Section I · Location 1 of 4
Section 1 · Open to readFrom Commentarius in Joannis Evangelium by Saint Cyril of Alexandria
Edition: Commentary on the Gospel According to S. John, Vol. I (Books I–V), trans. Philip Edward Pusey (1874)
Book I (Chapters I–X, John 1:1–28): The Eternal Generation and Consubstantiality of the Word, the True Light, and the Incarnation
Commentarius in Joannis Evangelium · Chapter 1 summary
Expounding John 1:1–28 against Eunomian and Arian objections in Book I (Chapters I–X) (Cyril of Alexandria proves that the Word is eternal), co-essential with the Father (the Creator and Life of all things) (and made flesh without ceasing to be God).
Atlas of Saints wrote this summary of section 1 of Commentarius in Joannis Evangelium by Saint Cyril of Alexandria. It uses our own words. It is not a quotation from the book.
Cite this summary
Atlas of Saints. “Book I (Chapters I–X, John 1:1–28): The Eternal Generation and Consubstantiality of the Word, the True Light, and the Incarnation” Summary of Commentarius in Joannis Evangelium, by Saint Cyril of Alexandria. https://www.atlasofsaints.com/writings/commentarius-in-joannis-evangelium-cyril-of-alexandria/chapters/1#atlas-answer
Section breakdown
Opening his massive dogmatical commentary on the Fourth Gospel (Cyril compares John the Evangelist to a subtile husbandman who plows down to the deepest roots of Arian and Eunomian heresy). Whereas the Synoptic Evangelists trace Christ's human genealogy after the flesh (John soars above all created time: 'In the beginning was the Word), and the Word was with God (and the Word was God.' Because 'was' reaches back before every origin without limit) (the Only-Begotten never had a beginning of existence out of non-being). He is 'with God' as a distinct Hypostasis subsisting beside the Father (yet 'was God' as sharing the one undivided Divine Nature).
Refuting the Eunomian syllogism that because the Father is Unbegotten and the Son (is Begotten they must differ in substance)(Cyril demonstrates in Chapters II–V that 'Unbegotten' and 'Begotten' denote how the Father and Son subsist relatively), not what their essence is—just as Adam (unbegotten of man) and Seth (begotten of Adam) possess the exact same human nature. Because 'all things were made by Him' (John 1:3), the Word cannot be a creature (and the life that was in Him is the True Light that enlightens every rational mind coming into the world). By contrast, John the Baptist was only a witness to the Light.
Turning in Chapters VIII–X to the climax of the Prologue—'And the Word was made (flesh, and dwelt among us')(John 1:14)—Cyril explains that 'flesh' stands by synecdoche for a complete human being endowed with a rational soul. The Word was not changed into flesh by losing His deity (nor did He merely associate with a separate man). Rather, remaining what He eternally was (He took our fallen nature as His own temple to free it from corruption and make believers partakers of the divine nature through grace). Meanwhile (John the Baptist confessed before the priests and Levites at Bethany beyond Jordan that he was not the Christ), Elijah, or the Prophet. Yet the voice crying in the wilderness.
The story inside
When Arian disputants in Alexandria argued that if the Father is Unbegotten (and the Son is Begotten they cannot share the same essence)(Cyril answered them from nature and Scripture in Book I of his Commentary on John). Take a human father and son, or take fire and the radiance shining forth from fire. The radiance is generated from the fire and is never prior to or separate from it (yet both exist together in one unbroken light). Even so, the Word is generated impassibly from the Father's essence without cutting, flux, or time. As a result, whoever sees the Son sees the Father.
Lessons worth keeping
- 1
In John 1:1, 'was' proves the Word's eternal pre-existence, 'with God' proves His distinct Person (and 'was God' proves His consubstantiality with the Father).
- 2
Against Eunomius (Cyril shows that 'Unbegotten' and 'Begotten' distinguish the Persons of Father and Son without dividing their one divine substance).
- 3
In John 1:14, 'the Word was made flesh' means the immutable Word united a complete humanity (body and rational soul) to Himself without change or confusion.
Test your recall
How does Cyril interpret the three clauses of John 1:1, and how does he refute the Eunomian claim that 'Unbegotten' and 'Begotten' mean two different substances?
Answer from memory first. Then check the summary and lessons above.
Notes & sources
3 notesFrom Commentary on the Gospel According to S. John, Vol. I (Books I–V), trans. Philip Edward Pusey (1874). Line numbers show where each passage appears in the digitized text.
- 1.Lines 2895–2897
“Chapter 4. Against those who dare to say, that the conceived and natural Word in God the Father is one, and He that is called Son by the Divine Scriptures another (such is the misconceit of”
- 2.Lines 4812–4814
“learn, another teacher, the word invented by them, which they call conceived, let them tell us, if they think that their own opinion hereupon ought to prevail, whether they will say that”
- 3.Lines 6729–6731
“Ps. cxix. as. Before I 2vas afflicted I went astray, and moreover not ashamed of such foolish prating say, Lo the soul says that before its humiliation, that is, its embodiment, it transgressed”
