Skip to content
Atlas of Saints

The Religious State, Together with a Short Treatise on the Vocation to the Priesthood

Section 4 · Saint Alphonsus Liguori

Section IV · Location 4 of 4

Section 4 · Open to read

From The Religious State, Together with a Short Treatise on the Vocation to the Priesthood by Saint Alphonsus Liguori

Edition: The Religious State, Together with a Short Treatise on the Vocation to the Priesthood, trans. Edited by Rev. Eugene Grimm, C.SS.R. (1889)

The Vocation to the Priesthood: Divine Call, Marks of Vocation, and Dangers of Uncalled Entry (Sections I–III)

The Religious State, Together with a Short Treatise on the Vocation to the Priesthood · Chapter 4 summary

No man may enter the priesthood unless called by God as Aaron was (Hebrews 5:4). A true priestly vocation is discerned not by family patrimony or parental will, but by three concurrent marks. These include pure intention, sufficient theological learning, and long-tested holiness of life.

Atlas of Saints wrote this summary of section 4 of The Religious State, Together with a Short Treatise on the Vocation to the Priesthood by Saint Alphonsus Liguori. It uses our own words. It is not a quotation from the book.

Cite this summary

Atlas of Saints. “The Vocation to the Priesthood: Divine Call, Marks of Vocation, and Dangers of Uncalled Entry (Sections I–III)” Summary of The Religious State, Together with a Short Treatise on the Vocation to the Priesthood, by Saint Alphonsus Liguori. https://www.atlasofsaints.com/writings/the-religious-state-and-vocation-to-the-priesthood/chapters/4#atlas-answer

Section breakdown

In his 'Short Treatise on the Vocation to the Priesthood', St. Alphonsus begins from the apostolic rule of Hebrews 5:4: 'Neither doth any man take the honor to himself. Yet he that is called by God, as Aaron was.' He cites the Council of Trent, St. Augustine, St. Gregory the Great, and St. John Chrysostom. Then he proves that no one may enter the sanctuary of Holy Orders without a positive divine call. The priesthood places a man in the office of mediator between God and the people (requiring angelic chastity and heroic charity amid constant spiritual dangers). Therefore (anyone who forces his way into the priesthood without God's call deprives himself of the special vocation graces needed to stand firm). In addition, he exposes both himself and the flock to ruin.

Alphonsus next exposes the false motives that are never marks of a divine call to the priesthood. A young man is not called by God merely because he is the younger son of a family. Nor is this because an ecclesiastical benefice or family chapel would otherwise pass to strangers. Nor is this because he possesses natural talent for study. Above all (the ambition or avarice of parents who push an uncalled son into the priesthood to enrich their house or advance their family name is an abomination before God that draws down malediction rather than blessing).

How, then, can a candidate and his spiritual director recognize a genuine vocation to the priesthood? Alphonsus establishes three true marks that must all be present together. The first mark is purity of intention. The candidate must seek to enter Holy Orders solely for the glory of God, his own sanctification (and the salvation of souls) (not for ease), honor, or income. The second mark is science and talent. He must possess the solid theological and moral learning required to administer the sacraments worthily and direct consciences. The third mark is positive, tried goodness of life. He receives Sacred Orders. Then he must already practice habitual prayer, frequent the sacraments (and have proved over a long time that he has conquered habitual mortal sin), especially the vice of impurity.

In his concluding warnings to bishops, confessors, parents, and candidates (Alphonsus refutes the fatal illusion that receiving Holy Orders will cure a young man who is still enslaved to habitual impurity or vice). Because an uncalled intruder enters the sanctuary by sin, ordination only hardens his chains and turns sacrilege into habit. Confessors must refuse absolution both to unproved candidates who presume to take Orders in (habitual sin and to parents who force or entice their sons into the priesthood without a vocation).

The story inside

When a father urges his son to become a priest so that a wealthy (family benefice will not pass out of the house)(or when a confessor considers allowing a young man still struggling with habitual impurity (to be ordained in the hope that the grace of the priesthood will reform him)) (how must moral theology judge both cases)? St. Alphonsus answers from Hebrews 5:4 and the Fathers of the Church that both act toward eternal ruin. First, family wealth and parental ambition are motives of flesh and blood, never a call from God. Second, sacramental grace helps those whom God calls. By contrast (a young man who enters the sanctuary enslaved to habitual vice without having proved his chastity commits a sacrilegious intrusion that turns the altar itself into his condemnation).

Lessons worth keeping

  1. 1

    Entering the priesthood without a divine call ('as Aaron was,' Hebrews 5:4) is a presumptuous intrusion that forfeits the special graces required for priestly chastity and ministry.

  2. 2

    Family birth, ecclesiastical benefices, natural talent alone (and parental ambition to enrich the family house are never valid marks of a priestly vocation).

  3. 3

    A true vocation to the priesthood requires three marks together. A pure intention to serve God and save souls, competent theological learning (and long-tested virtue and chastity proved before ordination).

Test your recall

What three marks must be present together to prove a genuine divine vocation to the priesthood, and why is it wrong to ordain an unproved candidate in the hope that Holy Orders will cure his habitual sins?

Answer from memory first. Then check the summary and lessons above.

Notes & sources

3 notes

From The Religious State, Together with a Short Treatise on the Vocation to the Priesthood, trans. Edited by Rev. Eugene Grimm, C.SS.R. (1889). Line numbers show where each passage appears in the digitized text.

  1. 1.
    Lines 7725–7780
    “St. Cyril of Alexandria, "such are the”
  2. 2.
    Lines 8080–8135
    “nor to advance the family, nor for the sake”
  3. 3.
    Lines 8300–8355
    “priest is appointed to exercise the most”

Location: section 4 of 4 · 100%

Display settings