Section XXV · Location 25 of 80
Section 25 · Open to readFrom Summa Theologica by Saint Thomas Aquinas
Edition: Summa Theologica, First Part of the Second Part, Questions 90–114: Treatise on Law and Grace, trans. Fathers of the English Dominican Province (1915)
First Part of the Second Part — The Old Law and Its Moral, Ceremonial, and Judicial Precepts (Questions 98–105)
Summa Theologica · Chapter 25 summary
The Old Law was good and given by God at the fitting time when natural law had been darkened by exuberant idolatry. As a result, the proud might learn their helplessness and seek the grace of the Redeemer. All the moral precepts of the Old Law are reduced to the Ten Commandments of the Decalogue (derived immediately from the twofold precept of love of God and neighbor) from which Not even God can dispense. This is because they contain the very intention of the Lawgiver.
Atlas of Saints wrote this summary of section 25 of Summa Theologica by Saint Thomas Aquinas. It uses our own words. It is not a quotation from the book.
Cite this summary
Atlas of Saints. “First Part of the Second Part — The Old Law and Its Moral, Ceremonial, and Judicial Precepts (Questions 98–105)” Summary of Summa Theologica, by Saint Thomas Aquinas. https://www.atlasofsaints.com/writings/summa-theologica/chapters/25#atlas-answer
Section breakdown
In Questions 98–105, Aquinas presents one of the most comprehensive treatises in Christian theology on the Old Law given through Moses. Against Manichaeans who attributed the Old Testament to an evil god, he proves that the Old Law was good. In addition, he came from the one true God through the ministry of angels to prepare the people of Israel for Christ. Even so, it could not confer justifying grace by its own power (Question 98). He divides all the precepts of the Old Law into three species under one law (Question 99): Moral Precepts, which dictate the natural law of virtue and are summarized in the Ten Commandments of the Decalogue (Question 100). Ceremonial Precepts, which determined divine worship—sacrifices, sacred things, sacraments, and observances—both to turn Israel away from Egyptian idolatry and to prefigure Christ (Questions 101–103). Moreover, Judicial Precepts, which ordered justice among the people of Israel in their mixed constitution of monarchy, aristocracy, and democracy, property law, warfare, and courts (Questions 104–105).
In Questions 98–100, Thomas Aquinas proves that the Old Law was given by the good God through angels to the people of Israel from whom Christ would be born. In addition, he separates its moral, ceremonial, and judicial precepts. Moreover, he demonstrates that the Ten Commandments of the Decalogue are entirely indispensable. Question 99 distinguishes moral, ceremonial, and judicial precepts as the three parts of the Old Law. In Questions 101–103, Aquinas examines the ceremonial precepts of the Old Law (sacrifices, sacred vessels and tabernacle, consecrations, and dietary/clothing observances), demonstrating both their literal anti-idolatry reasons and their figurative Christological fulfillment, and concluding that after the promulgation of the Gospel the legal ceremonies have ceased and cannot be practiced without sinning against faith in Christ's accomplished coming.
In Question 102, the architecture of the Tabernacle and Temple and the details of Mosaic worship were wisely designed to exclude the idolatrous rites of the surrounding nations. In Questions 104–105, Aquinas analyzes the judicial precepts of the Old Law concerning rulers, property, alien nations, and family life. In doing so, he defends the mixed political constitution of Moses and Joshua (combining monarchy, aristocracy, and democracy). In addition, he shows why these civil laws were annulled by Christ's coming though their underlying principles of equity remain informative. Question 105, Article 1 analyzes the political constitution of Israel and defends the mixed regime of monarchy, aristocracy, and democracy. In ordering the rulers of Israel (Question 105, Article 1), the Old Law established the best form of polity—a mixed constitution combining one chief ruler (monarchy), elders chosen from all for their virtue (aristocracy), and popular election by and from all the people (democracy).
The story inside
In Question 105, Article 1, while examining whether the Old Law rightly ordered the governance of rulers in Israel, Aquinas sets forth his classic political philosophy of the 'mixed constitution.' Two things, he notes, must be observed in any sound establishment of rulers: first. Moreover, all citizens should have some share in the government. This is because this preserves peace among the people and makes everyone love and guard the constitution. Moreover, second, that the form of government should combine the strengths of the best regimes. Taken in isolation, monarchy easily degenerates into tyranny when one king seeks private gain. Aristocracy easily turns into oligarchic faction. Therefore, the best constitution of a city or kingdom is a mixed regime: one person presides over all according to virtue (monarchy). Under him, a number of upright magistrates govern according to virtue (aristocracy). Moreover, yet this government belongs to all the people (democracy), both because those magistrates can be chosen from any of the people. Moreover, this is because they are elected by all the people! This was the very polity God instituted under Moses and his seventy-two elders chosen from the tribes of Israel. A just political community unites unified leadership with virtuous counsel and broad civic participation. As a result, power serves the common good rather than tyranny.
Lessons worth keeping
- 1
The Old Law was good and given by God at the fitting time when natural law had been darkened by exuberant idolatry. As a result, the proud might learn their helplessness and seek the grace of the Redeemer.
- 2
All the moral precepts of the Old Law are reduced to the Ten Commandments of the Decalogue (derived immediately from the twofold precept of love of God and neighbor) from which Not even God can dispense. This is because they contain the very intention of the Lawgiver.
- 3
Every ceremonial precept of the Mosaic Law had both a literal rationale (combating pagan idolatry and honoring God) and a figurative, prophetic rationale prefiguring the mysteries of Christ and His Church. Hence since Christ's Passion they are fulfilled and can no longer be observed without mortal sin.
- 4
In ordering the rulers of Israel (Question 105, Article 1), the Old Law established the best form of polity—a mixed constitution combining one chief ruler (monarchy), elders chosen from all for their virtue (aristocracy), and popular election by and from all the people (democracy).
Test your recall
Why can no one—not even God—dispense from the Ten Commandments of the Decalogue, even though God commanded Abraham to sacrifice Isaac and the Israelites to take Egyptian vessels?
Answer from memory first. Then check the summary and lessons above.
Notes & sources
3 notesFrom Summa Theologica, First Part of the Second Part, Questions 90–114: Treatise on Law and Grace, trans. Fathers of the English Dominican Province (1915). Line numbers show where each passage appears in the digitized text.
- 1.Lines 4006–4008
“But the Old Law was not salutary; rather was it deadly and hurtful. For the Apostle says (Rom. vii. 8, seq.): Without the law sin was dead. And I lived some time without the law.”
- 2.Lines 6637–6638
“Ohj. 2. Further, the moral precepts are distinct from the judicial and ceremonial precepts, as stated above (Q. XCIX.”
- 3.Lines 8915–8918
“And all these things had reasonable causes, both literal, in so far as they were ordained to the worship of God for the time being, and figurative, in so far as they were ordained to foreshadow Christ: as we shall see by taking them one by one.”
