Catholic Saints · Carthage, Tunisia
- Canonized Saint
- d. 14 September 258 at Carthage
- 4 sources

Saint Cyprian of Carthage (d. 258)
Also known as Thascius Caecilius Cyprianus, Caecilius Cyprianus, qui et Thascius
Why is Saint Cyprian of Carthage remembered as a landmark figure among Bishops of Carthage?
Saint Cyprian of Carthage (Thascius Caecilius Cyprianus; martyred 14 September 258) was Bishop of Carthage and the first great Latin Christian writer. Guiding the African Church through the Decian persecution, the Novatianist schism, and the baptismal controversy, he became the first Bishop of Carthage to die a martyr.123
Life and remembrance
Traditional account
Saint Cyprian of Carthage (Thascius Caecilius Cyprianus) was a wealthy and cultivated Carthaginian rhetorician converted to Christianity around 246 by the aged presbyter Caecilianus. Soon after his baptism he gave a large part of his fortune to the poor, composed his apologetic epistle Ad Donatum and three books of Scripture Testimonia for Quirinus, and was raised from the priesthood to the See of Carthage between July 248 and April 249 despite the opposition of five presbyters led by Novatus. When the persecution of Decius broke out in January 250, pagan crowds in the circus demanded that Cyprian be thrown to the lions; warned by a vision, he governed his flock from a place of concealment through letters, funds, and deputies while confessors in prison—above all Lucian in the name of the martyr Paulus—issued wholesale libelli pacis to the lapsed (sacrificati and libellatici).1
Returning to Carthage after Easter 251, Cyprian presented his treatises De Lapsis and De Catholicae Ecclesiae Unitate to the spring council of African bishops, which excommunicated the schismatic deacon Felicissimus and required penance before the restoration of the fallen, though conceding communion to all the lapsed in 252 as a new persecution under Gallus approached. Simultaneously he supported Pope Saint Cornelius against the antipope Novatian (who had been backed by Novatus at Rome) and against the rival laxist bishop Fortunatus in Carthage. When a devastating plague struck Carthage in 252, Cyprian organized a relief corps and fund to nurse the sick and bury the dead, composing De Mortalitate, De Opere et Eleemosynis, and his fiery reply to the pagan magistrate in Ad Demetrianum.23
From 255 to 256 Cyprian and three Carthaginian councils (numbered ending in the September 256 council of eighty-seven bishops) maintained the custom introduced by Agrippinus of rebaptizing converts from heresy and schism, bringing him into sharp conflict with Pope Saint Stephen I, who upheld the traditional Roman teaching that baptism conferred in the name of Christ or the Trinity was valid and threatened excommunication before dying in August 257. Summoned on 30 August 257 before the proconsul Aspasius Paternus under Valerian's first edict, Cyprian confessed Christ and was banished to Curubis, where a vision foretold his martyrdom a year hence. Recalled by the new proconsul Galerius Maximus under Valerian's second edict of August 258, Cyprian was tried on 14 September 258 at the Villa of Sextus, refused to sacrifice, gifted his executioner twenty-five gold pieces, bandaged his own eyes with the help of the priest and deacon Julius, and was beheaded—becoming the first Bishop of Carthage to win the martyr's crown.23
Remember
- Thascius Caecilius Cyprianus was a wealthy Carthaginian rhetorician converted by the presbyter Caecilianus and consecrated Bishop of Carthage in 248 or 249.1
- During the Decian persecution (250–251) he directed his diocese from concealment and regulated the reconciliation of the lapsed against the laxist faction of Novatus and Felicissimus.1
- In 251 he composed De Lapsis and De Catholicae Ecclesiae Unitate and backed Pope Saint Cornelius against the rigorist antipope Novatian.2
- During the plague of 252 he organized city-wide relief for the sick and dying, writing De Mortalitate, De Opere et Eleemosynis, and Ad Demetrianum.3
- After contesting the validity of heretical baptism against Pope Saint Stephen I (255–256) and enduring exile at Curubis (257), he was beheaded at Carthage under Galerius Maximus on 14 September 258.23
Check yourself
To which coastal town was Saint Cyprian banished by the proconsul Aspasius Paternus on 30 August 257?
Writings and words
- De Catholicae Ecclesiae Unitate · Written by this author · 251
- De LapsisComing soon · Written by this author
- Ad Donatum · Written by this author · c. 246
- Testimonia ad Quirinum · Written by this author · c. 248–250
- De MortalitateComing soon · Written by this author
- Epistulae (Letters of Saint Cyprian)Coming soon · Written by this author
Virtues
Facts and sources
Each fact names its source. The label shows how sure we can be.
The Church status of Saint Cyprian of Carthage is Saint.
Verified: Directly supported by strong evidenceThe Catholic Encyclopedia, Volume IV: Cland–Diocesanvol. IV, pp. 583–589 (clean-text lines 97582–97583)
Thascius Caecilius Cyprianus was a Carthaginian rhetorician converted by the priest Caecilianus and consecrated Bishop of Carthage between July 248 and April 249.
Verified: Directly supported by strong evidenceThe Catholic Encyclopedia, Volume IV: Cland–Diocesanvol. IV, pp. 583–589 (clean-text lines 97582–97636)
After guiding the African Church through the Decian persecution, the Novatianist schism, the plague of 252, and the baptismal controversy with Pope Stephen I, Cyprian was exiled to Curubis in 257 and beheaded at Carthage on 14 September 258.
Verified: Directly supported by strong evidenceThe Catholic Encyclopedia, Volume IV: Cland–Diocesanvol. IV, pp. 583–589 (clean-text lines 97654–98340)
Cyprian's authentic writings include eighty-one letters in the Cyprianic collection and treatises including Ad Donatum, Testimonia, De Habitu Virginum, De Lapsis, De Catholicae Ecclesiae Unitate, De Dominica Oratione, De Mortalitate, De Opere et Eleemosynis, Ad Demetrianum, De Bono Patientiae, and De Zelo et Livore.
Verified: Directly supported by strong evidenceThe Catholic Encyclopedia, Volume IV: Cland–Diocesanvol. IV, pp. 583–589 (clean-text lines 98341–98381)
Primary bibliography cited for Pass 2: Hartel, C.S.E.L., III (1868–1871); Pearson, Annales Cyprianici (1682); Benson, Cyprian (1897); Monceaux, Hist. litt. de l'Afrique chrét., II (1902); Bardenhewer, II (1903); Watson, Studia Biblica, IV (1896); Bayard (1902); von Soden (1904); d'Alès (1907).
Verified: Directly supported by strong evidenceThe Catholic Encyclopedia, Volume IV: Cland–Diocesanvol. IV, pp. 583–589 (clean-text lines 98513–98643)
Sources
John Chapman, “Cyprian of Carthage (Tha.sciu.s C-ecilius Cypri- ANis), Saint,” The Catholic Encyclopedia (1908), vol. IV, pp. 583–589. About this source
Notes and sources
About the source edition · John Chapman, The Catholic Encyclopedia (1908), vol. IV, pp. 583–589
1. Thascius Caecilius Cyprianus, Carthaginian rhetorician converted by Caecilianus; wrote Ad Donatum, Testimonia, and De Habitu Virginum; consecrated Bishop of Carthage (248/249); governed from concealment during the Decian persecution (250) and regulated the libelli pacis of Lucian and the confessors.
1. Conversion, early treatises, election as Bishop, and Decian persecution (246–251)Lines 97582–97883
Original passage
“Cyprian of Carthage (Tha.sciu.s C-ecilius Cypri- ANis), Saint, bi.shop and martyr. Of the date of the saint's birlli and of his early life nothing is known. At the time of his conversion to Christianity he had, perhaps, pa.ssed middle life. He w.as famous as an orator and pleader, had considerable wealth, and held, no doubt, a great position in the metropolis of Africa. We learn from his deacon, St. Pontius, whose life of the saint is preserved, that liis mien was dignified without severity, and cheerful without effusiveness. Ilis gift of elo()uence is evident in his WTitings. He was not a thinker, a pliilosopher, a theologian, but eminently a man of the world and an administrator, of v.ast energies, and of forcible and striking character. His conversion was due to an aged priest named Caeciliamis, with whom he seems to have gone to live. (Aecilianus in dying commended to Cyprian the care of his wife and family. While yet a catechumen the saint decided to observe chastity, and he gave most of his revenues to the poor. He sold his property, including his gardens at Carthage. These were restored to him {Dei indulgentiA reslituti, says Pontius), being apparently bought back for him by his friends; but he would have sold them again, had not the persecution made this imprudent. His baptism probably took place c. 246, presumably on Easter eve, 18 April. Cyprian's first Christian vvTiting is "Ad Donatum", a monologue spoken to a friend, sitting under a vineclad pergola. He tells how, until the grace of God illuminated and strengthened the convert, it had seemed impossible to conquer vice; the decay of Roman society is pictured, the gladiatorial shows, the theatre, the unjust law-courts, the hollowness of political success; the only refuge is the temperate, studious, and prayerful life of the Christian. At the beginning should probably be placed the few words of Donatus to Cj'prian which are printed by Hartel as a spurious letter. The style of this pamphlet is affected and reminds us of the bombastic unintelligibUity of Pontius. It is not like TertuUian, brilliant, barbarous, uncouth, but it reflects the preciosity which Apuleius made fashionable in Africa. In his other works Cyprian addresses a Christian audience; his own fervour is allowed full play, his style becomes simpler, though forcible, and sometimes poetical, not to say flowery. Without being classical, it is correct for its date, and the cadences of the sentences are in strict rhythm in all his more careful writings. On the whole his beauty of style has rarely been equalled among the Latin Fathers, and never surpassed except by the matclilcss energy and wit of St. Jerome. Another work of his early days was the " Testimonia ad Quirinum", in two books. It consists of passages of Scripture arranged under headings to illustrate the passing away of the Old Law and its fulfilment in Christ. A third book, added later, contains texts dealing with Christian ethics. This work is of the greatest value for the history of the Old Latin version of the Bible. It gives ils an African text closely related to that of the Bobbio MS. known as k (Turin). Hartel's edition has taken the text from a MS. which exhibits a revised version, but what Cyjirian wrote can be fairly well restored from the Mi^. cited in Hartel's notes as L. Another Ixjok of excerpts on martyrdom is entitled "Ad Fortunatum"; its text cannot be judged in any printed edition. Cyprian was ci^rtainly only a recent convert when he became Bishop of Carthage c. 248 or the beginning of 249, but he pa.ssed through all the grades of the ministry. He had declined the charge, but was constrained by the people. A minority oppo.sed his election, including five priests, who remained his enemies; but he tells us that he was validly elected "after the Divine judgment, the vote of the people and the consent of the bishops". The Decian Persecutiox. — The prosperity of the Church during a peace of thirty-eight years had produced great disorders. Many even of the bishops were given up to worldlincss and gain, and we hear of worse scandals. In October, 249, Decius became emi)eror with the ambition of restoring the ancient virtue of Rome. In Jamiary, 250, he published an edict against Christians. Bishoiis were to be put to death, other persons to be punished and tortured till they recanted. On 20 January Pope Fabian was martyretl, and about the same time St. Cyjirian retired to a .safe place of hiding. His enemies continually reproached him with this. But to remain at Carthage was to court death, to cause greater danger to others, and to leave the Church without government; for to elect a new bishop would have been as impossible as it was at Rome. He made over much property to a confessor priest, Rogatian, for the needy. Some of the clergy lapsed, otliers fled; Cyprian suspended their pay, for their ministrations were needed and they were in less danger than the bishop. From his retreat he encouraged the confessors and wrote eloquent panegyrics on the martyrs. Fifteen soon died in prison and one in the mines. On the arrival of the proconsul in April the severity of the persecution increased. St. Mappalicus died gloriously on the 17th. Children were tortured, women dishonoured. Numidicus, who had encouraged many, saw his wife burnt alive, and was himself half burnt, then stoned and left for dead; his daughter found him yet living; he recovered and Cyprian made him a priest. Some, after being twice tortured, were dismissed or banished, often beggared. But there was another side to the picture. At Rome terrified Christians rushed to the temples to sacrifice. At Carthage the majority apostatized. Some would not sacrifice, but purchased libelH, or certificates, that they had done so. Some bought the exemption of their family at the price of their own sin. Of these Ubellatici there were several thousands in Carthage. Of the fallen some did not repent, others joined the heretics, but most of them clamoured for forgiveness and restoration. Some, who had sacrificed imder torture, returned to be tortured afresh. Castus and ^milius were burnt for recanting, others were exiled; but such cases were necessarily rare. A few began to perform canonical penance. The first to suffer at Rome had been a young Carthaginian, Celerinus. He recovered, and Cyprian made him a lector. His grandmother and two uncles had been martyrs, but his two sisters apostatized under fear of torture, and in their repentance gave themselves to the service of those in prison. Their brother was very urgent for their restoration. His letter from Rome to Lucian, a confessor at Carthage, is extant, with the reply of the latter. Lucian obtained from a martyr named Paul before his passion a commission to grant peace to any who asked for it, and he distributed these " indulgences " with a vague formula : " Let such a one with his family communicate". Tertullian speaks in 197 of the "custom" for those who were not at peace with the Chiu-ch to beg this peace from the martyrs. Much later, in his Montanist days (c. 220), he urges that the adulterers whom Pope Callistus was ready to forgive after due penance would now get restored by merely imploring the confessors and those in the mines. Correspondingly we find Lucian issuing pardons in the name of confessors who were still alive, a manifest abuse. The heroic Mappalicus had only interceded for his own sister and mother. It seemed now as if no penance was to be enforced upon the lapsed, and Cyprian wrote to remonstrate. Meanwhile official news had arrived fmm Rome of the death of Pope Fabian, together with *n unsigned and ungrammatical letter to the clergy of Carthage from some of the Roman clergy, implying blame to Cyprian for the desertion of his flock, and giving advice as to the treatment of the lapsed. Cyprian explained his conduct (Ep. xx), and sent to Rome copies of thirteen of the letters he had written from his hiding-place to Carthage. The five priests who opposed him were now admitting at once to commimion all who had recommendations from the confessors, and the confessors themselves issiied a general indulgence, in accordance witli which the bishops were to restore to communion all whom they had examined. This was an outrage on discipline, yet Cyprian was ready to give some value to the indulgences thus improperly granted, but all must be done in submission to the bishop. He proposed that Ubellatici should be re- stored, when in danger of death, by a priest or even by a deacon, but that the rest shotild await the cessation of persecution, when councils could be held at Rome! and at Carthage, and a conunon decision be agreed! j upon. Some regard must be had for the prerogative! J of the confessors, yet the lapsed must surely not be a placed in a better position than those who had stood I fast, and had been tortured, or beggared, or exiled. I The guilty were ttrrifietl by marvels that occurred. I A man was struck ilumi) on the very Capitol where he '] had denied Christ. Another went mad in the public | baths, and gnawed the tongue which had tasted the pagan victun. In Cyprian's own presence an infant who had been taken by its niu-se to partake at the heathen altar, and then to the Holy Sacrifice offered by the bishop, was as though in torture, and vomited the Sacred Species it had received in the holy chalice.- A lapsed woman of advanced age had fallen in a fit, on venturing to communicate unworthily. Another, on opening the receptacle in which, according to custom, she had taken home the Blessed Sacrament for private Communion, was deterred from sacrilegiously touching it by fire which came forth. Yet another found nought within her pyx save cinders. About September, Cyprian received promise of support from the Roman priests in t"'o letters wTitten by the famous Novatian in the name of his colleagues. In the beginning of 251 the persecution waned, owing to the successive appearance of two rival emperors. The confessors were released, and a council was convened at Carthage. By the perfidy of some priests Cyprian was unable to leave his retreat till after Easter (23 March). But he wrote a letter to his flock denouncing the most infamous of the five priests, Novatus, and his deacon Felicissimus (Ep. xliii). To the bishop's order to delay the reconciliation of the lapsed until the council, Felicissimus had replied by a manifesto, declaring that none should communicate with himself who accepted the large alms distributed by Cyprian's order. The subject of the letter is more fully developed in the treatise "De Ecclesite Catholicae Unitate" which Cyprian wrote about this time (Benson -nTongly thought it was WTitten against Novatian some weeli later). This Celebrated pamphlet was read by its author to the council which met in April, that he might get the support of the bishops against the schism started by Felicissimus and Novatus, who had a large following. The imity with which St. Cyprian deals is not so much the unity of the whole Church, the necessity of which he rather postulates, as the unity to be kept in each diocese by union with the bishop; the unity of the whole Church is maintained by the close union of the bishops who are "glued to one another", hence whosoever is not with his bishop is cut off from the unity of the Church and cannot be imited to Christ; the type^ of the bishop is St. Peter, the first bishop. Protestant controversialists have attributed to St. Cyprian the absurd argimient that Christ said to Peter what He really meant for all, in order to give a tyjie or pictiu-e: of unity. What St. Cyprian really says is simply this,! that Christ, using the metaphor of an edifice, founds His Church on a single foimdation which shall mani-i fest and ensure its unity. And as Peter is the foimda-i tion, binding the whole Church together, so in eacll diocese is the bishop. With this one argmnent Cyprian claims to cut at the root of all heresies am schisms. It has been a mistake to find anj- referenc( to Rome in this passage (De Fnit., 4). Church Unity. — About the time of the opening o the council (2.51), two letters arrived from Rome One of these, announcing the election of a pope, St Cornelius, was read by Cy|)rian to the assembly; thi other contained such violent and improbable accusal tions against the new pope that he thought it better t' pass it over. But two liisliops, Caldoiiius and For tunatus, were disi)atched to Rome for furtlier infoij mi (ion, and the whole council was to await their return— such was the importance of a papal election. Meantime another message arrived with the news that Novatian, the most eminent among the Roman cIiTgjf, had been made pope. Happily two African prelates, Pompeius and Stephanus, who had been present at the election of Cornelius, arrived also, and were able to testify that he had been validly set "in the place of Peter", when as yet there was no other claimant. It was thus possible to reply to the recrimination of Novatian's envoys, and a short letter was sent to Rome, explaining the discussion which had taken place in the council. Soon afterwards came the report of Caldonius and Fortunatus together with a letter from Cornelius, in which the latter complained somewhat of the delay in recognizing him. Cyprian wrote to Cornelius explaining his prudent conduct. He adtled a letter to the confessors who were the main support of the antipope, leaving it to Cornelius whether it should be delivered or no. He sent also copies of his two treatises, " De U nitate "and "De Lapsis" (this had been composed by him immediately after the other"), and he wishes the confessors to read these in order that they may understand what a fearful thing is schism. It is in this copy of the "De Unitate" that Cyprian appears most probably to have added in the margin all alternative version of the fourth chapter. The original passage, as found in most MSS. and as printed in Hartel's edition, rims thus: " If any will consider this, there is no need of a long treatise and of argimients. The Lord saith to Peter: 'I say unto thee that thou art Peter, and upon this rock I will buikl Mj- Church, and the gates of hell shall not prevail against it ; to thee I will give the keys of the kingdom of heaven, and what thou shalt have boimd on earth shall be boimd in heaven, and what thou shalt have loosed shall be loosed in heaven.' Upon one He builds His Church, and though to all His Apostles after His resurrection He gives an equal power and says: 'As My Father hath sent Me, even so send I you: Receive the Holy Ghost, who.sesoever sins you shall have remitted they shall be remitted unto them, and whose.soever sins you .shall have retained they shall be retained', yet that He might make imity manifest, He disposed the origin of that unity beginning from one. The other Apostles were indeed what Peter was, endowed with a like fellowship both of honour and of power, but the commencement proceeds”
2. Council of 251, De Lapsis and De Catholicae Ecclesiae Unitate (including the prima cathedra text in chap. iv), support for Pope Cornelius against Novatian and Fortunatus, Councils of 252–254, and the baptismal controversy with Pope Stephen I and Firmilian of Caesarea (255–256).
2. Council of 251, De Lapsis, De Unitate, Novatianist schism, and baptismal controversy (251–256)Lines 97884–98253
Original passage
“from one, that the Church may be shown to be one. This one Ch\iroh the Holy Ghost in the person of the Lord designates in the Canticle of Canticles, and says. One is My Dove, My perfect one, one is she to her Mother, one to her that bare her. He that holds not this unity of the Church, does he believe that he holds the Faith? He who strives against and resists the Church, is he confident that he is in the Church?" The substituted passage is as follows: "... boimd in heaven. T'pon one He builds His Church, and to the same He says after His resurrection, 'feed My sheep'. And though to all His Apostles He gave an equal power net did He set up one chair, and disposed the origin and nuinnrr of unity by his authority. The other Apostles were indeed what Peter was, but the primary is girrii to Peter, and the Church and the chair is shown to be one. And all are pastors, but the flock U shown to be one, which is fed by all the Apostles with one mind and heart. He who holds not this imity of the Church, does he think that he holds the faith? He who deserts the chair of Peter, upon whom the Church is founded, is he confident that he is in the Church?" These .alt<-rnative versions are given one after the other in the chief family of MSS. which contains them, while in simie other families tlie two hiivv. been partially or wholl}- combined into one. Tlie combine<I Version is the one which has been printed in many edi- tions, and has played a large part in controversy with Protestants. It is of course spm'ious in this conflated form, but the alternative form given above is not only found in eighth- and ninth-century MSS., but it is quoted by Bede, by Gregory the Great (in a letter written for his predecessor Pelagius II), and by St. Gelasius ; indeed, it was almost certainly known to St. Jerome and St. Optatus in the fourth century. The evidence of the MSS. would indicate an equally early date. Every expression and thought in the passage can be paralleled from St. Cj-prian's habitual language, and it seems to be now generally admitted that this alternative passage is an alteration made by the author himself when forwarding his work to the Roman confessors. The "one chair" is always in Cyprian the episcopal chair, but in Rome that chair was the chair of Peter, and Cyprian has been careful to emphasize this point, and to add a reference to the other great Petrine text, the Charge in John, x.xi. The assertion of the equality of the Apostles as Apostles remains, and the omissions are only for the sake of brevity. The old contention that it is a Roman forgery is at all events quite out of the question. Another passage is also altered in all the same MSS. which contain the "interpolation"; it is a paragraph in which the humble and pious conduct of the lapsed "on this hand" (hie) is contrasted in along succession of parallels with the pride and wickedness of the schismatics "on that hand" (illie), but in the delicate manner of the treatise the latter are only referred to in a general way. In the "interpolated" MSS. we find that the lapsed, whose cause had now been settled by the council, are "on that hand" (iltic), whereas the references to the schismatics — meaning the Roman confessors who were supporting Novatian, and to whom the book was being sent — are made as pointed as possible, being brought into the foregroimd by the repeated hie, "on this hand". Nov.\TiANiSM. — The saint's remonstrance had its effect, and the confessors rallied to Cornelius. But for two or three months the confusion throughout the Catholic Church had been terrible. No other event in these early times shows us so clearly the enormous importance of the papacy in East and West. St. Dionysius of .-Vlexandria joined his great influence to that of the Carthaginian primate, and he was very soon able to write that .\ntioch, Ca>sarea, and Jerusalem, Tyre and Laodicea, all Cilicia and Cappadocia, Syria and Arabia, Mesopotamia, Pontus, and Bithynia, had returned to union and that their bishops were all in concord (Eusebius, Hist. Eccl., VII, v). From this we gauge the area of disturbance. Cyprian says that Novatian "assumed the primacy" (Ep. Ixix, 8) and sent out his new apostles to very many cities; and where in all provinces and cities there were long established, orthodox bishops, tried in persecution, he dared to create new ones to supplant them, as though he could range through the whole world (Ep. Iv, 24). Such was the power assumed by a third-century antipope. Let it be remembered that in the first days of the schism no question of heresy was raised and that Novatian only enunciated his refusal of forgiveness to the lapsed after he had made himself pope. Cyprian's reasons for holding Cornelius to be the true bishop are fully detailed in Ep. Iv to a bishop, who had at first yielded to Cyprian's argtiments and had commissioned him to inform Cornelius that "he now communicated with him, that is with the Catholic Church", but had afterwards wavered. It is evidently implied that if he did not communicate with Cornelius he would be outside the Catholic Church. Writing to the pope, Cyprian apologizes for his delay in acknciwlcilging him; he had at lea.st urged all those who sailrd to Rome to make sure that they acknowledged and held the womb and root of the Catholic Church (Ep. xlviii, .3). By this is probably meant "the womb and root which is the Catholic Church", but Harnack and many Protestants, as well as many Catholics, find here a statement that the Roman Church is the womb and root. Cyprian continues that he had waited for a formal report from the bishops who had been sent to Rome, before committing all the bishops of Africa, Numidia, and Mauretania to a decision, in order that, when no doubt could remain, all his colleagues "might firmly approve and hold your communion, that is the imity and charity of the Catholic Church". It is certain that St. Cyprian held that one who was in communion with an antipope held not the root of the Catholic Church, was not nourished at her breast, drank not at her fountain. So little was the rigorism of Novatian the origin of his schism, that his chief partisan was no other than Novatus, who at Carthage had been reconciling all the lapsed indiscriminately without penance. He seems to have arrived at Rome j ust after the election of Cornelius, and his adhesion to the party of rigorism had the curious result of destroying the opposition to Cyprian at Carthage. It is true that Felicissimus fought manfully for a tune; he even procured five bishops, all excommunicated and deposed, who consecrated for the party a certain Fortunatus in opposition to St. Cyprian, in order not to be outdone by the Novatian party, who had already a rival bishop at Carthage. The faction even appealed to St. Cornelius, and Cyprian had to write to the pope a long account of the circumstances, ridiculing their presumption in " sailing to Rome, the priinatial Church {ecclcsia ■principalis), the Chair of Peter, whence the unity of the Episcopate had its origin, not recollecting that these are the Romans whose faith w.-is praised bySt.Paul (Rom., i, 8), to whom unfaith could have no access". But this embassy was naturally unsuccessful, and the party of Fortunatus and Felicissimus seems to have melted away. The Lap.sed. — With regard to the lapsed the council had decided that each case must be judged on its merits, and that Uhcllfitici should be restored after varying, but lengthy, terms of penance, whereas those who had actually sacrificed might after life-long penance receive Communion in the hour of death. But any one who put off sorrow and penance until the hour of sickness must be refused all Communion. The decision was a severe one. A recrudescence of persecution, annoimced, Cyprian tells us, by numerous visions, caused the assembling of another council in the summer of 252 (so Benson and Nelke, but Ritschl and Harnack prefer 2.53), in which it was decided to restore at once all those who were doing penance, in order that they might be fortified by the Holy Eucharist against trial. In this persecution of Callus and Volusianus, the Church of Rome was again tried, but this time Cyprian was able to congratulate the pope on the firmness shown; the whole Church of Rome, he says, had confessed unanimously, and once again its faith, praised by the Apostle, was celebrated throughout the whole world (Ep. Ix). About June 253, Cornelius was exiled to Centumcellae (Civitavecchia), and died there, being counted as a martyr by Cyprian and the rest of the Church. His successor Lucius was at once sent to the same place on his election, but soon was allowed to return, and Cyprian wrote to congratulate him. He died 5 March, 254, and was succeeded by Stephen, 12 May, 254. Rebaptism of Heretics. — TertuUian had characteristically argued long before, that heretics have not the same God, the same Christ with Catholics, therefore their baptism is null. The African Church had adopted this view in a council held vmder a [)red('cessor of Cyprian, Agrippinus, at Carthage. In the East it was also the custom of Cilicia, Cappadocia, and Galatia to rebaptize Montanists who returned to the Church. Cyiirian's opinion of baptism by heretics was strongly expressed: "Non abluuutur illic homines, sed potius sordidantur, nee purgantur delicta sed immo cumulantur. Non Deo nativitas ilia sed j diabolo filios generat" ("De Unit.", xi). A cer- j tain bishop, Magnus, wrote to ask if the baptism ' 1 of the Novatians was to be respected (Ep. Ixix). i j Cyprian's answer may be of the year 255; he denies \i that they are to be distinguished from any other \ heretics. Later we find a letter in the same sense, I probably of the spring of 255 (autumn, according to 1 d'.^les), from a council under Cyprian of thirty-one j bishops (Ep. Ixx), addressed to eighteen Numidian j bishops; this was apparently the beginning of the controversy. It appears that the bishops of Maure- ! tania did not in this follow the custom of Proconsular Africa and Numidia, and that Pope Stephen sent them a letter approving their adherence to Roman custom. Cyprian, being consulted by a Numidian bishop, Quintiis, sent him Ep. Ixx, and replied to his difficulties (Ep. Ixxi). The spring council at Carthage in the following year, 256, was more numerous than usual, and sLxty-one bishops signed the conciliar letter to the pope explaining their reasons for rebaptizing, and claiming that it was a question upon which bishops were free to differ. This was not Stephen's view, and he immediately issued a decree, couched evidently in very peremptory terms, that no "innovation" was to be made (this is taken by some moderns to mean " no new baptism"), but the Roman tradition of merely laying hands on converted heretics in sign of absolution must be everywhere observed, under pain of excommunication. The letter was evidently addressed to the African bishops, and contained some severe censures on Cyprian himself. Cyprian writes to Jubaianus that he is defending the one Church, the Church foimded on Peter — Why then is he called a prevaricator of the truth, a traitor to the truth? (Ep. Ixxiii, 11). To the same correspondent he sends Epp. lx,x, Ix.xi, Ixxii; he makes no laws for others, but retains his own liberty. He sends also a copy of his newly written treatise "De Bono Patientiie". To Pompeius, who had asked to see a copy of Stephen's rescript, he writes with great violence: "As you read it, you will note his error more and more clearly; in approving the baptism of all the heresies, he has heaped into his own breast the sins of all of them ; a fine tradition indeed ! What blindness of mind, what depravity!" — "ineptitude", "hard obstinacy", — such are the expressions which run from the pen of one who declared that opinion on the subject was free, and who in this very letter explains that a bishop must never be quarrelsome, but meek and teachable. In September, 256, a yet larger coimcil assembled at Carthage. All agreed with Cyprian ; Stephen was not mentioned ; and some writers have even supposed that the council met before Stephen's letter was received (so Ritschl, Grisar, Ernst, Bardenhewer). Cyprian did not wish the responsibility to be all his own. He declared that no one made himself a bishop of bishops, and that all must give their true opinion. The vote of each was therefore given in a short speech, and the minutes have come down to us in the Cyprianic correspondence under the title of "SententiiE Episcoporura ". But the messengers sent to Rome with this document were refused an audience and even denied all hospitality by the pope. The}' returned incontinently to Carthage, and Cyprian tried for support from the East. He wrote to the famous Bishop of C;B.sarea in Cappadocia, Firmilian, sending him the treatise "De Unitate" and the correspondence on the baptismal question. By the middle of November Firmilian 's reply had arrived, and it has come down to us in a translation made at the time in Africa. Its tone is, if possible, more violent than that of Cyprian. tSee Fir.\ui.i.\n.) After this wo Uni)\v no more of the controversy. Stephen ilieil on 27 .\ugu.':t, 257, and Wiis succeeded by Sixtus II. who certainly communicated with Cyprian, and is called by Pontius "a good and peaceloving bishop". I'robably when it was seen at Rome (hit the East was largely committed to the same \\ rung practice, the question was tacitly dropped. It >liouM be remembered that, though Stephen had deininiled unquestioning obedience, he had apparently, like I'yprian, considered the matter as a point of dis- I il'linc. St. Cyprian supports his view by a wrong inli'ience from the unity of the Church, and no one tliniight of the principle afterwards taught by St. Aiiuustine, that, since Christ is always the principal :iL;'-nt, the validity of the sacrament is independent of tlie imworthiness of the minister: Ipse est qui baptizat. Yet this is what is implied in Stephen's insisting upon nothing more than the correct form, "because baptism is given in the name of Christ", and "the effect is due to the majesty of the Name". The laying on of hands enjoined by Stephen is repeatedly said to be in pienitentiam, yet Cyprian goes on to argue that the gift of the Holy Ghost by the laying on of hands is not the new birth, but must be subsequent to it and implies it. This has led some modems into the notion that Stephen meant confirmation to be given (so Duchesne), or at least that he has been so misunderstood by Cyprian (d'Alcs). But the passage (Ep. Ixxiv, 7) need not mean this, and it is most improbable that confirmation was even thought of in this connexion. Cyprian seems to consider the laying on of hands in penance to be a giving of the Holy Ghost. In the East the custom of rebaptizing heretics had perhaps arisen from the fact that so many heretics disbelieved in the Holy Trinity, and po.ssibIy did not even use the right form and matter. For centuries the practice persisted, at least in the case of some of the heresies. But in the West to rebaptize was regarded as heretical, and Africa came into line soon after St. Cyprian. St. Augustine, St. Jerome, and St. Vincent of Lerins are full of praise for the firmness of Stephen as befitting his place. But Cyprian's unfortunate letters became the chief support of the Puritanism of the Donatists. St. Augustine in his "De Baptismo" goes through them one by one. He will not dwell on the violent words quce in Stephanum irritnlux effudit, and expresses his confidence that Cyprian's glorious martyrdom will have atoned for his excess. Appe.vls to Rome. — Ep. Ixviii was written to Stephen before the breach. Cyprian has heard twice from Faustinus, Bishop of Lyons, that Marcianus, Bishop of Aries, has joined the party of Novatian. The pope will certainly have been already informed of this by Faustinus and by the other bishops of the province. Cyprian urges: " You ought to send very full letters to our fellow-bishops in Gaul, not to allow the obstinate and proud Marcianus any more to insult our fellowship. . . . Therefore send letters to the province and to the people of Aries, by which, Marcianus having been excommunicated, another shall be svibstituted in his place . . . for the whole copious body of bishops Is joined together by the glue of mutual concord and the bond of unity, in order that if any of our fellowship should attempt to make a heresy and to lacerate and devastate the fiock of Christ, the rest may give their aid. . . . For though we are many shepherds, yet we feed one flock." It seems incontestable that Cyprian is here explaining to the pope why he ventures to interfere, and that he attributes to the po[)e the power of deposing Marciaims and ordering a fresh election. We should compare his witness that Novatian usurped a similar power as antipope. Another letter dates perhaps somewhat later. It emanates from a council of thirty-seven bishops, and was obviously composed by Cyprian. It is addres.sed to the priest Felix and the people of Legio and Asturica, and to th(> deacon .'Julius and the people of Emerita, in Spain. It relates that the bi.shops Felix and SabiiuLs had come to Carthage to complain. They had been legitimately ordained by the bishops of the province in the place of the former bishops, Basilides and Martialis, who had both accepted libelli in the persecution. Basilides had further blasphemed God in sickness, had confessed his blasphemy, had voluntarily resigned his bishopric, and had been thankful to be allowed lay communion. Martialis had indulged in pagan banquets and had buried his sons in a pagan cemetery. He had publicly attested before tlie procurator ducenarius that he had denied Christ. Wherefore, says the letter, such men are unfit to be bishops, the whole Church and the late Pope Cornelius having decided that such men may be admitted to penance but never to ordination ; it does not profit them that they have deceived Pope Stephen, who was afar off and unaware of the facts, so that they obtained to be unjustly restored to their sees; nay, by this deceit they have only increased their guilt. The letter is thus a declaration that Stephen was wickedly deceived. No fault is imputed to him, nor is there any claim to reverse his decision or to deny his right to give it ; it is simply pointed out that it was founded on false information, and was therefore null. But it is obvious that the African council had heard only one”
3. Exiled to Curubis by Aspasius Paternus on 30 Aug. 257; tried and beheaded under Galerius Maximus at the Villa of Sextus on 14 Sept. 258; survey of authentic treatises, letters, doctrine, spuria, and editions (Hartel, C.S.E.L., III, 1868–1871). Pass 2 bibliography cited by John Chapman: Pontius, Vita Cypriani; Acta Proconsularia; Pearson, Annales Cyprianici (ed. Fell, 1682); Baluze-Maran (1726; P.L., IV–V); Hartel (1868–1871); Freppel (1865); Peters (1877); Fechtrup (1878); Ritschl (1885); Benson, Cyprian (1897); Monceaux, Hist. litt. de l'Afrique chrét., II (1902); Bardenhewer, II (1903); Harnack, Chronol., II; Watson, Studia Biblica, IV (1896); Bayard, Le Latin de Saint Cyprien (1902); Mercati (1899); von Soden (1904).
3. Exile to Curubis, martyrdom at Carthage (14 Sept. 258), writings, spuria, and bibliographyLines 98254–98644
Original passage
“side, whereas Felix and Sabinus must have pleaded their cause at Rome before they came to Africa. On this ground the Africans seem to have made too hasty a judgment. But nothing more is known of the matter. Martykdom. — The empire was surrounded by barbarian hordes who poured in on all sides. The danger was the signal for a renewal of persecution on the part of the Emperor Valerian. At Alexandria St. Dionysius was exiled. On .30 Aug., 257, Cyprian was brought before the Proconsul Paternus in his secreturium. His interrogatory is extant and forms the finst part of the "Acta proconsularia" of his martyrdom. Cyprian declares himself a Christian and a bishop. He serves one God to Whom he prays day and night for all men and for the safety of the emperors. "Do you per.severe in this?" asks Paternus. "A good wUl which knows C!od cannot be altered." "Can you, then, go into exile at Curubis?" "I go." He is asked for the names of the priests also, but replies that delation is forbidden by the laws; they will be found easily enough in their respective cities. On September he went to Curubis, accompanied by Pontius. The town was lonely, but Pontius tells us it was sunny and pleasant, and that there were plenty of visitors, while the citizens were full of kindness. He relates at length Cj'jirian's dream on his first night there, that he was in the proconsul's court and condemned to death, but was reprieved at his own request until the morrow. He awoke in terror, but once awake he awaited that morrow with calmness. It came to him on the very amiiversary of the dream. In Numidia the measures were more severe. Cyprian writes to nine bishops who were working in the mines, with half their hair .shorn, and with insufficient food and clothing. He was still rich and able to help them. Their replies are preserved, and we have also the authentic Acts of several African martyrs who suffered soon after Cyjirian. In August, 2.5.S, Cjiirian learned that Pope Sixtus had been put to deatli in the catacombs on the Cth of that month, together with four of his deacons, in consequence of a new edict that bishops, priests, and deacons should be at once i)ut to death; senators, knights, and others of rank ar<' to lose their goods, and, if they still persist, to die; matrons to be exiled; Ca'sarians (oflicers of the /i.s-cus) to become slaves, (ialerius Ma.xinuis, the succe.s.sor of Paternus, sent for (-'vprian back to ( 'arthage, and in his own gardens the bishop awaited the final senti'iice. Many great personages urged him to fiy, l)ut he had now no vision to recommend this course, and he desired above all to remain to exhort others. Yet he hid himself rather than obey the proconsul's summons to Utica, for he declared it was right for a bishop to die in his own city. On the return of Galerius to Carthage, Cyprian was brouglit from his gardens by two prinriprK in a chariot, but tlie proconsul was ill, and Cyprian passed the night in the hoase of the first priiiteps in tlic company of his friends. Of the rest we have a vague description by Pontius and a detailed report in the proconsular Acts. On the morning of the 14th a crowd gathered " at the villa of Sextus ' ', by order of the authorities. Cyprian was tried there. He refused to sacrifice, and added that in such a matter there was no room for thought of the consequences to hunself. The proconsul read his condemnation and the multitude cried, " Let us be beheaded with him! " He was taken into the grounds, to a hollow surrounded by trees, into which many of the people climbed. Cyprian took off his cloak, and knelt down and prayed. Then he took off his dalmatic and gave it to his deacons, and stood in his linen tunic in silence awaiting the executioner, to whom he ordered twenty-five gold pieces to be given. The brethren cast cloths and handkerchiefs before him to catch his blood. He bandaged his own eyes with the help of a priest and a deacon, both called Julius. So he suffered. For the rest of the day his body was expo.sed to satisfy the curiosity of the pagans. But at night the brethren bore him with candles and torches, with prayer and great triumph, to the cemetery of Macrobius Candidianus in the suburb of Mapalia. He was the first Bishop of Carthage to obtain the crown of martyrdom. Writings. — The correspondence of Cj'prian consists of eighty-one letters. Sixty-two of them are his own, three more are in the name of councils. From this large collection we get a vivid picture of his time. The first collection of his writings must have been made just before or just after his death, as it was known to Pontius. It consisted of ten treatises and seven letters on martyrdom. To these were added in Africa a set of letters on the baptismal question, and at Rome, it seems, the correspondence with Cornelius, except Ep. xlviii. Other letters were successively aggregated to these groups, including letters to Cyj)rian or cormected with him, his collections of Testimonies, and many spurious works. To the treatises already mentioned we have to add a well-known exposition of the Lord's Prayer; a work on the simplicity of dress proper to consecrated virgins (these are both founded on Tertullian); "On the Mortality", a beautiful pamphlet, composed on the occasion of the plague which reached Carthage in 252, when Cyprian, with wonderful energy, raised a staff of workers and a great fund of money for the nursing of the sick and the burial of the dead. Another work, "On Almsgiving", its Christian character, necessity, and satisfactory value, was perhaps written, as Watson has pointed out, in reply to the calumny that Cyprian's own laWsh gifts were bribes to attach men to his side. Only one of his writings is couched in a pungent strain, the "ad Demetrianmn", in which he replies m a spirited manner to the accusation of a heathen that Christianity had brought the plague upon the world. Two short works, "On Patience" and "On Rivalry and Envy", apparently WTitten during the baptismal controversy, were much read in ancient times. St. Cyprian was the first great Latin writer among the Christians, for Tertullian fell into heresy, and his style was harsh and unintelligible. Until the daysof Jerome and Augustine, Cyprian's wTitings had no rivals in the West. Their praise is sung by Prudentius, who joins with Pacian, Jerome, Augustine, and many others in attesting their extraordinary popularity. Doctrine. — The little that can be extracted from St. Cyprian on the Holy Trinity and the Incarnation is correct, judged by later standards. On bapti.snial regeneration, on the Real Presence, on the Sacrifice of the Mass, his faith is clearly and repeatedly exiinssed, especially in Ep. Ixiv on infant baptism, and in lOp. Ixiii on the mixed chalice, written against the sacrilegious custom of using water without wine for Mass. On penance he is clear, like all the ancients, that for those who have been separated from the Church by sin there is no return except by an hiunble confession {exoniologesis apud sacerdotes), followed by remissio facia per sacerdotes. The ordinary minister of this sacrament is the sacerdos par excellence, the bishop; but priests can administer it subject to him, and in case of necessity the lapsed might be restored by a deacon. He does not add, as we should at the present day, that in this case there is no sacrament ; such theological distinctions were not in his line. There was not even a beginning of canon law in the Western Church of the third century. In Cyprian's \-iew each bishop is answerable to God alone for his action, though he ought to take counsel of the clergy and of the laity also in all important matters. The Bishop of Carthage had a great position as honorary chief of all the bishops in the provinces of Proconsular Africa, Numidia, and Mauretania, who were about a hmidred in number; but he had no actual jurisdiction over them. They seem to have met in some numbers at Carthage every spring, but their coneiliar decisions had no real binding force. If a bishop should apostatize or become a heretic or fall into scandalous sin, he might be deposed by his comprovincials or by the pope. Cj'jirian probably thought that questions of heresy would always be too obvious to need much discission. It is certain that where internal discipline was concerned he considered that Rome should not interfere, and that uniformity was not desirable — a most unpractical notion. We have always to remember that his experience as a Cliristian was of short duration, that he became a bishop soon after he was converted, and that he had no Christian writings besides Holy Scripture to study but those of Tertullian. He evidently knew no Greek, and probably was not acquainted with the translation of Irenaeus. Rome is to him the centre of the Church's unity; it was inaccessible to heresy, which had been knocking at its doors for a century in vain. It was the See of Peter, who was the type of the bishop, the first of the Apostles. Difference of opinion between bishops as to the right occupant of the Sees of Aries or Emerita would not involve breach of communion, but rival bishops at Rome would divide the Church, and to communicate with the wTong one would be schism. It is controverted whether chastity was obligatory or only strongly m-ged upon priests in his day. The consecrated virgins were to him the flower of his flock, the jewels of the Church, amid the profligacy of paganism. Spuria. — A short treatise, "Quod Idola dii non sint", is printed in all editions as Cj-prian's. It is made up out of Tertullian and Minucius Felix. Its genuineness is accepted by Benson, Monceaux, and Bardenhewer, as it was anciently by Jerome and Augustine. It has been attributed by Haussleiter to Novatian, and is rejected by Harnack, Watson, and von Soden. "De Spectaculis" and "De bono pudiciti8e"are, with some probability, ascribed to Novatian. They are well-written letters of an absent bishop to his flock. "De Laude mart>Tii" is again attributed by Harnack to Novatian; but this is not generally accepted. "Adversus Juda^os" is perhaps by a Novatianist, and Harnack ascribes it to Novatian himself. "Ad Novatianum" is ascribed by Harnack to Pope Sixtus II. Ehrhard, Benson, Nelke, and Weynian agree with him that it was written in Rome. This is denied by Jiilicher, Bardenhewer, Monceaux. Rombold thinks it is by Cyprian. "De Rebaptismate" is apparently the work attributed by Gennadius to a Roman named TTrsinus, c. 400. He was followed by some earlier critics, Routh, Oudin, and lately by "Zahn. But it was almost certainly written during the baptismal controversy under Stephen. It comes from Rome (so Harnack and oiliois) or from Mauretania (so Ernst, Monceaux, '\ \lrs>, anil is ilirrctrd against the view of Cyprian. I lie little liotuily "!)(' Alcatoribus" has had quite a lihrature i)f its own within the last few years, since it \\ lis attributed by Ilarnack to Pope Victor, and therefi 'IT accounted the earliest Latm ecclesiastical WTiting. rill' controversy has at least made it clear that the author was either very early or not orthodox. It has !h lu shown to be improbable that he was very early, a 111 I Harnack now admits that the work is by an anti- I II i|ic. either Novatianist or Donatist. References to all tlie brochures and articles on the subject will be t iind in Ehrhartl, in Bardenliewer, and especially in Ilarnack (C'hronol., II, 370 sqq.). " l)e Montibus Sina et Sion" is possibly older than ( \'!>rian's time (see Harnack, and also Turner in Journal of Theol. Studies, July, 1906). " Ad Vigiliura Episcopum de Judaica incredulitate " is by a certain Celsus, and was once supposed by Harnack and Zahn to be addressed to the well-known Vigilius of Thapsus, but Macholz has now convinced Harnack that it dates from either the persecution of Valerian or that of Maxentias. The two " Orationes " are of uncertain date and authorship. The tract " De Singularitate clericorum ' ' has been attributed by Dom Morin and by Harnack to the Donatist Bishop Macrobius in the fourth century. " De duplici Martyrio ad Fortunatiun" is found in no MS., and was apparently written by Erasmus in 1530. "De Pascha computus" was written in the year preceding Easter, 243. All the above spuria are printed in Hartel's edition of Cyprian. The " Exhortatio de psenitentia" (first printed by Trombelli in 1751) is placed in the fourth or fifth century by Wunderer, but in Cyprian's time by Monceaux. Four letters are also given by Hartel; the first is the original commencement of the "Ad Donatum". The others are forgeries; the third, according to Mercati, is by a fourth-century Donatist. The six poems are by one author, of quite uncertain date. The amusing " Cena Cypriani" is foimd in a large number of Cyprianic MSS. Its date is uncertain; it was re-edited by Blessed Rhabanus Maiu-us. On the use of it at pageants in the early Middle Ages, see Mann, " History of the Popes", II, 289. The principal editions of the works of St. Cyprian are: Rome, 1471 (the ed. pri/iceps), dedicated to Paul II ; reprinted, Venice, 1471, and 1483; Memmingen, c. 1477; Deventer, c. 1477; Paris, 1500; ed. by Rembolt (Pari.s, 1512); by Erasmus (Ba.sle, 1520 and frequently; the ed. of 1544 was printed at Cologne). A careful critical edition was prepared by Latino Latini, and published by Manutius (Rome, 1563) ; Morel also went to the MSS. (Paris, 1564); so did Pamele (Antwerp, 15G8), but with less success; Rigault did somewhat better (Paris, 1648, etc.). John Fell, Bishop of 0.xford and Dean of Christ Church, published a weU- known edition from MSS. in England (Oxford, 1682). The dissertations by Dodwell and the " Annales Cyprianici ' ' by Pearson, who arranged the letters in chronological order, make this edition important, though the text is poor. The edition prepared by Etieime Baluze was brought out after his death by Dom Prudence Maran (Paris, 1726), and has been several times reprinted, especially by Mignr (P. L., IV and V). The best edition Ls that of the Vienna Academy (C. S. E. L., vol. Ill, in 3 parts, Vienna, 1868-71), edited from the MSS. by Hartel. Since then much work has been done upon the history of the text, and especially on the order of the letters and treatises as witnessing to the genealogj' of the codices. A stichometriral list, proKahlv made in 354, of the Books of the Bible, and of many work.>< of .SI. Cvprian, ^x^s published in J886 from a MS. (hen at Cheltenham bv Mommskn, Ziir Int. Slichomrlric; Hrrmes. XXl. U2: iftiVi. (18901. XXV, 636. on a second MS. at St. Gall. See Sanday and Tdrner in Sturlia Biblica (Oxford, 1891). Ill; Tirner in Claiiskal Revifw (1892, etc.), VI, 205. On Oxfonl MSS., see Wordsworth in Old Lai. Bibliait Texts (Oxford. 1886). 11, 123; on Madrid MSS, Schulz, Th. Lit. Zeitung (1897), p. 179. On other MSS., Tub.ner in Journal of Th. St., III. 282. 586. 579; Ramsay, ibid.. III. 585, IV, 86. On the significan.p of fl,p ,,r.lrr. (.'ii ipman, ibid.. IV, 103: VON SoDEN, /','.,, , :" '■ilnjifi (LeipziK, 190-1). Thereareiiiiii.il M i ^ n, Cate/ni miovi su.'isidi per l,i . ■ U..me, 1899). On the life of St. <'\ [IN Ml I < ' ' ypnunici. ed. Fell; Ada S.S'., 14 Sept.; lii.Triii.ii.i, Th. Crc. Cyprianus (Gottingen, 1831); Freppel, Saint Cyprien et VEglise d'Afrique (Paris, 1865. etc.); Peters, Der hi. Cypr. v. Karlh. (Ratisbon. 1877); Freppel and Peters occasionally exaggerate in the Catholic interest. Fecutrup, Der hi. Cypruui (Miinster. 1878); RiTsciiL, Cyprian v. K. und die Verja.-^.'sung dir Kirche (Gottingen. 1885); Benson, Cyprian, his life, /a.s timv.^, /ii.s work (London, 1897). (This is the fullest and best English life; it is full of enthusiasm, but marred by odium theologicum, and quite untrustworthy where controversial points arise, whether against Nonconformists or against Catholics.) Monceaux. Hist. lilt, de VAfrique chrU. (Paris, 1902), II. a valuable work. Of the accounts in histories, encyclopedias, and patrologies, the best is that of Bardenhewer. Gesch. der attkirehl. Lit. (Freiburg, 1903), II. Pearson's chronological order of the letters is given in Hartel's edition. Rectifications are proposed by RlTscHL, De Epistulis Cyprianicis (Halle. 1885), and Cyprian V. Karthago (Gottingen, 1885); by Nelke. Die Chronologie der Korresp. Cypr. (Thorn. 1902); by von Soden. op. cit.; by Benson and Monceaux. These views are discussed by Bardenhewer. loc. cit., and Harnack. ChronoL, II. Bonaccorsi. Le lettere di S. Cipriano in Riv. storico-crilica delle scienze teol. (Rome, 1905). I, 377; Stufler. Die Behandlung der Gefallenen zur Zeit der decischen Verfolgung in Zeitschrift fiir Kathol. Theol., 1907. XXXI. 577: Dwight, St. Cyvrianand thelibelli mnrtyrum in .4 mer. Cath. Qu. Rev. (1907). XXXII. 478. On the chronology of the baptismal controversy. d'Ales, La question baplismale au temps de Saint-Cyprien in Rev. des Questions Hist. (1907). p. 353. On Cyprian's Biblical text: Corssen. Zur Orientierung iiber die bisherige Erforsehung des Btbeltextes Cyprians in Jahresbericht liber die Forl.ichrilte drr klass. Allertumswiss. (1899); Sanday in Old Latin Bibl. T,x(« ilSS6), II; Turner in Joum. Theol. .St., II. 600, 610; Hkiih Mil i< ii. D,r nil. Text bei Cyprian (Bamberg, 1900); MoNrj:\i \, ny r,/ Corssen. Der cypr. Text der .Ada Ap. (Berlin, l.^l'j ; /mc, / ,,r,KcAuni7cn (Eriangen, 1891), IV. 79 (on Cyprian's te\i ,.f th.- .\poc.). A new edition (O.xford Univ. Pre^s) is expected of the Teslimonia by Sanday and Turner. Tentative prolegomena to it bv Turner in Journal Theological Studies (1905). VI. 246. and (1907). IX. 62. 'The work has been interpolalcd; see R \m.-*av. On early insertions in the third book of SI. r , , ' 7, ' in .L.urnal of Theol. 5(. (1901), II, 276. Testiiiii 111 in i o. Cyprian in H.'LRy.'^CK, Gesch. der altchn!/ I I. <; i ' , ,/,. der cyprianischenLileraturbiszuderZ''' ■ '' i: ■ '' '. <m Handschriflen (Basle, 1891). On the Latin of St. Cyprian an excellent essay by Watson, The Slyle and Language of St. Cyprian in Slud. Bibl. (Oxford. 1896), IV; Bayard. Le Latin de Saint Cyprien (Paris. 1902). The letters of Cornelius are in Vulgar Latin (see Mkrcati, op. <n/.), and so areEpp. viii (anonymous) anri xxi-xxiv (Celerinus, Lucian, Confes,sors. Caldonius); tliev have been edited by Miodonski, Adversus Alealores (Erlaiit-'cr, and LcipziR. I.SS9), On the interpolations in Z>p t'/M/;'. /'. ' . . !■ II M, H 1 , Prrfii I ; I'll \son, pp. 200-21. S47-.'-.,-i:' , rn:,. /, , , , /.n , ,'.,„., le Iraite de Saint CuP'" / ii /' l.^nidic- (inc (1902). XIX. L'le., :;:i., :ui.i i'.in:i,\\. jr,; l|..-.,,Kin Theol. Lilt. Zeilimg (1<H«), no. SI, and m Chronnl.. 11; \\ AT.SON in Journal Theol. St. (1904). p. 432; Chapman, ibid., p. 634, etc. On particular points see Harnack in Texte und Vnlersuch., IV. 3. 'VIII. 2; on the letters of the Roman clergy. Harnack in Theol. Abhandl. Carl r. W, i:x„rkcr gewidmet (Freiburg. 1896). On Cyprian's theology- murti has been written. Ritschl is fanciful and unsvnipatiicfn-. Hi:\son untrustworthy. GOtz. Das Chri.ttenlum Ci/iir:„ir< iCirs.sen. 1896). On his trust in visions, H\RN\rK. Ci/pniin '!ls l^nthusiast in Zeilschr. fiir nil. TI'i'-^.s-. (100 J I, 111. (7)///. ( »Ti the Iiaptismal controversy and Cyprian's cx.nt.iiitniiiiatiiiii, 1-vr 'iiiisin in Zeilschr. fur kalh. Theol. (l.Ssll. \; Hn],Nsnil..i.rii.i/,»/. ii,s91).XV; Ernst. itiV/.. XVII. XVIIl. XIX. Poschmann, Die Sichlbarkeit der Kirche nach der Lehre des h. Cypr. (Breslau. 1907) ; Riou. La genlae de I'uniie catholique et la pensee de Cyprien (Paris. 1907). To merely controversial works it is unnecessary to refer. The above is only a selection from an immense literature on Cyprian and the pseudo-Cyprianic writings, for wliich see Chevalier. Bio-Bibl., and Richardson. Bibtiographical Synop- 5i'^. Good lists in von Soden. and in Harnack. ChronoL, II; the very full references in Bardenhewer are conveniently classified. JoHN CHAPMAN.”
Found an error? Report a correction.
