Section II · Location 2 of 3
Section 2 · Open to readFrom De fide ad Gratianum Augustum by Saint Ambrose
Edition: The Catholic Encyclopedia, Volume I: Aachen–Assize (1907)
Section 2 — Books III–V: The Twofold Rule of Biblical Exegesis against Arian Objections (379–380)
De fide ad Gratianum Augustum · Chapter 2 summary
Illyrian Arians attack Books I and II, Ambrose adds Books III–V for Gratian in 379–380. In response, establishing the patristic rule that distinguishes texts spoken of Christ's eternal Godhead from texts spoken of His assumed humanity.
Atlas of Saints wrote this summary of section 2 of De fide ad Gratianum Augustum by Saint Ambrose. It uses our own words. It is not a quotation from the book.
Cite this summary
Atlas of Saints. “Section 2 — Books III–V: The Twofold Rule of Biblical Exegesis against Arian Objections (379–380)” Summary of De fide ad Gratianum Augustum, by Saint Ambrose. https://www.atlasofsaints.com/writings/de-fide-ad-gratianum/chapters/2#atlas-answer
Section breakdown
Books I and II circulated in Illyricum and Milan. In response, the Arian bishops Palladius of Ratiaria and Secundianus of Singidunum attacked Ambrose's arguments and appealed to Emperor Gratian. Returning to Milan in 379, Gratian asked Ambrose to expand the work and answer the Arian objections in detail. Ambrose responded by writing Books III, IV, and V of De Fide (379–380). In doing so, he examined one by one the biblical proof-texts that Arians cited to claim the Son was inferior to the Father.
At the center of Books III–V stands the great patristic rule of Christological exegesis. Sacred Scripture speaks of Christ as equal to the Father, eternal, omnipotent, and Creator. In response, it speaks according to His divine substance as the Eternal Word. Scripture speaks of Him as sent, obedient, weeping, suffering, or saying 'The Father is greater than I' (John 14:28). In response, it speaks according to the form of a servant which He freely assumed in the Incarnation. Even Christ's statement that the Son knows not the day of judgment refers to His office as head of the mystical body, not to any ignorance in the Eternal Wisdom of God.
The story inside
Arian controversialists in Milan constantly quoted Christ's words in the Gospel ('The Father is greater than I' and 'Of that day and hour knoweth no man, neither the Son') to persuade courtiers that the Son of God was a lesser creature. In Books III to V of De Fide, Ambrose taught Emperor Gratian the simple key that unlocked every contested verse: distinguishing what belongs to Christ according to His eternal Godhead from what belongs to the human nature He took from the Virgin Mary.
Lessons worth keeping
- 1
Sound biblical interpretation never pits one verse of Scripture against another. However, he separates Christ's divine nature from His assumed human nature.
- 2
The humility of Christ's Incarnation and Passion is the proof of His redeeming love, not a sign of inferiority in His Godhead.
Test your recall
Why did Saint Ambrose add Books III, IV, and V to De Fide in 379–380, and what exegetical rule did he use to answer Arian proof-texts?
Answer from memory first. Then check the summary and lessons above.
Notes & sources
1 noteFrom The Catholic Encyclopedia, Volume I: Aachen–Assize (1907). Line numbers show where each passage appears in the digitized text.
- 1.Lines 65718–65912
“Writings op Saint Ambrose. — The special character and value of the writings of St. Ambrose are at once tangible in the title of Doctor of the Church, which from time immemorial he has shared in the West with St. Jerome, St. Augustine, and St. Gregory. He is an official witness to the teaching of the Catholic Church in his own time and in the preceding centuries. As such his writings have been constantly invoked by popes, councils, and theologians; even in his own day it was felt that few could voice so clearly the true sense of the Scriptures and the teaching of the Church (St. Augustine, De doctrin^ christ., IV, 46, 48, 50). Ambrose is pre-eminently the ecclesiastical teacher, setting forth in a sound and edifying way, and with conscientious regularity, the deposit of faith as made known to him. He is not the philosophic scholar meditating in silence and retirement on the truths of the Christian Faith, but the strenuous administrator, bishop, and statesman, whose writings are only the mature expression of his ofiicial life and labours. Most of his writings are really homilies, spoken commentaries on the Old and New Testaments, taken down by his hearers, and afterwards reduced to their present form, though very few of these discourses have reached us exactly as they fell from the lips of the great bishop. In Ambrose the native Roman genius shines out with surpassing di.stinclne.ss; he is clear, sober, practical, and aims always at persuading his hearers to act at once on the principles and argvnnents he has laid down, which affect nearly everj' phase of their religious or moral life. "He is a genuine Roman in whom the ethico-practical note is always dominant. He had neither time nor liking for philosophico-dogniatic speculations. In all iiis writings he follows some practical purpose, ileiice lie is often content to reproduce what has been already treatc<l, to turn over for another harvest a field already worked. He often draws abundantly from the ideas of some earlier writer, Christian or pagan, but adapts these thoughts with tact and inteliipence to the larger public of his time and his people. In formal |>erfection his writings leave something to be desired; a fact that need not surprise us vvlien we recall the demands on the time of such a busy man. His diction abounds in unconscious reminiscences of classical writers, Greek and Roman. He is especiidly conversant with the writings of Ver- fil. His style is in every way peculiar and personal, t is never wanting in a certain dignified reserve; when it appears more carefully studied than is usual with him, its characteristics are energetic brevity and bold originaUty. Those of his writings that are homiletic in origin and form betray naturally the great oratorical gifts of .\mbrose; in them he rises occasionally to a noble height of poetical inspiration. His hymns are a suflicient evidence of the sure ma.stery that he possessed over the Latin language." (Hardcnhewer, Les o^res de lY-glise, Paris, 1898, 73(i-7;57; cf. Pruner, Die Theologie des heil. Ainbro.sius, Eichstadt, 18G1.) For convenience sake his extant writings may be divided into four classes: exegetical, dogmatic, a.scetico-moral, and occasional. The excgctic;vl writings, or scripture-commentaries deal witli tlie story of Creation, the Old Testament figures of ('ain and .Vbel, Noe, .Vbrahanj and the patrianhs. IMias, Tobias, David and the Psalms, and otlicr ,sul)jocts. Of his discourses on the New Testament only the lengthy commentary on St. Luke has reached us (Expositio in Lucam). He is not the author of the admirable commentary on the thirteen Epistles of St. Paul known as " Ambrosiaster". Altogether these Scripture commentaries make up more than one half of the writings of .\mbrosc. He deliglits in the allegorico-mystical interpretation of Scripture, i. e. while admitting the natural or literal sense he .seeks everj'vvhere a deeper mystic meaning that he converts into practical instruction for Christian life. In this, says St. Jerome (Kp. xli) "he was a disciple of Origen, but after the modifications in that master's manner due to St. Hippolytus of Rome and St. H.a.sil the (ireat". He was also influenced in this direction by the Jewish writer Philo to such an extent that the mucli corrupteil text of the latter can often be successfully corrected from the echoes and reminiscences met with in tlie works of .\mbro.se. It is to be noted, however, that in his use of non- Christian writers the great Doctor never abandons a strictly Christian attitude (cf. Kellner, Der heilige Ambrosius als Erkliirer des Alten Testaraentes, Ratisbon, 189.3). The most influential of his ascetico-mor.al writings is the work on the duties of Christian ecclesiastics (De odiciis niinistrorum). It is a manual of Christian morality, and in its order and disposition follows closely tlie homonymous work of Cicero. "Nevertheless", .says Dr. Hardenhewer, "the antithesis between the philosophical morality of the pagan and the morality of the Christian ecclesiastic is acute and striking. In liis exhortations, partic\darly, Ambro.-ie betrays an irresistible spiritual power" (cf. R. Thamin, Saint .\mbroise ct la morale chr(5- tienne au miatriOme siecle, Paris, 189.")). He wrote several works on virginity, or rather published a number of his discourses on that virtue, the most important of which is the treatise "On Virgins" adilresscd to his sister Marcellina, herself a virgin consecrated to the divine service. St. Jerome .says (Ep. xxii) that he w.as the most eloquent and exhaustive of all the exponents of virginity, and this juilgment expresses yet the opinion of the Church. The genuineness of the touching little work "On the Fail of a Consecrated Virgin (De lapsu virginis consecrataO has been called in question, but without sufficient rea.son. Dom Cierniain Morin maintains that it is a real homily of .Vmbrose, but like so many more of his so-called " books", owes its actual form tc some one of his auditors. His dogmatic writings deal mostly with the divinity of Jesus Christ and of the Holy Ghost, also with the Christian sacraments. ,\t the request of the young Emperor Gratian (375- 3S3) he c()m[)osed a defence of the true divinity of Jesus Clirist against the .\rians, and another on the true divinity of the Holy Ghost against the .Macedonians; also a work on the Incarnation of Our Lord. His work "On Penance" was written in refutation of the rigoristic tenets of the Novatians an<l abounds in useful evidences of the power of the Church to forgive sins, the necessity of confession and the meritorious character of good works. A special work on Baptism (De Sacramento regenerationis), often (pioted by St. Augustine, has perished. We possess yet, however, his excellent treatise (De Mysteriis) on Baptism, Confirmation, and the Blessed Eucharist (P. L., XVI, -4 17-lGl.'), addre.s.sed to the newlybaptized. Its genuineness has been called in doubt by opponents of Catholic teaching concerning the Eucharist, but without any good reason. It is highly probable that the work on the sacraments (De Sacramentis, ibid.) is identical with the preceding work; only, says Bardenhewer, "indiscreetly pubhshed by some hearer of Ambrose". Its e\idences to the sacrificial character of the Mass, and to the antiquity of the Roman Canon of the Mass are too well known to need more than a mention; some of them may easily be seen in any edition of the Roman Breviary (cf. Probst, Die Liturgic des vierten Jahrhunderts und deren Reform, Milnster, 1893, 232-239). The correspondence of .Ambrose includes but a few confidential or personal letters; most of his letters are oflicial notes, memorials on public affairs, reports of councils held, and the like. Their historical value is, however, of the first order, and they exhibit him as a Roman ailministrator and statesman second to none in Church or State. If his personal letters are unimportant, his remaining discourscsare of a very high order. His work on the death (378) of his brother Satyrus (De excessu fratris sui Satyri) contains his funeral sermon on this brother, one of the earliest of Christian panegj-rics and a model of the con.solatory discourses that were henceforth to take the place of the cold and inept declamations of the Stoics. His funeral discourses on Valentinian II (392), and Theodosius the Great (39.3) are considered models of rhetorical composition; (cf. Villem.ain, De IV'loquence chrC'ticnne. Paris, ed. 1S9I); they are also nistorical documents of much importance. Such, also, are his discourse against the Arian intruder, Auxentius (Contra Auxentium de basilicis tradendis) and his two discourses on the finding of the bodies of the Milanese martjTS Ger\'asius and Protasius. Not a few works have been falsely attributed to St. Ambrose; most of them are found in the Benedictine edition of his WTitings (reprinted in Migne) and are di.scussed in the manuals of patrologj- (e. g. Bardenhewer). Some of his genuine works appear to have been lost, e. g. the already mentioned work on baptism. St. Augustine (Ep. 31. 8) is loud in his praise of a (now lost) work of Ambrose written against those who as.sertoa an intellectual dependency of Je.sus Christ on Plato. It is not improbalilc lliat he is really the author of the Latin translation and paraphra.se of Josephus (De Brllo Judaico). known in the Middle Ages as Hegesippus or Egcsippus, a distortion of the Greek name of the origmal author (' I (JcrrjTro!) . Monimsen denies (1890) his authorship of the famous Roman law text known as the " Lex Dei, sive Mosaicanim et Romanarum Legum Collatio", an attempt to exhibit the law of Moses as the historical source wlience Roman criminal jurisprudence drew its principal dispositions.”
