Section III · Location 3 of 3
Section 3 · Open to readFrom Commentaria in Quatuor Libros Sententiarum by Saint Bonaventure
Edition: Commentaria in Quatuor Libros Sententiarum Magistri Petri Lombardi (Opera Omnia, Tomus I), trans. Quaracchi Franciscans (PP. Collegii a S. Bonaventura) (1882)
Distinctiones XXVII–XLIV: Operating and Cooperating Grace, the Transmission of Original Sin, Actual Sin, and the Power of Sin
Commentaria in Quatuor Libros Sententiarum · Chapter 3 summary
In Distinctions XXVII–XLIV (Bonaventure refutes Pelagianism by showing that fallen free will requires prevenient and cooperating grace to prepare for justification), defines original sin as the privation of original justice with concupiscence. It also proves that the malice of sin never comes from God.
Atlas of Saints wrote this summary of section 3 of Commentaria in Quatuor Libros Sententiarum by Saint Bonaventure. It uses our own words. It is not a quotation from the book.
Cite this summary
Atlas of Saints. “Distinctiones XXVII–XLIV: Operating and Cooperating Grace, the Transmission of Original Sin, Actual Sin, and the Power of Sin” Summary of Commentaria in Quatuor Libros Sententiarum, by Saint Bonaventure. https://www.atlasofsaints.com/writings/commentaria-in-quatuor-libros-sententiarum-bonaventure/chapters/3#atlas-answer
Section breakdown
In Distinctions XXVII–XXIX (Bonaventure shows that operating and cooperating grace are one and the same habit of sanctifying grace viewed in two effects: operating when God alone heals and justifies the soul), and cooperating when the healed will acts meritoriously with God. Against Pelagius and the Semi-Pelagians (he proves that even in the state of innocent nature Adam needed sanctifying grace to merit heaven). After the Fall no adult can even prepare himself congruously for justification without God's prevenient gratuitous gift (gratia gratis data) awakening his heart.
In Distinctions XXX–XXXIII, Bonaventure investigates how original sin passes from Adam to all his descendants generated by natural concupiscence. Because the freshly created soul is infused into flesh infected through Adam'sseminal transmission (the soul contracts original sin—which consists formally in the privation of original justice owed to human nature and materially in disordered concupiscence). While Baptism washes away the guilt of original sin so that remaining concupiscence (is a penal struggle rather than a sin in the baptized)(infant children who die without Baptism suffer only the loss of the beatific vision (without the sensory fire of personal guilt)).
In Distinctions XXXIV–XLIV, concluding Book II, Bonaventure examines actual sin and its causes. Evil is no positive nature created by God. Yet the privation of due measure, species, and order in a created will. Every positive act and power underlying a sinful deed comes from God as First Cause (just as the motion of a limping leg comes from the soul's motive power while the limp itself comes solely from the crooked bone). Having traced the seven capital vices, sins against the Holy Spirit (and why legitimate obedience to earthly rulers never extends to anything contrary to God's law), Bonaventure closes with thanksgiving to the eternal King.
The story inside
How can God be the First Cause of every physical action in the universe (without being the author of human sin)? In Distinction XXXVII of Book II (Bonaventure illustrated the answer with the famous comparison of a man walking with a crooked leg). When a lame man walks down the street (the energy and motion of his step come entirely from the healthy vital power of his soul). By contrast, the limping deformity of the step comes solely from the crookedness of his bone. In the exact same way, whatever positive being and power exist in a human action come from God. Meanwhile, the moral deformity of sin comes exclusively from the defective choice of the creature's free will.
Lessons worth keeping
- 1
Against Pelagianism, fallen man cannot even prepare himself for justification without prevenient grace (nor merit eternal life without infused sanctifying grace).
- 2
Original sin is formally the privation of original justice and materially concupiscence, transmitted through natural generation from Adam.
- 3
Like a healthy soul moving a crooked leg, God is the cause of all positive being and action. Meanwhile, the moral defect of sin springs solely from created free will.
Test your recall
How does Bonaventure define the formal and material elements of original sin in Distinction XXX, and how does his analogy of the limping leg in Distinction XXXVII explain why God is not the author of sin?
Answer from memory first. Then check the summary and lessons above.
Notes & sources
3 notesFrom Commentaria in Quatuor Libros Sententiarum Magistri Petri Lombardi (Opera Omnia, Tomus I), trans. Quaracchi Franciscans (PP. Collegii a S. Bonaventura) (1882). Line numbers show where each passage appears in the digitized text.
- 1.Lines 100594–100595
“liberari ac praeparari, ut bonum velit, et per gratiam cooperantem et subsequentem adiuvarl, iie frustra velit;”
- 2.Lines 119139–119140
“edd. 3, 4 interserunt Matthaei 7. Glossa ; Vat. inter verbn jF^ eiectus interii<:il Glossa in Matthaco.”
- 3.Lines 137654–137656
“c. 3. seqq. (c. 6. seq.). — Paulo superius pro ad regimen codd. VY cc et ed. I habent nd regitivum, et mox pro speclat di- rigere in pluribus codd., ut I Iv T V W Y bb ee, legitur spectat”
