Section LI · Location 51 of 80
Section 51 · Open to readFrom Summa Theologica by Saint Thomas Aquinas
Edition: Summa Theologica, Third Part, Questions 1–26: Treatise on the Incarnation, trans. Fathers of the English Dominican Province (1913)
Third Part — The Bodily and Spiritual Defects Assumed by Christ and the Unity of His Being, Will, and Operation (Questions 14–19)
Summa Theologica · Chapter 51 summary
Christ voluntarily assumed common bodily penalties (hunger, thirst, weariness, pain, and death) to satisfy for our sins and prove His true humanity. At the same time, he remains wholly free from sin, ignorance, and disordered concupiscence. In Christ's soul there were genuine, sinless passions (`propassiones`) of sorrow, fear, and sensible pain that never anticipated or clouded the judgment of His reason.
Atlas of Saints wrote this summary of section 51 of Summa Theologica by Saint Thomas Aquinas. It uses our own words. It is not a quotation from the book.
Cite this summary
Atlas of Saints. “Third Part — The Bodily and Spiritual Defects Assumed by Christ and the Unity of His Being, Will, and Operation (Questions 14–19)” Summary of Summa Theologica, by Saint Thomas Aquinas. https://www.atlasofsaints.com/writings/summa-theologica/chapters/51#atlas-answer
Section breakdown
Alongside the perfection of grace and wisdom, the Son of God voluntarily assumed certain bodily and spiritual defects. As a result, He could offer satisfaction for our sins, and prove the reality of His human nature. In addition, he could give us an example of patience. He took upon Himself the common, blameless penalties of human nature—hunger, thirst, fatigue, bodily pain, and mortality—while rejecting personal defects like sickness, ignorance, sin, and the disordered rebellion of concupiscence (the fomes peccati). In His soul, Christ possessed sinless human passions (`propassiones`) of sensible pain, sorrow, fear, and wonder without ever disturbing His higher reason. Because of the union of two natures in one Person, what belongs to either nature is truly predicated of the one Person of Christ (`communicatio idiomatum`). Christ has only one personal Being (`esse`). At the same time, He possesses two complete wills (divine and human) and two distinct operations (divine and human) acting in complete harmony. As a result, His human actions are theurgic and meritorious for Himself and for us.
In Questions 14–15, Thomas Aquinas explains that Christ freely assumed the common, blameless bodily penalties of fallen humanity (hunger, thirst, pain, and mortality) and sinless human affections (`propassiones` of sorrow, fear, wonder, and righteous zeal). At the same time, he remained completely free from sin, ignorance, and the `fomes` of concupiscence. Question 15 opens the examination of Christ's sinlessness, freedom from disordered concupiscence, and sinless human affections. In Questions 16–17, Aquinas establishes the logical rules of the `communicatio idiomatum`—why 'God is man' and 'Man is God' are literally true in the concrete. Moreover, he proves that because there is one hypostasis in Christ, there is one personal substantial existence (`esse`).
Question 16 sets forth the rules of Christological predication (communicatio idiomatum) based on St. John Damascene. In Questions 18–19, Aquinas defends the Sixth Ecumenical Council (Constantinople III) against Monothelitism. This proves that Christ had two distinct wills and two operations (with His human nature acting as the living, free instrument of His Divinity) and that Christ merited bodily glory and our salvation. In Question 18, Christ's human will remained in total conformity with the divine will even while His natural human appetite recoiled from bodily death. Against the Monothelite heresy, Christ possesses two distinct wills (divine and human) and two operations. In Gethsemane His natural sensitive and rational will shrank from death in itself. At the same time, His deliberate human will freely embraced the Father's plan.
The story inside
In the Garden of Gethsemane, Jesus prayed, 'Father, if it be possible, let this chalice pass from Me; nevertheless not as I will, but as Thou wilt' (Matthew 26:39). How could Christ wish the cup of suffering to pass from Him without His human will opposing God's will? In Question 18, Articles 5 and 6, Aquinas distinguishes between the natural appetite of sensibility and reason Considered simply in itself (`voluntas ut natura`) (which naturally and rightly recoils from bodily pain and death as evils to human nature). Moreover, he the deliberate rational will considering all things in order to the divine end (`voluntas ut ratio`). God Himself willed that Christ's human nature should feel its natural horror of death. At the same time, Christ's deliberate human will freely chose the Cross for our redemption. Feeling a natural human dread of suffering and death is not a sin or rebellion when the deliberate will freely submits to God's plan.
Lessons worth keeping
- 1
Christ voluntarily assumed common bodily penalties (hunger, thirst, weariness, pain, and death) to satisfy for our sins and prove His true humanity. At the same time, he remains wholly free from sin, ignorance, and disordered concupiscence.
- 2
In Christ's soul there were genuine, sinless passions (`propassiones`) of sorrow, fear, and sensible pain that never anticipated or clouded the judgment of His reason.
- 3
By the communication of properties (`communicatio idiomatum`), whatever belongs to either the divine or the human nature is truly predicated of the one Person of the Son of God.
- 4
Against the Monothelite heresy, Christ possesses two distinct wills (divine and human) and two operations. In Gethsemane His natural sensitive and rational will shrank from death in itself. At the same time, His deliberate human will freely embraced the Father's plan.
Test your recall
Why did Christ assume common bodily defects like hunger, thirst, and death, but not particular diseases like fever or leprosy?
Answer from memory first. Then check the summary and lessons above.
Notes & sources
3 notesFrom Summa Theologica, Third Part, Questions 1–26: Treatise on the Incarnation, trans. Fathers of the English Dominican Province (1913). Line numbers show where each passage appears in the digitized text.
- 1.Lines 8979–8981
“Ohj. 2. Further, the soul of Christ saw the Word of God by the vision wherein the blessed see, as was said above (Q. IX., A. 2), and thus the soul of Christ was blessed.”
- 2.Lines 10301–10302
“Ohj. 2. Further, the three Divine Persons are in greater mutual agreement than the human nature and the Divine.”
- 3.Lines 11443–11445
“Obj. 4. Further, Christ is something that the Father is, and something that the Father is not. Therefore Christ is one thing and another. Therefore Christ is two.”
