Section XXXV · Location 35 of 80
Section 35 · Open to readFrom Summa Theologica by Saint Thomas Aquinas
Edition: Summa Theologica, Second Part of the Second Part, Questions 80–100: Potential Parts of Justice and the Virtue of Religion, trans. Fathers of the English Dominican Province (1922)
Second Part of the Second Part — Adjuration, Divine Praise, Superstition, Idolatry, and Divination (Questions 90–95)
Summa Theologica · Chapter 35 summary
Sacred singing and church music are lawful acts of religion when used to stir interior devotion in the weak rather than to indulge theatrical pleasure. Superstition is a vice opposed to religion by excess—not because anyone can worship God too much. However, because it offers worship to whom it ought not or in a manner it ought not.
Atlas of Saints wrote this summary of section 35 of Summa Theologica by Saint Thomas Aquinas. It uses our own words. It is not a quotation from the book.
Cite this summary
Atlas of Saints. “Second Part of the Second Part — Adjuration, Divine Praise, Superstition, Idolatry, and Divination (Questions 90–95)” Summary of Summa Theologica, by Saint Thomas Aquinas. https://www.atlasofsaints.com/writings/summa-theologica/chapters/35#atlas-answer
Section breakdown
Aquinas concludes his study of the lawful acts of religion with adjuration (commanding or entreating in God's name) and vocal praise of God. This includes sacred chant and music, which are justified when they move the heart to devotion rather than theatrical vanity. He then turns to the vices opposed to religion by excess (superstition) where divine worship is either offered to the wrong object or offered to the true God in an improper, false manner. The gravest of all superstitions is idolatry, which gives the supreme worship of latria to creatures or images and is inspired internally by human pride and disordered affection and externally by demonic deceit. Closely allied to idolatry is divination, which usurps God's prerogative of knowing free and contingent future events by invoking demons explicitly or implicitly through astrology, auguries, omens, or lots.
In Questions 90–91, Thomas Aquinas teaches that Christians may lawfully adjure demons by Christ's compulsive power to prevent harm. Furthermore, vocal praise and sacred chant serve to arouse interior devotion toward God. In Question 91, we praise God with our lips not to inform Him of His goodness, but to stir our own and others' devotion toward Him. In Questions 92–94, Aquinas defines superstition as offering divine worship either to an undue recipient or in an undue mode. Moreover, he traces the historical roots of idolatry to disordered affection, flattery of rulers, and demonic fraud.
Question 94 shows why idolatry is the worst of sins against religion. Indeed, it directly opposes the highest good of divine sovereignty. In Question 95, Aquinas condemns divination as a usurpation of divine foreknowledge involving explicit or implicit pacts with demons. At the same time, he separates natural astronomical forecasts of weather or eclipses from astrological divination of free human choices. Question 95 proves against astrological fatalism that heavenly bodies can never make a direct impression on the spiritual intellect and free will. Judicial astrology and divination are unlawful because no star or physical body can compel the human intellect and free will. Seeking hidden futures beyond natural causes invites demonic interference.
The story inside
Astrologers in the thirteenth century claimed that the positions of the planets at a person's birth foretell his future decisions and destiny. Aquinas carefully separates real natural science from superstitious divination. Astronomers can rightly predict solar eclipses, droughts, or rain because heavenly bodies act naturally on lower physical elements. Even human bodily temperaments feel physical influences that incline the passions. Yet the human intellect and free will are wholly immaterial powers. No bodily star can force a spiritual mind. Wise men rule their passions by reason, defeating astrological predictions. When astrologers try to foretell free human events, demons step in to ensnare souls in superstition. Natural science studies physical causes, while human moral freedom remains master over bodily inclinations.
Lessons worth keeping
- 1
Sacred singing and church music are lawful acts of religion when used to stir interior devotion in the weak rather than to indulge theatrical pleasure.
- 2
Superstition is a vice opposed to religion by excess—not because anyone can worship God too much. However, because it offers worship to whom it ought not or in a manner it ought not.
- 3
Idolatry is the gravest of sins against religion because it sets up another lord against the one sovereign God.
- 4
Judicial astrology and divination are unlawful because no star or physical body can compel the human intellect and free will. Seeking hidden futures beyond natural causes invites demonic interference.
Test your recall
How can superstition be a vice by 'excess' of religion if we can never honor God enough?
Answer from memory first. Then check the summary and lessons above.
Notes & sources
3 notesFrom Summa Theologica, Second Part of the Second Part, Questions 80–100: Potential Parts of Justice and the Virtue of Religion, trans. Fathers of the English Dominican Province (1922). Line numbers show where each passage appears in the digitized text.
- 1.Lines 7193–7196
“Obj. 3. Further, To adjure is to induce a person to swear. Now it belongs to a man's superior to induce him to swear, for the superior imposes an oath on his subject. Therefore subjects cannot adjure their superiors.”
- 2.Lines 7560–7563
“But the great, who are in the church, ought not to sing: for Gregory says (Regist. iv.): By this present decree I ordain that the ministers should not sing in this abode of the sacred altar. Therefore singing is unsuitable to the divine praises.”
- 3.Lines 8278–8279
“Obj. 3. Further, The most high God should be honoured with an inward worship, according to John iv., God...”
