Skip to content
Atlas of Saints

Decision case · Saint Teresa of Ávila

Obeying the Church's Minister When Tested Over Visions

Context

Christ has appeared to you in clear inward visions that leave your soul peaceful, humble, and charitable. Yet when you open your soul to your confessor and his advisers, recent false mystics in Spain alarm them. Judging your visions a trap of the devil, they command you to cross yourself whenever Christ appears. Worse still, they order you to make a gesture of scorn ('making the fig'). How will you act when the Lord appears again?

Options

  • Obey your confessor humbly in God’s place—making the gesture while begging Christ’s pardon—and hide nothing.
  • Defy your confessor, hide future visions, and claim private revelations place you above Church authority.

Choice

Saint Teresa obeyed her confessor even when ordered to make a sign of scorn toward her visions. Complete honesty and humble obedience to Church ministers stand as the surest safeguard of mystical life.

Consequence

In Chapters XXVI and XXIX, Teresa obeyed that painful order while begging Christ’s pardon. She did so because the Church bade her obey God’s minister. Christ immediately blessed her obedience, promised to make the truth known, and turned her wooden rosary cross into heavenly jewels.

Virtues: Perseverance in Mental Prayer, Humility, Apostolic Poverty

Evidence