose and the Empress, in the years :i.S.5, 386, has been grai)hi(ally described by Cardinal Newman in his "Historical Sketches". The question at issue was the surrender of one of the basilicas to the Arians for public worship. Throughout the long struggle .\mbroso displayed in an eminent degree all the qualities of a great leader. His intrepidity in the moments of personal danger was equalled only by his admirable moderation; for, at certain critical stages of the drama one word from him would have hurled the Empress and her son from their throne. That word was never sfioken. An enduring result of this great struggle with despotism Wiis the rapid development during its course of the ecclesiastical chant, of which Ambrose laid the foundation. Vnable to overcome the fortitude of the Bishop and the spirit of the people, the court finally desisted from its efforts. Ere long it was forced to call upon Ambrose to exert hini.self to save the imperilled throne.”
- 2.Lines 21688–21718
“mind, his clearness of insight, his intrepidity in maintaining the faith and discipline of ttye Church ? Whence but from his con- tempt of the world, from his fearing God alone? DECEMBER 8.— THE FEAST OF THE IMMACULATE CONCEPTION. N this day, so dear to every Catholic heart, we celebrate, in the first place, the moment in which Almighty God showed Mary, through the distance of ages, to our first parents as the Virgin Mother of the Divine Redeemer, the woman destined to crush the head of the serpent. And as by eternal decree she was”
