Skip to content
Atlas of Saints

Summa Theologica Moralis, partibus IV distincta

Section 3 · Saint Antoninus of Florence

Section III · Location 3 of 4

Section 3 · Open to read

From Summa Theologica Moralis, partibus IV distincta by Saint Antoninus of Florence

Edition: St. Antonino and Mediaeval Economics (with Excerpts from the Summa Theologica Moralis), trans. Bede Jarrett, O.P. (1914)

Chapter VII: Social and Economic Ideals in the Summa Moralis — Wealth, Private Property, Just Price, Usury, Capital, and Wages

Summa Theologica Moralis, partibus IV distincta · Chapter 3 summary

In Chapter VII ('His Social Ideals'), Bede Jarrett sets forth Antoninus's teaching on production, usury versus productive capital (ut vero capitali), social value (usefulness, rarity, pleasurableness) (prompt wages and tending sick workmen) (and fair taxation).

Atlas of Saints wrote this summary of section 3 of Summa Theologica Moralis, partibus IV distincta by Saint Antoninus of Florence. It uses our own words. It is not a quotation from the book.

Cite this summary

Atlas of Saints. “Chapter VII: Social and Economic Ideals in the Summa Moralis — Wealth, Private Property, Just Price, Usury, Capital, and Wages” Summary of Summa Theologica Moralis, partibus IV distincta, by Saint Antoninus of Florence. https://www.atlasofsaints.com/writings/summa-theologica-moralis/chapters/3#atlas-answer

Section breakdown

Organizing Antoninus's economic doctrine into Production, Distribution, and Consumption (Bede Jarrett shows that commercial value arises from human labor of head or hand). Condemning shoddy building, adulterated goods, and monopolistic price rings (Antoninus upholds the traditional prohibition of usury on a simple loan of barren money) (including 'deposits' through which idle nobles seek annual interest without risk). At the same time, he recognizes that a lender foregoing lawful trade gain (may claim compensation and that money earmarked for commerce takes on the true character of productive capital)(ut vero capitali).

Examining the just price, Antoninus distinguishes natural value in the scale of being (valor naturalis, where a living mouse ranks higher than dead wheat) from social use-value (valor usualis) (which depends on three factors: usefulness), rarity, and pleasurableness. Because human estimates vary by time and place (a prudent appraiser allows a fair margin from half a florin to one-and-a-half florins around a one-florin valuation rather than a rigid mathematical point).

Turning to Distribution and Consumption (Antoninus insists that every worker must receive a prompt just wage proportioned to his skill), danger, and number of children (and urges employers to care for and tend their sick workmen rather than hurrying to send them away to a hospital). Citizens who falsify their catasto tax returns and rulers who impose taxes out (of class spite are equally bound to make restitution). Meanwhile, almsgiving from superfluous wealth must follow family duties and debts of justice.

The story inside

In his Summa Moralis, Archbishop Antoninus examined the daily relationship between Florentine masters and the workmen in their shops. Every laborer had a strict right to a prompt wage proportioned not only (to his skill and the danger of his trade). Yet also to the number of children in his household. What if a workman fell ill? Instead of casting the sick man aside at the first sign of fever (a Christian master should care for and tend his sick workmen rather than hurry to send them away into a hospital).

Lessons worth keeping

  1. 1

    While condemning simple loan interest and disguised usurious 'deposits,' Antoninus recognizes that money devoted (to commerce acts as productive capital)(ut vero capitali).

  2. 2

    In society, the just price (valor usualis) depends on usefulness, rarity, and pleasurableness within a prudent range around the appraised value.

  3. 3

    Employers owe workmen a prompt family wage and should care for their sick employees. Meanwhile, tax fraud and partisan taxation bind to restitution.

Test your recall

What three factors determine social value (valor usualis) for Antoninus, and how should a Christian employer treat his workmen when they fall sick?

Answer from memory first. Then check the summary and lessons above.

Notes & sources

3 notes

From St. Antonino and Mediaeval Economics (with Excerpts from the Summa Theologica Moralis), trans. Bede Jarrett, O.P. (1914). Line numbers show where each passage appears in the digitized text.

  1. 1.
    Lines 2592–2594
    “It is inevitable indeed that he should have been enormously influenced by the theories of Aristotle, who in those ages was regarded in the phrase of”
  2. 2.
    Lines 2908–2910
    “The same holds good, even if he be not a merchant but have only the intention of investing his funds in lawful trade ; but not if he be a man who hoards”
  3. 3.
    Lines 3156–3157
    “But it does not follow from this that the present state of society is such as God would have it to be.”

Location: section 3 of 4 · 75%

Display settings