Decision case · Saint Ignatius of Loyola
Governing Zealous Scholastics at the College of Coimbra
Context
In May 1547, news reaches you in Rome from the thriving Jesuit College of Coimbra in Portugal. The young Jesuit students, called scholastics, burn with intense zeal for bodily penance. They keep harsh fasts, long night watches, and public humiliations. Their devotion inspires the city, yet several students are wearing out their bodies. They can barely keep up with university lectures and risk lasting illness before becoming priests for the missions. Crushing their zeal might make them lukewarm, while unchecked penances feed stubbornness and ruin their health. How will you guide the Coimbra students on penance, study, and obedience?
Options
- Praise their zeal and urge them forward in virtue and study. At the same time, place bodily penances under strict obedience and good sense so they stay healthy to serve others.
- Encourage every student to add still more fasts and night watches according to his own private devotion without limit.
- Order the students to stop all prayer and penance until they finish their university degrees.
Choice
In Letter XXIV (7 May 1547), Ignatius warmly praised the Coimbra students' desire for holiness. Drawing on St. Bernard, he warned that extreme penance ruins health, blocks study, and hides self-will. He ordered them to keep a wise middle path under obedience to their superiors.
Consequence
Ignatius's letter to Coimbra became the classic Jesuit rule for uniting serious study with moderate penance and obedience.
Virtues: Obedience, Prudence, Discernment
