Section II · Location 2 of 3
Section 2 · Open to readFrom Theological treatises against the Adoptianism of Felix of Urgel (PL CIII, 1381–1420) by Saint Benedict of Aniane
Edition: The Catholic Encyclopedia, Volume II: Assize–Brownson (1907)
Section 2 — Refuting the Adoptianist Heresy of Bishop Felix of Urgel (PL CIII, 1381–1420)
Theological treatises against the Adoptianism of Felix of Urgel (PL CIII, 1381–1420) · Chapter 2 summary
Bishop Felix of Urgel spreads the Adoptianist heresy into Septimania. In response, Abbot Benedict composes his dogmatic treatises and letters (PL CIII, 1381–1420). In doing so, he proves that the Incarnate Word is one Person and the natural Son of God.
Atlas of Saints wrote this summary of section 2 of Theological treatises against the Adoptianism of Felix of Urgel (PL CIII, 1381–1420) by Saint Benedict of Aniane. It uses our own words. It is not a quotation from the book.
Cite this summary
Atlas of Saints. “Section 2 — Refuting the Adoptianist Heresy of Bishop Felix of Urgel (PL CIII, 1381–1420)” Summary of Theological treatises against the Adoptianism of Felix of Urgel (PL CIII, 1381–1420), by Saint Benedict of Aniane. https://www.atlasofsaints.com/writings/treatises-against-adoptianism/chapters/2#atlas-answer
Section breakdown
In the last decades of the eighth century, Archbishop Elipandus of Toledo and Bishop Felix of Urgel (whose Catalan diocese bordered Charlemagne's Spanish March) revived a Nestorianizing error known as Adoptianism. Admitting that Christ according to His divine nature was the true and natural Son of God. At the same time, Felix of Urgel taught that according to His human nature Christ was only the 'adopted' and 'nominal' Son of God (filius adoptivus et nuncupativus). Because Urgel lay adjacent to Septimania, the heresy spread rapidly among monks, clergy, and laypeople near Aniane.
Working closely with Charlemagne's theological adviser Alcuin and Archbishop Leidrad of Lyons, Abbot Benedict of Aniane preached throughout the infected provinces. Moreover, he composed the group of dogmatic treatises and letters printed in Migne's Patrologia Latina (Vol. CIII, cols. 1381–1420). Against Felix of Urgel, Benedict demonstrated from Scripture and the Fathers that sonship belongs to the Person, not to the nature in isolation. The human nature of Jesus has no separate human person but subsists in the one Eternal Person of God the Son. Therefore, the Son of the Virgin Mary is by nature—and never by mere adoption—the Only-Begotten Son of the Father.
The story inside
Bishop Felix of Urgel's teaching crossed the Pyrenees into Septimania. In response, Charlemagne commissioned Archbishop Leidrad of Lyons, Bishop Nefridius of Narbonne, and Abbot Benedict of Aniane to travel directly to Urgel in 799. Combining doctrinal clarity with monastic charity, Benedict and his colleagues persuaded Felix to appear before the synod at Aachen. At the same time, Benedict wrote his anti-Adoptianist treatises to fortify the monks and clergy of southern Gaul.
Lessons worth keeping
- 1
Dividing Christ into two sons (one natural and one adopted) destroys the unity of His divine Person established at Ephesus and Chalcedon.
- 2
The Eternal Word assumed human nature into His own Person. Therefore, we become adopted children of God precisely through Him who is the one natural Son of God.
Test your recall
What did the Adoptianist heresy of Bishop Felix of Urgel teach about Christ's human nature, and how did Saint Benedict of Aniane refute it in his treatises?
Answer from memory first. Then check the summary and lessons above.
Notes & sources
1 noteFrom The Catholic Encyclopedia, Volume II: Assize–Brownson (1907). Line numbers show where each passage appears in the digitized text.
- 1.Lines 77231–77256
“which wa,s to be an exemplar for all other abbeys. and to be under the guidance of Benedict. In the •dogmatic controversy over Adoptianism, under the leadership of Felix of Trgel, Benedict took the part of orthodoxy. To promote the monastic reforms, he compiled a collection of monastic rules. A pupil of his, the monk Ardo, wrote a biography of the great abbot. For Benedict's writings see Codex regularum monasticarum el canonicarum in P. L., CIII, 393-702; Concordia rcgulaTum. loc. cit.; Letters, loc. cit., 703-1380. Other treatises (loc. cit., 1381 sqq.) a.scribed to him are probably not authentic. Ardo Smar.vgdus, Life, op. cit., CIII, 353 sqq.; Man. Germ. Hist.: Script., XV, I, 200-220; Acta SS., Feb., II, 606 sqq.; NicOLAi, Der hi. Benedikt, Grunder von Aniane und Cornelia munster (Cologne, 1865); Paulinier. S. Beno'it d'.lniane el la fondatian du monasttre de ce nam (Montpellier, 1871); Foss, Benedikt von Aniane (Berlin, 1884); Pickert, Aniane und Gellone (Leipzig. 1899); Hauck, Kirchengesch. Dcutschlands (2nd ed., Leipzig, 1900), II, 575 sqq.; Butler, Lives of the Saints, 12 Feb. J. P. KlHSCH.”
