Decision case · Saint Ignatius of Loyola
Choosing a Path of Penance and Parting from Loyola
Context
After the siege of Pamplona and painful leg surgeries, you spent months in bed at Loyola. Reading the Life of Christ and the Lives of the Saints changed your desires. A night vision of the Mother of God with the Child Jesus also turned your heart from courtly fame. You decided to walk as a pilgrim to Jerusalem and practice penance like St. Francis and St. Dominic. You sent a servant to Burgos to learn the Rule of the Carthusian Charterhouse at Seville, where monks eat only herbs. The report pleases you, yet you fear entering an enclosed monastery, or cloister, right after Jerusalem. A fixed cloister might limit the harsher fasts and pilgrim travels you want to undertake. Now you can walk again, and your older brother Martin Garcia suspects a radical change of life. Leading you from room to room, he begs you not to ruin your career or your family's hopes. Giving in would bring back worldly vanity, while rash words might make your family block your departure. How will you handle the Carthusian plan and part truthfully from your brother?
Options
- Put off any promise to join the Carthusian monastery, or cloister, until after your Jerusalem pilgrimage. Tell your brother truthfully that you are going to visit the Duke of Najera.
- Bind yourself at once to enter the Carthusian Convent of Seville as an unnamed lay brother eating only herbs.
- Give in to your older brother's pleas and return to military service under the Duke of Najera while praying privately.
Choice
Ignatius put off the question of joining the Carthusian Order until after his pilgrimage. He did not want a monastery cloister to limit his penances beforehand. He also answered his brother truthfully that he ought to visit the Duke of Najera, who knew of his recovery.
Consequence
His brother let him leave in peace. Ignatius rode to Najera and went straight on to Montserrat and Manresa to begin his pilgrim life.
Virtues: Discernment, Prudence, Fortitude
