Decision case · Saint Ignatius of Loyola
Breaking the Grip of Scrupulosity at Manresa
Context
At Montserrat you made a careful, written general confession of your whole life over three days. Even so, for months at Manresa, obsessive doubts have haunted you that you left out some past sin. Near despair, you felt tempted to throw yourself through a large hole in your room. You stopped only after crying out that you would never offend God. Hoping for peace, you fasted from all food and drink for seven straight days, from Sunday to Sunday. On Sunday your confessor, the priest hearing your confession, ordered you to eat because your life was in danger. You obeyed him, yet on Tuesday the old anxious doubts returned during prayer, pushing you to dig up your past again. Searching old sins or fasting again risks collapse, while stopping requires deep trust in God's mercy. How will you respond to these returning doubts?
Options
- Recognize the returning doubts as a trap from the spiritual enemy. Firmly resolve never again to confess any sin from your past life.
- Search your memory once more for forgotten details of your past life and write out another general confession.
Choice
During prayer on Tuesday, God gave Ignatius light to see how these anxious thoughts attacked him point by point. Ignatius firmly resolved never again to confess anything from his past life. From that day forward, he remained completely free from scruples.
Consequence
Freedom from scruples prepared Ignatius for five great spiritual insights at Manresa. It also gave him lifelong skill in helping troubled souls, later recorded in the Rules on Scruples in the Spiritual Exercises.
Virtues: Obedience, Discernment, Humility
