Section III · Location 3 of 80
Section 3 · Open to readFrom Summa Theologica by Saint Thomas Aquinas
Edition: Summa Theologica, First Part, Questions 1–26: Treatise on Sacred Doctrine and the One God, trans. Fathers of the English Dominican Province (1920)
First Part — The Life, Will, Love, Justice, and Mercy of God (Questions 18–21)
Summa Theologica · Chapter 3 summary
A thing is more perfectly alive the more its operation originates from within itself. Therefore, God (who is swayed by no external agent and whose intellect is His essence) possesses life in the supreme degree. God wills His own goodness necessarily, just as the human will necessarily wills happiness. However, He wills created things freely without any compulsion or internal change.
Atlas of Saints wrote this summary of section 3 of Summa Theologica by Saint Thomas Aquinas. It uses our own words. It is not a quotation from the book.
Cite this summary
Atlas of Saints. “First Part — The Life, Will, Love, Justice, and Mercy of God (Questions 18–21)” Summary of Summa Theologica, by Saint Thomas Aquinas. https://www.atlasofsaints.com/writings/summa-theologica/chapters/3#atlas-answer
Section breakdown
Since understanding belongs to living beings and willing follows upon understanding, Aquinas next examines the life of God (Question 18), and the will of God (Question 19). The account also covers the love of God (Question 20), and the justice and mercy of God (Question 21). Life belongs in the highest degree to that which moves itself to act by intellect. In addition, he will without being determined by another. Hence God, whose very understanding is His existence, is supreme Life itself. God's will has His own goodness as its necessary principal object. At the same time, He wills all created things freely as ordered to His goodness. God neither wills moral evil nor prevents all contingent freedom. Indeed, His will produces necessary causes for necessary effects and free causes for free effects. Human love is drawn forth by goodness already existing in the beloved. By contrast, God's love infuses and creates goodness in things, uniting distributive justice and mercy in every divine work.
In Questions 18–19, Thomas Aquinas proves that God is supreme Life and possesses will, willing His own goodness necessarily and all creatures freely. Moreover, the divine will is immutable and always fulfilled. Moreover, it causes free things to act freely rather than imposing universal necessity, and that God never wills moral evil. Question 18 compares plants, animals, and rational agents to show that intellectual beings move themselves to act most perfectly, culminating in God's self-subsistent life. In Question 20, Aquinas demonstrates that love exists in God not as a passion. However, as the act of His will willing good to another. God's love creates and infuses goodness in creatures. Therefore, God loves all existing things, and loves better things more simply because He wills them a greater good.
Question 19, Article 8 examines whether the will of God imposes necessity on the things willed. This proves that God wills contingent things to happen contingently. In Question 21, Aquinas shows that distributive justice (giving to each thing what is due to its nature and condition) and mercy (dispelling defect without sadness) belong to God. Furthermore, both justice and mercy are present in every divine work, with mercy as the first root. In Question 20, God loves a predestined sinner more as regards the eternal good He prepares for him. At the same time, he loves a righteous person more as regards present grace. Human love is caused by the goodness it finds in things. By contrast, the love of God infuses and creates goodness in things, and every work of God's justice is founded upon the prior gift of His mercy.
The story inside
People often pit God's justice and God's mercy against each other, as if God acts justly only when He punishes and mercifully only when He waives justice. In Question 21, Article 4, Aquinas dismantles this false opposition. He does this by asking what makes anything 'due' to a creature in the first place. A work of divine justice always presupposes a work of mercy and is founded upon it. For nothing is due to a creature except on account of something that already exists in it: for instance, hands are due to a human being. This is because he has a rational soul. A rational soul is due if he is to be a man. Yet that there should be a man at all is due to nothing prior,Proceeding purely from God's unmerited goodness! Even when God rewards the just with eternal glory in strict fidelity to His promise, or pardons a repentant sinner, or punishes the wicked less than they deserve, the initial gift of nature, grace, and promise springs entirely from mercy. God's justice never contradicts His mercy; rather, every claim a creature has on God's fidelity flows first from the free gift of His merciful love.
Lessons worth keeping
- 1
A thing is more perfectly alive the more its operation originates from within itself. Therefore, God (who is swayed by no external agent and whose intellect is His essence) possesses life in the supreme degree.
- 2
God wills His own goodness necessarily, just as the human will necessarily wills happiness. However, He wills created things freely without any compulsion or internal change.
- 3
God's will does not impose absolute necessity on all things willed. Rather, Because God's will is supremely efficacious, it causes both the outcome and the mode (necessary or free) by which the outcome happens.
- 4
Human love is caused by the goodness it finds in things. By contrast, the love of God infuses and creates goodness in things, and every work of God's justice is founded upon the prior gift of His mercy.
Test your recall
How does God's love for creatures differ fundamentally from our human love?
Answer from memory first. Then check the summary and lessons above.
Notes & sources
3 notesFrom Summa Theologica, First Part, Questions 1–26: Treatise on Sacred Doctrine and the One God, trans. Fathers of the English Dominican Province (1920). Line numbers show where each passage appears in the digitized text.
- 1.Lines 13753–13757
“Since to understand belongs to living beings, after considering the divine knowledge and intellect, we must consider the divine life. About this, four points of inquiry arise: (i) To whom does it belong to live? (2) What is life? (3) Whether life is properly attributed to God?”
- 2.Lines 14592–14594
“Therefore He acts by His essence; and that is His nature. He acts then by nature, and not by will. Therefore the divine will is not the cause of things.”
- 3.Lines 15494–15496
“Obj. 2t. Further, love, anger, sorrow, and the like, are mutually divided against one another. But sorrow and anger are not attributed to God, unless by metaphor.”
