Decision case · Saint Augustine of Hippo
The 'Man Is a Noun' Trap
Context
After studying how words point to other words, your father Augustine warns against tricks that confuse a sign with reality. One old joke claims a fierce lion jumps out of your mouth whenever you speak the word 'lion'. Suddenly Augustine tests you. First you agree that we are human beings ('men', homines), and then he asks what part of speech 'man' (homo) is. Answering solely from grammar that 'man' is a noun lets him conclude that you are a noun. Yet denying it breaks the grammar rules you just proved.
Options
- Distinguish reason’s natural rule—turning the listener’s mind straight to the living person—from grammar’s rule examining the spoken word-sign.
- Answer purely from grammar that 'man' is a noun in every sense and accept whatever conclusion follows.
Choice
Adeodatus answered right away that he was not a noun. By the natural law of reason (lex rationis), a listener thinks of the real person meant. The mind turns to the word itself only when someone asks about the sign.
Consequence
Augustine praised Adeodatus’s sharp reply and confirmed that this law of reason guides all honest talk about realities and signs.
Evidence
- Verified: Directly supported by strong evidenceAdeodatus immediately told Augustine that he was not a noun, explaining that by the natural law of reason (lex rationis) implanted in our minds, a listener's attention moves straight to the reality signified unless the speaker asks specifically about the sign itself. Augustine praised Adeodatus's answer and confirmed that the law of reason governs all truthful discourse about things and signs.
