Skip to content
Atlas of Saints

Decision case · Saint Teresa of Ávila

Unmasking the False Humility That Quits Silent Prayer

Context

A distressed sister in your monastery comes to ask your counsel. Because she still falls into idle talk and distractions, she feels like a hypocrite during silent prayer. Silent mental prayer is quiet, friendly conversation with Christ. Calling her plan 'humility', she wants to quit silent prayer until she makes herself virtuous alone. Using Saint Teresa’s experience in Chapters VII and VIII, how will you keep her friendship with God open?

Options

  • Warn her that quitting silent prayer out of 'false humility' is a trap, and urge daily friendly prayer with Christ.
  • Approve her plan to give up silent mental prayer until she wipes out all her faults alone.

Choice

Saint Teresa unmasked quitting mental prayer out of felt unworthiness as 'false humility' stirred up by the devil. Every soul must keep up daily silent prayer as friendly conversation with God.

Consequence

Across Chapters VII and VIII, Teresa’s nineteen-year struggle proved that quitting prayer was her worst temptation. True humility welcomes God’s gifts knowing our weakness, whereas false humility flees the Light that heals us. Whoever keeps up daily silent prayer, however imperfectly at first, is drawn by God to safe harbor.

Virtues: Perseverance in Mental Prayer, Humility, Apostolic Poverty

Evidence