Skip to content
Atlas of Saints

Decision case · Saint Teresa of Ávila

Standing Firm for Complete Poverty at Saint Joseph's in Ávila

Context

You learn that Mount Carmel’s original Primitive Rule forbids convents from owning fixed yearly income. In prayer, Christ assures you that Saint Joseph’s will never lack daily bread if founded in complete poverty. Nearly all cautious scholars warn that housing thirteen enclosed women without guaranteed income is reckless folly. After the convent opens on 24 August 1562, the city council threatens to break down the doors. They demand that you either disband or accept fixed income. How will you proceed?

Options

  • Follow the Primitive Rule, Christ’s word, and Saint Peter of Alcántara in poverty while obeying superiors and seeking a Papal Brief.
  • Drop the Primitive Rule’s poverty and accept wealthy endowments and parlor patrons to calm the city council.

Choice

Saint Teresa founded Saint Joseph’s Monastery in Ávila in complete gospel poverty without fixed yearly income. Throughout the six-month legal storm, she combined calm obedience to superiors with loyalty to the Primitive Carmelite Rule.

Consequence

In Chapters XXXV and XXXVI, Teresa stood firm alongside detached servants of God like Saint Peter of Alcántara. Father Domingo Báñez halted the city’s threat of force. Soon Teresa secured a Papal Brief approving poverty without income, filling her thirteen sisters with peace.

Virtues: Perseverance in Mental Prayer, Humility, Apostolic Poverty

Evidence