Section XLVII · Location 47 of 80
Section 47 · Open to readFrom Summa Theologica by Saint Thomas Aquinas
Edition: Summa Theologica, Second Part of the Second Part, Questions 171–189: Treatise on Gratuitous Graces, Active and Contemplative Life, and the States of Life, trans. Fathers of the English Dominican Province (1922)
Second Part of the Second Part — Human Duties, the State of Perfection in General, and the Episcopal State (Questions 183–185)
Summa Theologica · Chapter 47 summary
The diversity of offices and states in the Church serves the perfection, necessary ministry, and beauty of the mystical body of Christ. Christian perfection consists essentially in the precepts of charity (loving God and neighbor) and instrumentally in the evangelical counsels.
Atlas of Saints wrote this summary of section 47 of Summa Theologica by Saint Thomas Aquinas. It uses our own words. It is not a quotation from the book.
Cite this summary
Atlas of Saints. “Second Part of the Second Part — Human Duties, the State of Perfection in General, and the Episcopal State (Questions 183–185)” Summary of Summa Theologica, by Saint Thomas Aquinas. https://www.atlasofsaints.com/writings/summa-theologica/chapters/47#atlas-answer
Section breakdown
The third difference among Christians arises from their public offices and states of life, which give beauty and order to the Church. A 'state' properly signifies a stable condition of freedom or obligation under law. Christian perfection consists essentially in charity (the love of God and neighbor) and secondarily in the evangelical counsels that remove obstacles to charity. Therefore, a public 'state of perfection' requires a perpetual, solemn obligation to the works of perfection. Only two states in the Church are states of perfection: the state of religious. He bind themselves by vow to strive toward perfection, and the state of bishops. They bind themselves as shepherds already possessing pastoral perfection to lay down their lives for their flock.
In Question 183, Thomas Aquinas explains that diverse offices and states exist in the Church to reflect divine wisdom, provide for every spiritual need, and adorn the body of Christ, defining a state as a permanent condition of freedom or servitude. Question 183 distinguishes an office or duty (officium), which refers to an action to be performed, from a state (status), which denotes a permanent condition of freedom or servitude. In Question 184, Aquinas establishes that Christian perfection consists essentially in charity and secondarily in the counsels. Furthermore, the public state of perfection belongs only to bishops (as perfecters) and religious (as those bound by vow to tend toward perfection).
Question 184 compares the episcopal state of active pastoral perfection with the religious state of schooling in perfection and with parish priests. In Question 185, Aquinas rules that desiring the episcopate out of ambition is presumptuous. Moreover, a candidate must accept when commanded by his superior. Furthermore, a bishop must remain with his flock in persecution whenever his absence would endanger their souls. In Question 185, bishops must administer Church goods as stewards for the poor rather than as private worldly riches. Bishops are in a state of perfection as teachers and shepherds bound to lay down their lives for their sheep,. In this way, they may never desert their flock in danger.
The story inside
In John 10:12, Christ condemns the hireling who sees the wolf coming, leaves the sheep, and flees. Yet in Matthew 10:23, Christ tells His disciples, 'When they shall persecute you in this city, flee into another', and Saint Athanasius and Saint Paul both escaped when their lives were sought. Following Saint Augustine's letter to Honoratus, Question 185 resolves this pastoral dilemma. A bishop binds himself at consecration to lay down his life for his flock. Therefore, he sins gravely if he flees when the flock itself is in spiritual danger. In addition, he lacks other ministers to baptize, absolve, and strengthen them. Only when the persecutor seeks the bishop's person alone and the flock is fully provided for by other pastors may the bishop withdraw to preserve his ministry for the future. A true shepherd places the spiritual safety of his flock above his own life. Moreover, he abandons his people without pastoral care in the hour of danger.
Lessons worth keeping
- 1
The diversity of offices and states in the Church serves the perfection, necessary ministry, and beauty of the mystical body of Christ.
- 2
Christian perfection consists essentially in the precepts of charity (loving God and neighbor) and instrumentally in the evangelical counsels.
- 3
A person may be interiorly perfect without being in the public state of perfection, or be in the state of perfection. At the same time, interiorly failing to live up to it.
- 4
Bishops are in a state of perfection as teachers and shepherds bound to lay down their lives for their sheep,. In this way, they may never desert their flock in danger.
Test your recall
Why does Christian perfection consist essentially in the commandments of charity rather than in the evangelical counsels?
Answer from memory first. Then check the summary and lessons above.
Notes & sources
3 notesFrom Summa Theologica, Second Part of the Second Part, Questions 171–189: Treatise on Gratuitous Graces, Active and Contemplative Life, and the States of Life, trans. Fathers of the English Dominican Province (1922). Line numbers show where each passage appears in the digitized text.
- 1.Lines 6596–6598
“The stone is foursquare, and is stable on all sides, if no disturbance will make it fall. Now it is virtue that enables us to act with immobility, according to Ethic, ii. i, 2.”
- 2.Lines 7370–7372
“Ohj. 3. Further, A man acquires a state by being freed from servitude. But one is freed from the servitude of sin by charity, because chanty cover eth all sins (Prov. x. 12).”
- 3.Lines 8372–8376
“Secondly, because this is contrary to humility, whereby a man submits to his superior's commands: hence Gregory says [Pastor, i. 6): In God's sight humility is true when it does not obstinately refuse to submit to what is usefully prescribed.”
