Section II · Location 2 of 3
Section 2 · Open to readFrom De reductione Artium ad Theologiam by Saint Bonaventure
Edition: The Catholic Encyclopedia, Volume II: Assize–Brownson (1907)
Section 2 — The Autonomy of Philosophy, Exemplarism, and Divine Illumination
De reductione Artium ad Theologiam · Chapter 2 summary
Bonaventure affirms that philosophy is a true and distinct science prior in time to theology. Yet he requires divine exemplarism and the illumination of the Eternal Word to reach infallible certitude.
Atlas of Saints wrote this summary of section 2 of De reductione Artium ad Theologiam by Saint Bonaventure. It uses our own words. It is not a quotation from the book.
Cite this summary
Atlas of Saints. “Section 2 — The Autonomy of Philosophy, Exemplarism, and Divine Illumination” Summary of De reductione Artium ad Theologiam, by Saint Bonaventure. https://www.atlasofsaints.com/writings/de-reductione-artium-ad-theologiam-bonaventure/chapters/2#atlas-answer
Section breakdown
De Reductione Artium ad Theologiam orders all human sciences toward sacred theology. Therefore, some readers have mistakenly supposed that Bonaventure denied philosophy any independent existence. On the contrary, considered in itself (philosophy is a true and distinct science that comes before theology in the order of time). Bonaventure's critique means only that natural reason is not the final or supreme end of human inquiry. When compared with revealed theology, philosophy occupies a subordinate rank that prepares the mind for higher truth.
In steering between the older Augustinian tradition and the newly recovered works of Aristotle (Bonaventure remained a faithful disciple of Saint Augustine). At the same time, he quoted Aristotle more frequently than any earlier Scholastic had done. Following Augustine, he placed the doctrine of Exemplarism at the center of metaphysics. All finite creatures are imitations of the eternal ideas (rationes aeternae) in the Divine Mind. Consequently, to attain infallible certitude in intellectual knowledge, the human mind needs not only abstraction from sense experience. Yet also a special regulating illumination from the Eternal Truth.
The story inside
At the University of Paris in the mid-thirteenth century (masters debated fiercely whether Aristotle's natural philosophy should replace the older patristic tradition of Saint Augustine). Rather than rejecting Aristotle's logic and natural science, Bonaventure mastered and quoted the Greek philosopher extensively. At the same time (he insisted that Aristotle's rejection of divine exemplarism left human reason incomplete without Augustine's doctrine of the Eternal Word as the archetype of all truth).
Lessons worth keeping
- 1
Recognizing philosophy as a true science in its own right is fully compatible (with ordering reason toward the higher light of divine revelation).
- 2
Every created truth is a reflection of the eternal ideas in the Mind of God (who illumines the human intellect to know truth with certitude).
Test your recall
How does Saint Bonaventure view the status of philosophy in itself versus its relation to theology, and what role do the rationes aeternae play in human knowledge?
Answer from memory first. Then check the summary and lessons above.
Notes & sources
1 noteFrom The Catholic Encyclopedia, Volume II: Assize–Brownson (1907). Line numbers show where each passage appears in the digitized text.
- 1.Lines 106894–107203
“Bonaventure, as Hefele remarks, united in himself the two elements whence proceed whatever was noble and sublime, great and beautiful, in the Middle Ages, viz., tender piety and profound learning. These two qualities shine forth conspicuously in his writings. Bonaventure wrote on almost every subject treated by the Schoolmen, and his writings are very numerous. The greater number of them deal with philosopliy and theology. No work of Bonaventure's is exclusively philosophical, but in his "Commentary on the Sentences", his "Breviloquium", his "Itinerarium Mentis in Deum" and his "De reductione Artium ad Theologiam", he deals with the most important and difficult questions of philosophy in such a way that these four works taken together contain the elements of a complete system of philosophy, and at the same time bear striking witness to the mutual interpenetration of philosophy and theology which is a distinguishing mark of the Scholastic period. The "Commentary on the Sentences" remains without doubt Bonaventure's greatest work; all his other writings are in some way subservient to it. It was written, superiorum prceceplo (at the command of his superiors) when he was only twenty-seven and is a theological achievement of the first rank. It comprises more than four thousand pages in folio and treats extensively and profoundly of God and the Trinity, the Creation and Fall of Man, the Incarnation and Redemption, Grace, the Sacraments, and the Last Judgment, that is to say, traverses the entire field of Scholastic theology. Like the other medieval Smnmas, Bonaventiu-e's "Commentary" is divided into four books. In the first, second, and fourth Bonaventure can compete favourably with the best commentaries on the Sentences, but it is admitted that in the third book he surpasses all others. The "Breviloquium", written before 1257, is, as its name implies, a shorter work. It is to some extent a summary of the "Commentary" containing as Scheeben says, the quintessence of the theology of the time, and is the most sublime compendium of dogma in our possession. It is perhaps the work which will best give a popular notion of Bonaventure's theology; in it his powers are seen at their best. Whilst the "Breviloquium" derives all things from God, the "Itinerarium Mentis in Deum " proceeds in the opposite direction, bringing all things back to their Supreme End. The latter work, which formed the delight of Gerson for more than thirty years, and from which Bl. Henry Suso drew so largely, was wTitten on Mount la Verna in 1259. The relation of the finite and infinite, the natural and supernatural, is again dealt with by Bonaventure, in his "De reductione Artium ad Theologiam", a little work written to demonstrate the relation which philosophy and the arts bear to theology, and to prove that they are all absorbed in it as into a natural centre. It must not be inferred, however, that philosophy in Bonaventure's view does not possess an existence of its own. The passages in Bonaventure's works on which such an opinion might De founded only go to prove that he did not regard philosophy as the chief or last end of scientific research and speculation. Moreover, it is only when compared with theology that he considers philosophy of an inferior order. Oansidered in itself, philosophy is, according to Bonaventure, a true science, prior in point of time to theology. Again, Bonaventure's pre-eminence as a mystic must not be suffered to overshadow his labours in the domain of philosophy, for he was undoubtedly one of the greatest philosophers of the Middle Ages. Bonaventure's philosophy, no less than his theology, manifests his profound respect for tradition. He regarded new opinions with disfavour and ever strove to follow those generally received in his time. Thus, between the two great influences which determined the trend of Scholasticism about the middle of the thirteenth century, there can be no doubt that Bonaventure ever remained a faithful disciple of Augustine and always defended the teaching of that Doctor; yet he by no means repudiated the teaching of Aristotle. While basing his doctrine on that of the old school, Bonaventure borrowed not a little from the new. Though he severely criticized the defects of Aristotle, he is said to have quoted more frequently from the latter than any former Scholastic had done. Perhaps he inclined more, on the whole, to some general views of Plato than to those of Aristotle, but he cannot therefore be called a Platonist. Although he adopted the hylomorphic theory of matter and form, Bonaventure, following Alexander of Hales, whose Summa he appears to have had before him in composing his own works, does not limit matter to corporeal lx;ings, but holds that one and the same kind of matter is the substratum of spiritual and corporeal beings alike. According to Bonaventure, materia prima is not a mere indeterniimxtum quid, but contains the raliones seminale.s infused by the Creator at the beginning, and tends towards the acquisition of those special forms which it ultimately assumes. The substantial form is not in Bonaventure's opinion, essentially, one, as St. Thomas taught. Another point in which Bonaventure, as representing the Franciscan school, is at variance with St. Thomas is that which concerns the possibility of creation from eternity. He declares that reason can demonstrate that the world was not created ab ceterno. In his system of ideology Bonaventure does not favour either the doctrine of Plato or that of the Ontologists. It is only by completely misunderstanding Bonaventure's teaching that any ontologistic interpretation can be read into it. For he is most emphatic in rejecting any direct or immediate vision of God or of His Divine attributes in this life. For the rest, the psychology of Bonaventure differs in no essential point from the common teaching of the Schoolmen. The same is true, as a whole, of his theology. Bonaventure's theological writings may be classed under four heads: dogmatic, mystic, exegetical, and homiletic. His dogmatic teaching is found chiefly in his "Commentary on the Sentences" and in his "Breviloquium". Treating of the Incarnation, Bonaventure does not differ substantially from St. Thomas. In answer to the question: "Would the Incarnation have taken place if Adam had not sinned?", he answers in the negative. Again, notwithstanding his deep devotion to the Blessed Virgin, he favours the opinion which does not exempt her from original sin, quia magis consonat fidei pietati el sandnrum auctoritati. But Bonaventure's treatment of this question marked a distinct advance, and he did more perhaps than anyone before Scotus to clear the ground for its correct presentation. His treatise on the sacraments is largely practical and is characterized by a distinctly devotional element. This appears especially in his treatment of tlie Holy Eucharist. He rejects the doctrine of pliysical, and admits only a moral, efficacy in the sacraments. It is much to be regretted that Bonaventure's views on this and other controverted questions should be so often misrepresented, even by recent wxiters. For example, at least three of the latest and best known manuals of dogma in treating of such questions as "De angelorum natura", "De scientia Cliristi", "De natura distinctionis inter caritatem et gratiam sanctifioantem", "De causalitate sacramentorum", and "De statu parvulorum sine baptismo morientiimi", gratuitously attribute opinions to Bonaventure which are entirely at variance with his real teaching. To be siu'e Bonaventure, like all the Scholastics, occasionally put forward opinions not strictly correct in regard to questions not yet defined or clearly settled, but even here his teaching represents the most profound and acceptable ideas of his age and marks a notable stage in the evolution of knowledge. Bonaventure's authority has always been very great in the Church. Apart from his personal influence at Lyons (1274). his WTitings carried great weight at the subsequent councils at Vienne (1311), Constance (1417), Basle (1431), and Florence (1438). At Trent (1546) his \iTitings, as NewTiian remarks (Apologia, ch. v) had a critical effect on some of the definitions of dogma, and at the Vatican Council (1870), sentences from them were embodied in the decrees concerning papal supremacy and infallibility. Only a small part of Bonaventure's WTitings is properly mystical. These are characterized by brevity and by a faithful adiierence to the teaching of the Gospel. The perfecting of the soul by the uprooting of vice and the implanting of virtue is his chief concern. There is a degree of prayer in which ecstasy occiu-s. AVhen it is attained, God is sincerely to be thanked. It must, however, he regarded only as incidental. It is by no means essential to the possession of perfection in the highest degree. Such is the general outline of Bonaventure's mysticism which is largely a continuation and development of what the St. Victors had already laid do«Ti. The shortest and most complete summary of it is found in his "De Triplici Via", often erroneously entitled the "Incendium Amoris", in which he distinguishes the different stages or degrees of perfect charity. What the " Breviloquium " is to Scholasticism, the "De Triplici Via" is to mysticism — a perfect compendium of all that is best in it. Savonarola made a pious and learned commentary upon it. Perhaps the best known of Bonaventure's other mystical and ascetical WTitingsare the "Soliloquium", a sort of dialogue containing a rich collection of passages from the Fathers on spiritual questions; the "Lignum vitae", a series of forty-eight devout meditations on the life of Christ, the "De sex alls seraphim.", a precious opuscule on the \nrtues of superiors, which Father Claudius Acqua\'iva caused to be printed separately and circulated throughout the Society of Jesus; the "Vitis mystica", a work on the Passion, which was for a long time erroneously ascrib)ed to St. Bernard, and "De Perfectione vitce", a treatise which depicts the virtues that make for religious perfection, and which appears to have been written for the use of Blessed Isabella of France, who had founded a monasterj- of Poor Clares at Longchamps. Bonaventure's exegetical works were highly esteemed in the Middle Ages and still remain a treasure house of thoughts and treatises. They include commentaries on the Books of Ecclesiastes and Wisdom and on the Gospels of St. Luke and St. John. In addition to his commentarj' on the Fourth Gospel, Bonaventure composed "Collationes in Joannem", ninety-one conferences on subjects relating to it. His "Collationes in He.xameron" is a work of the same kind, but its title, which did not originate with Bonaventure, is somewhat misleading. It consists of an unfinished course of instructions delivered at Paris in 1273. Bonaventure did not intend in these twenty-one discourses to e.xplain the work of the six days, but rather to draw some analogous instructions from the first chapter of Genesis, as a warning to his auditors against some errors of the day. It is an exaggeration to say that Bonaventure had regard only to the mystical sense of Scripture. In such of his wTitings as are properly exegetical he follows the text, though he also develops the practical conclusions deduced from it, for in the composition of these works he had the advantage of the preacher mainly in view. Bonaventure had conceived the most sublime idea of the ministry of preaching, and notwithstanding his manifold labours in other fields, this ministry ever held an especial place among his labours. He neglected no opportunity of preaching, whether to the clergy, the people, or his own Friars, and Bl. Francis of Fabriano (d. 1322), his contemporary and auditor, bears witness that Bonaventure's renown as a preacher almost surpassed his fame as a teacher. He preached before popes and kings, in Spain and Germany, as well as in France and Italy. Nearly five hundred authentic sermons of Bonaventure have come do\^'n to us; the greater part of them were delivered in Paris before the university while Bonaventure was professor there, or after he had become minister general. Most of them were taken down by some of his auditors and thus preserved to posterit}-. In his sermons he follows the Scholastic method of putting forth the divisions of his subject and then expounding each division according to the different senses. Besides his philosophical and theological writings, Bonaventure left a number of works referring to the religious life, but more especially to the Franciscan Order. Among the latter is his well-known ex)>lanation of the Rule of the Friars Minor; in this work, WTitten at a time when the dissensions ivithin the order as to the observance of the Rule were so painfully marked, he adopted a conciliatory attitude, approving neither the interpretation of the Zelanti nor that of the Rclaxti. His aim was to promote harmony in essentials. With this end in view, he had chosen a middle course at the outset and firmly adhered to it during the seventeen years of his generalship. If anyone could have succeeded in uniting the order, it would have been Bonaventure; but the rm media proved impracticable, and Bonaventure's personality only served to hold in check the elements of discord, subsequently represented by the Conventuals and the Fraticelli. Following upon his explanation of the Rule comes Bonaventure's important treatise emlx)ciying the Constitutions of Narbonne already referred to. There is also an answer by Bonaventure to some questions concerning the Rule, a treatise on the guidance of no\'ices, and an opuscule in which Bonaventure states why the Friars Minor preach and hear confessions, besides a number of letters which give us a special insight into the saint's character. These include official letters wTitten by Bonaventure as general to the superiors of the order, as well as personal letters addressed like that "Ad innominatum magistrum" to private individuals. Bonaventure's beautiful "Legend" or life of St. Francis completes the WTitings in which he strove to promote the spiritual welfare of his brethren. This well-known work is composed of two parts of very unequal value. In the first Bonaventure publishes the unedited facts that he had been able to gather at Assisi and elsewhere; in the other he merely abridges and repeats what others, and especially Celano, had already recorded. As a whole, it is essentially a Icgenda pocis, compiled mainly with a view to pacifying the unhappy discord still ravaging the order. St. Bonaventure's aim was to present a general portrait of the holy founder which, by the omission of certain points that had given rise to controversy, should be acceptable to all parties. This aim was surely legitimate even though from a critical standpoint the work may not be a perfect biography. Of tliis "Legenda Major", as it came to be called, Bonaventure made an abridgment arranged for use in choir and knorni as the "Legenda Minor".”
