Section I · Location 1 of 3
Section 1 · Open to readFrom Commentaria in Quatuor Libros Sententiarum by Saint Bonaventure
Edition: Commentaria in Quatuor Libros Sententiarum Magistri Petri Lombardi (Opera Omnia, Tomus I), trans. Quaracchi Franciscans (PP. Collegii a S. Bonaventura) (1882)
Praelocutio, Prooemium, and Distinctiones I–XI: Creation From Nothing and the Aeviternity, Choice, Fall, and Ministry of the Angels
Commentaria in Quatuor Libros Sententiarum · Chapter 1 summary
Opening Book II of his Commentary on the Sentences with a tribute to his master Alexander of Hales (Bonaventure proves against the Aristotelians that creation from nothing in time is demonstrable (by reason and traces the creation)), fall (and ministry of the angels).
Atlas of Saints wrote this summary of section 1 of Commentaria in Quatuor Libros Sententiarum by Saint Bonaventure. It uses our own words. It is not a quotation from the book.
Cite this summary
Atlas of Saints. “Praelocutio, Prooemium, and Distinctiones I–XI: Creation From Nothing and the Aeviternity, Choice, Fall, and Ministry of the Angels” Summary of Commentaria in Quatuor Libros Sententiarum, by Saint Bonaventure. https://www.atlasofsaints.com/writings/commentaria-in-quatuor-libros-sententiarum-bonaventure/chapters/1#atlas-answer
Section breakdown
In his opening Praelocutio and Prooemium to Book II of the Sentences (Bonaventure declares that just as he adhered in Book I to the common doctrine of the masters and above all to his beloved Franciscan father and master Alexander of Hales) (so in Book II he will walk the safe royal road where human uprightness and divine wisdom meet). In Distinction I, examining creation as the production of all things from nothing by the one First Principle (he famously refutes the Aristotelian thesis of an eternal world). For a creature brought out of pure nothingness to have existed from all eternity (without a beginning is a contradiction in terms)(since an infinite series of past days could never be traversed to reach today).
Across Distinctions II–VI, Bonaventure investigates the nature, duration, and probation of the angels. Created simultaneously with the empyrean heaven and corporeal matter in the measure of aeviternity, (every angel possesses a metaphysical composition of spiritual matter and form)(universal hylomorphism) that distinguishes even the highest creature from the absolute simplicity of God. Endowed with free will and natural charity (Lucifer was dazzled by his own splendour and fell immediately after creation through proud ambition for autonomous beatitude) (dragging down a multitude of rebel spirits into the murky air while Michael and the faithful angels turned humbly to God and were confirmed in glory).
In Distinctions VII–XI, Bonaventure examines the state of the confirmed angels and the malice of the demons. While the obstinate demons cannot repent and can never force human free will (though they can stir bodily humors (fashion illusory aerial bodies), and suggest temptations)the blessed angels are ordered across nine choirs in three hierarchies according (to the gifts of nature and grace)(and every human being receives a guardian angel from birth to protect the soul (against demonic assault and guide it toward heaven)).
The story inside
When thirteenth-century Parisian masters debated whether Aristotle had proved that the material universe existed (from all eternity without a beginning)(young Brother Bonaventure took a bold) (clear stand in Distinction I of Book II of his Sentences commentary). To say that a creature is made 'out of nothing' and yet (has 'no beginning' is an open contradiction: if an infinite number of days had already elapsed before today)(today could never have arrived) (and every new day would add to an actual infinity). Reason itself therefore joins Genesis in proclaiming that God created the world at the beginning of time.
Lessons worth keeping
- 1
In Distinction I (Bonaventure argues that 'creation from nothing from all eternity' is self-contradictory because an actual infinite series of past days cannot be traversed).
- 2
Even pure angelic spirits are composed of spiritual matter and form (hylomorphism). This preserves God's unique metaphysical simplicity as Pure Act.
- 3
Ordered across nine choirs (the blessed angels illuminate one another and guard every human soul from birth against the temptations of the fallen spirits).
Test your recall
How does Bonaventure prove by reason in Distinction I that the world could not have been created from nothing from all eternity, and why does he hold that angels are composed of spiritual matter and form?
Answer from memory first. Then check the summary and lessons above.
Notes & sources
3 notesFrom Commentaria in Quatuor Libros Sententiarum Magistri Petri Lombardi (Opera Omnia, Tomus I), trans. Quaracchi Franciscans (PP. Collegii a S. Bonaventura) (1882). Line numbers show where each passage appears in the digitized text.
- 1.Lines 1436–1437
“est ad completioneni prinii Sententiarum, Patrum interveniente instanlia, oportet inchoare secundum.”
- 2.Lines 16091–16093
“informi materia, quaiu ipse prius de nihilo rondidit, cunctarum rerum, hoe est sensibilium et insensibi- lium, intellectualiuni et intellectu carentiuin, spe-”
- 3.Lines 30758–30760
“stiidiuni daemonum maxime circa talia est iiitentum — sicut magnus clericus, qui vellet alios paralogizare, sluderet in sopliismatibus — et ideo phanlastici”
