Skip to content
Atlas of Saints

Summa Theologica

Section 5 · Saint Thomas Aquinas

Section V · Location 5 of 80

Section 5 · Open to read

From Summa Theologica by Saint Thomas Aquinas

Edition: Summa Theologica, First Part, Questions 27–49: Treatise on the Blessed Trinity and Treatise on the Creation, trans. Fathers of the English Dominican Province (1912)

First Part — The Processions, Relations, and Plurality of Persons in God, and Our Knowledge of the Trinity (Questions 27–32)

Summa Theologica · Chapter 5 summary

Divine procession is not an outward production of a creature, but an immanent action of Intellect (the Word) and Will (Love). In doing so, he remains within the one God. Real relations of origin (paternity, filiation, and passive spiration) distinguish the three Divine Persons without dividing or compounding the simple divine essence.

Atlas of Saints wrote this summary of section 5 of Summa Theologica by Saint Thomas Aquinas. It uses our own words. It is not a quotation from the book.

Cite this summary

Atlas of Saints. “First Part — The Processions, Relations, and Plurality of Persons in God, and Our Knowledge of the Trinity (Questions 27–32)” Summary of Summa Theologica, by Saint Thomas Aquinas. https://www.atlasofsaints.com/writings/summa-theologica/chapters/5#atlas-answer

Section breakdown

Thomas Aquinas examines the unity of the Divine Essence in Questions 1–26 of the First Part. Then he opens the Treatise on the Blessed Trinity in Question 27. Heretics such as Arius and Sabellius erred because they imagined divine procession as an outward effect. In doing so, he makes the Son either a lesser creature (Arius) or a mere aspect of the Father (Sabellius). Aquinas shows that in an intellectual nature, procession remains immanently within the agent itself. First is the procession of the intellect's concept, the Word (which in God is true generation of the Son), and second, the procession of the will's impulse, Love (the spiration of the Holy Ghost). These two internal processions establish four real relations in God (paternity, filiation, spiration, and procession) three of which are mutually opposed and therefore constitute three distinct subsisting Persons in one undivided essence. By natural reason alone, humans can prove God's unity and attributes from creatures. However, the Trinity of Persons can be known only by divine revelation.

In Questions 27–28, Thomas Aquinas demonstrates that God has exactly two immanent processions—the intellect's procession of the Word (generation) and the will's procession of Love (spiration)—which ground real relations of opposition in God. In Question 27, Arius and Sabellius both erred. He does this by treating procession in God as an outward effect rather than an inward intellectual act. In Questions 29–31, Aquinas defines a Divine Person as a subsisting relation in the divine nature. This shows why there can be neither fewer nor more than three Persons in the Godhead.

Question 29 analyzes Boethius's classic definition of Person and how 'person' applies analogically and supremely to God. In Question 32, Aquinas argues that the Trinity of Persons cannot be demonstrated by natural philosophical reason from created effects. Moreover, he warns that trying to prove the Trinity by weak arguments exposes the Catholic faith to the ridicule of unbelievers. Question 31 sets forth the rules of Trinitarian language to guard against both Arian separation and Sabellian confusion. Natural human reason cannot demonstrate the Trinity of Persons from created effects. This is because creatures proceed from the one creative power common to all three Persons.

The story inside

Some well-meaning Christian thinkers tried to prove by pure philosophical necessity that God must be three Persons. Specifically, infinite goodness must diffuse itself in three ways. In Question 32, Article 1, Aquinas firmly rejects such attempts. Every natural proof of God starts from created effects. The creative power that produces the universe belongs in common to the whole Trinity as one God. Therefore, natural reason can prove what belongs to the unity of God's essence, but never the distinction of the three Persons. Worse still, when a Christian tells non-believers that he can prove the Trinity by reason. Moreover, he offers unconvincing arguments, non-believers laugh and assume the whole Christian faith rests on weak logic. Respect the boundary between natural reason and divine revelation. As a result, mysteries of faith are defended with honesty and rigor.

Lessons worth keeping

  1. 1

    Divine procession is not an outward production of a creature, but an immanent action of Intellect (the Word) and Will (Love). In doing so, he remains within the one God.

  2. 2

    Real relations of origin (paternity, filiation, and passive spiration) distinguish the three Divine Persons without dividing or compounding the simple divine essence.

  3. 3

    Following Boethius, a Divine Person is an 'individual substance of a rational nature', signifying in God a subsisting relation.

  4. 4

    Natural human reason cannot demonstrate the Trinity of Persons from created effects. This is because creatures proceed from the one creative power common to all three Persons.

Test your recall

How did Arius and Sabellius both make the same root mistake about procession in God?

Answer from memory first. Then check the summary and lessons above.

Notes & sources

3 notes

From Summa Theologica, First Part, Questions 27–49: Treatise on the Blessed Trinity and Treatise on the Creation, trans. Fathers of the English Dominican Province (1912). Line numbers show where each passage appears in the digitized text.

  1. 1.
    Lines 264–267
    “Obj. 2. Further, everything which proceeds differs from that whence it proceeds. But in God there is no diversity; but supreme simpHcity. Therefore in God there is no procession.”
  2. 2.
    Lines 1399–1401
    “God, so we say there are three subsistences in God; which impHes that person and subsistence have the same meaning. Therefore person and subsistence mean the same.”
  3. 3.
    Lines 2324–2326
    “Therefore, if Trinity exists in God, it exists in the unity of the divine essence; and thus in God there would be three essential unities; which is heresy.”

Location: section 5 of 80 · 6%

Display settings